A rock performance can be memorable by sheer entertainment and talent but also because of controversy surrounding it. Here is my take on ten (maybe even the top ten) rock performances of all time. I know my list is very classic rock orientated so I am eager to see what other users would add from different genres. Maybe even share performances you’ve seen first hand!
The Who rose to fame with a pioneering instrument destruction stage show. One infamous performance occurred on television in 1967. The drummer, Keith Moon, overloaded his bass drum with explosives which were detonated during the finale of “My Generation.” As a result, guest Bette Davsis fainted, guitarist Pete Townshend’s hair was set on fire, and there is a legend that he received permanent damage to his hearing.
At this point in time, The Doors had already earned a reputation as a rebellious live act and Jim Morrison was a popular sex symbol. The band was approached by CBS reps before their live performance on the “Ed Sullivan Show.” The censors demanded that Morrison change the lyrics to the song from “Girl, we couldn’t get much higher” to “Girl, we couldn’t get much better.” The band agreed but Morrison sang the original line on live television with no delay. Ed Sullivan was furious and refused to shake the band members’ hands while also stating they would never be invited on the show again. Morrison’s reply? “So what. We just did the ‘Ed Sullivan Show’”
Called “The Gig That Changed the World” because it inspired a generation to make their own music and arguably change the world with the power of punk. The Sex Pistols emerged as a response to what was perceived to be the “increasingly safe and bloated” progressive rock and manufactured pop music of the mid-1970s. The gig is shrouded in myth and legend because only 42 people were in attendance but hundreds claim that they were there. But the people who were there formed legendary bands such as Joy Division, The Smiths, The Fall, and The Buzzcocks.
This show is so memorable in big part because it was one of the last televised performances by Kurt Cobain. It was recorded five months prior to his death in 1994. The set list consisted of several covers and lesser known originals; the only hit they played was “Come As You Are.” Many critics hailed the band’s performance because of their display that they could transcend the grunge stereotype which made them famous. This song’s performance is so eerie because of Cobain’s suicide and the lyrics in the song which seem to stem from the pain the singer was experiencing.
The Altamont Free Concert was headlined and organized by the Rolling Stones and featured other acts such as: Santana, Jefferson Airplane, and Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young. During the Rolling Stone’s performance of “Sympathy For The Devil,” a young man named Meredith Hunter was stabbed and beaten to death by the Hell’s Angels. They were hired by the band to handle security for a mere $500 and free beer. Various news agencies reported the event as a “drug induced riot” and the Stones continued while Hunter was attacked in order to prevent a possible riot. Many critics called this event the “Death of Woodstock Nation.”
Pink Floyd was, and still is, one of rock music’s most successful acts. They are very well-known for their elaborate live shows which brought psychedelia to the UK in the 1960’s. They were the first band to incorporate light shows and photo effects into their live performances, creating a precedent which still cannot be matched to this day. This tour celebrated the release of their album “The Wall,” which eventually was certified 23x platinum. What made this tour so special was that there were only 31 shows in 4 cities in 1980 and 1981. Many consider this tour to be one of the most celebrated stage shows in rock history.
Despite there being several famous acts playing at the festival, Hendrix was considered to be the festival’s main attraction as the headliner. His two-hour long set (the longest of his career) was cursed with technical difficulties ranging from microphone troubles to a snapped guitar string during the performance of the song “Red House.” Even with all the problems, Hendrix delivered a historical performance with his solo improvisation of the “Star Spangled Banner,” which was played loudly and sharply with stimulated sounds of war from his guitar. Some viewed his rendition as anti-American while others felt it was Hendrix’s statement about the unrest in U.S. society. Whatever his reasoning may be, this act became a defining moment of the 60s.
Freddie Mercury will always be one of the best and most charismatic live performers in rock history. His upbeat and commanding presence is unmatchable. The band is noted for its musical diversity, multi-layered arrangements, vocal harmonies and incorporation of audience participation into their live performances. This medley was performed in front of an audience of 75,000 people for the annual Live Aid festival at Wembley Stadium. A poll taken by the BBC in 2005 named this as the top live performance of all time. Watching Freddie Mercury get the entire audience to clap in unison is mesmerizing.
At the beginning of his career, Elvis’ performances were badly received by both critics and guests (mostly an older, more conservative audience). The controversy would soon get worse after this June 5th presentation of “Hound Dog.” Elvis performed without his guitar and stirred the audience with his vigorous leg shaking and hip thrusts. Forty million people tuned in and the critics were relentless the next day. Elvis was linked with juvenile delinquency and deemed “a no-talent performer.” Others said the dancing was “vulgar” and “obscene” because of its strong sexual connotations. Elvis would later be filmed only from the waist up on the “Ed Sullivan Show” a few months later. Despite the controversy, Elvis quickly became a sex symbol and Rock ‘n Roll genius which would propel him to “The King” status he still holds to this day.
Some say that during the Beatles first American debut on the Ed Sullivan Show, normal activities in America came to a standstill watching their performance. Still reeling in shock at the assassination of President Kennedy a few months prior, Americans were overjoyed by the atmosphere created when the four guys from Liverpool came on their black-and-white televisions. Before this program, Beatlemania had already swept Europe and the band was weary if they would be able to make it in America. This performance sealed the deal for the quartet and lead to a simultaneous transformation of rock music and youth culture. Sullivan received the biggest ratings of his career and this performance was one of the most watched programs in the history of television.
Contributor: deedee0323



















nirvana higher please
always did love that queen performance, id go #1
johnny cash?
deedee you should do another 10 memorable performance list. i bet your going to get oh about 500 suggestions on this list alone!
heres 1, neil young and pearl jam doing Rockin in the free world, maybe it was at MTV’s VMA awards? my first exposure to neil and i thought it was cool
nirvana is on this list? Man, Cobain blowing his brains out was the best thing that ever happened to the foo fighters
Really well done! I was hoping Hendrix doing the Star Spangled Banner would be on here, as well as Nirvana.
Love the list, would have put Nirvana higher, also would have put in any KISS concert, those concerts were *****in’.
“there is a legend that Moon’s received permanent damage to his hearing”
Pete Townshend suffered permanent hearing damage from this incident.
Good list. wow I have nothing useful to add but I had to post never been this high on a list before. sweet
iBored- ‘slap’
check out ll cool j doing mama said knock you out unplugged. it was great, but i think his VMA performance of it might have been better, the one where he was in boxer outfit, but i cant find it at youtub
The look on Tom Smothers face at the end is priceless. I could watch that clip over and over again. Awesome list!
iBored- Idiot! Idiot idiot idiot! Jurt Cobain was one of the most influential “Grunge” artists of all time! The music business would be ten times better than it is right now if hadn’t comitted suicide! Tsk tsk!
Kurt*
Was Jurt Curt’s brother
I’d add Dylan’s 1966 performance at the Royal Albert Concert Hall.
come on guys, jurt sucked.. he just wanted some attention… all of his songs sounded like he just threw them together on the spot. Nirvana is not real music
No matter your opinion on their music, you cannot argue that Nirvana was influential.
yes, and that influence was “build more homeless shelters”
Nirvana has there spot in music history. But all honestly everyone, look at the grunge genre now…standing 10 count. Kurt is highly overrated, and since he died he has become a god. I honestly think he has been givin far too much credit. When i started playing guitar i was able to learn any nirvana song i wanted. All power chords really, and his vocals are the same in every song. I give credit to him for sparking the beginning of a genre fad. But it died out quickly…kinda like him.
Great list! I would have liked to see some Led Zeppelin. Maybe Mountain at Woodstock? I agree with #1 though, great list.
Nirvana shouldn’t be on this list.
great list. i think you made wonderful choices. i couln’t have made a better list.
Tony: Everyone’s first song is either “Come As You Are” “Smells Like Teen Spirit” or “Smoke On The Water”
Nice list, but I would put Queen’s preformance at number 1.
Phender-Your right man, but theres a reason for that. And out of those 3 songs, smoke on the water would be the most difficult. All im saying is if thats your type of music…fine. But dont give a massive amount of credit where its not due. Everyone says nirvana changed rock music, and i do not believe this. They contributed something to rock that did not last or stand up to the mainstream media. They have achieved a huge following DUE to his death. I like nirvana dont get me wrong, but i do not look at that band as a major historical rock influence.
I hate this list. It reads like it was compiled by someone from Rolling Stone. There are so many great live bands out there, and a list is made about the ten most heard-of bands in the world. Totally predictable. Oh great. You want something new you say? Oh no! We can’t have that!
Sadly, when Kurt Cobain died, the last truly creative period of music died with him.
gwar should be on there
To DeeDee0323:
You could not have found more “Memorable Rock Performances”, as far as I’m concerned. I could have added many that I personally attended (at ‘My Father’s Place’, Filmore East, Salvation, etc) but few others would have ever remembered those performances
.
From this list, I remember #10, #9 and #1 when they occured, and #6 and #4 as they were made public.
I saw Jimi Hendrix in New York sometime soon after Woodstock at The Salvation. A small venue where you got really close to some top artists.
Thank you for this list. Job well done.
WOW! This is awesome! I can think of a few others though… Janis Joplin at Monterey Pop (I think that’s where Jimi Hendrix debuted too), Gram Parsons at Altamont, Bob Dylan’s Rolling Thunder Revue (and when he went electric!)… Hmm… Maybe I’ll have to find time to do a Volume 2 to this list
anon – You’re right, my bad
JFrater – Can you edit this for me to say Townshend received hearing damage? Thanks!
Hendrix, Joplin, or The Who all had more memorable and influential performances at The Monteray Pop Festival, which pre-dated Woodstock. In fact, there would never have been Woodstock if Monteray had not happened.
deedee0323: done
Also, to people who equate ‘difficult to perform as superior’ are wrong-headed. I know many hacks that can recreate a drawing or a musical performance but can’t CREATE anything.
Just because you can REcreate Kurt Cobain’s guitar riffs means absolutely nothing. Go CREATE something and you will see that it’s not so easy.
‘Sadly, when Kurt Cobain died, the last truly creative period of music died with him.’
Yeah… No.
“Before this program, Beatlemania had already swept Europe and the band was weary if they would be able to make it in America.”
Shouldn’t that be wary?
First to spot it
Neat list. I was 13 when Live Aid happened and watched all of it live on MTV, having received permission from my parents to stay up all night. Having grown up with older siblings, I knew and liked Queen but my big act of the day was Duran Duran, who ended up putting on a forgettable performance with a major vocal malfunction, but what I remember is being utterly mesmerized by Freddie Mercury that day.
It still took me a while when I started going to shows to know that I was probably never going to see something like that again. I agree that #1 and #2 are more significant, but that Queen performance, on that day, is really something special.
hey romerozombie
why dont you create a list of the top 10 recent live rock performances and submit it.
and theres a reason these are the most heard of bands, like um ,idk, greatness?
666:
True that Monterey was probably more influential than Woodstock, ushering in ‘the summer of Love’ as it did, but the title of this list is “…Memorable…”, and I suspect more people remember Woodstock, either because they were there, or there was simply less acid floating around Bethel two years later.
Or perhaps it was the movie.
What about the Monterey Pop Festival?
Absolutely love and agree with the top three! Though oddly enough Led Zeppelin is excluded from this list. Hmmm… Enough said.
Excelent Excelent list
Great list. Regarding Altamont, another of the multitude of reasons to hate the Grateful Dead is that they actually recruited the Hell’s Angels to provide security.
Take Nirvana’s Unplugged off the list and insert Eric Clapton’s Unplugged performance. Much, much, much, much better in every way.
Excellent list, although it could use some led zeppelin.
I probably wouldn’t have gone with “Another Brick in the Wall, Part II”. I’d gone with “Comfortably Numb” from that tour or Syd-era “Astronomy Domine” or “Interstellar Overdrive”.
Where Did You Sleep Last Night was a better performance than All Apologies on that Unplugged set. Any of you that are dissing Nirvana… can you dispute the fact that they paved the way for alot of the rock music we hear now?
I saw Pink Floyd at Rice Stadium in Houston,TX. That show was incredible, but unfortunately it had to be cut short due to the ran. So for the trip home, the radio station played Comfortably Numb, but it just wasn’t the same.
For the most part, good list. Although I’d place Nirvana higher and choose a different song for them. And I also nominate Metallica’s S&M performance as well.
ran = rain. my bad
The Altamont stabbing actually occurred during “Under My Thumb,” but most people think it happened during “Sympathy” or “Gimme Shelter”.
or possibly something from the White Stripes. “Jolene”, anyone? Or “Seven Nation Army”.
Live Aid was annual?
iBored – I agree to an extent. It wasn’t so much that created something new as much as they destroyed what came before. Prior to Nirvana’s explosion onto the scene music was dominated by Hairbands, Michael Jackson and a weird kind of white bread rap personified by MC Hammer and Vanilla Ice.
Nirvana made all of these acts seem silly by comparison. 80′s music died over night thanks to Nirvana.
But you are right iBored, as big as Nirvana was their influence was not lasting. Would the music scene be different if Cobain had not died? It’s impossible to say.
Nirvana is amazing. I’m glad it’s on the list.
musical creativity did not die at all.
perhaps who ever said that is looking in the wrong places. i really don’t think that vh1 is playing all of the good music.
i listen to tons of creative music made after 1994.
and the whole nirvana debate… yeah they are pretty important.
they still inspire kids to write music and learn instruments.
and that performance belongs on this list. it is extremely memorable and i’m sure everyone who got to see it will forever be talking about to impress people at parties.
i don’t know if they completely “paved the way” as if todays music wouldn’t exist without them, but you can’t say that they weren’t/aren’t important.
Bad News: While it’s true that the Angels did some security for the Grateful Dead and it is said that the Dead introduced the Angels to the Stones, there was never any indication that they were a part of any agreement that the Hells Angels may have had.
The Stones road manager brought them in, not The Dead.
Oh, and by the way, Mr. Hunter was attacked only after he pulled a hand gun and pointed it at the stage. The Angel responsible for stabbing him was aquitted for self defense. That doesn’t make them nice guys, but to a some accounts they were just doing their job.
I would say that the stones, led zeppelin and the who should be put at 1, 2, and 3.
The Beatles always come out on top.
I like to tease my Nirvana loving sister and saying that all Cobain did was whine incoherently into a microphone
But in all seriousness, I don’t particularly like Nirvana, but I can’t deny they were influential. Even if today it can be hard to see their influence (as least for me) there are a lot of young musicians out there who grew up with Nirvana. I imagine there is more Nirvana in modern music than I think.
Overall, the list is very good! Fascinating idea for a list, and very well put together. Someone mentioned Janis Joplin, who I would have liked to see as well. Not sure I’d call her WS performance one of the top 10 most memorable though.
How in the hell can Johnny Cash at San Quinten(sp?) NOT be included. That is like a must have for any list of this kind. Also, to a lesser extent, Metallica S&M was an awesome event.
this is one of the best lists on this site in my opinion
great job
I was just watching the Who’s performance of “My Generation” earlier today. Interesting list.