Following on from our previous two lists of disappearances, Top 10 Bizarre Disappearances, and Top 10 Notable People Who Disappeared, we are now presenting another list of mysterious or bizarre disappearances. These lists are always intriguing as nothing adds to the spice of life more than a good mystery.
Joe Crater was a judge from New York City who disappeared one evening in 1930. He had been vacationing with his wife in Maine, when he got a mysterious phone call. He told his wife he had to go back to New York for business, but would be back in a few days. On the evening of August 6, he went to a restaurant with his mistress and some friends, who watched him get into a taxi after dinner. What happened after that remains a mystery. However, he was not reported missing until September 3, almost a month later. His mistress, a showgirl named Sally Lou Ritz, also disappeared that September.
On the evening of November 8, 1974, Lady Veronica Lucan (wife of Richard, 7th Earl of Lucan) ran into a local pub, covered in blood and screaming that her husband had tried to kill her. When the police went to the Lucan home, they found the children’s nanny, Sandra Rivett, dead of head trauma in the basement and a bloodstained length of lead pipe. That night, several phone calls to friends were made by a very agitated Lord Lucan, who stated he had been at the house, but had interrupted the real attacker. A few days later, Lord Lucan’s Ford Corsair was discovered in Newhaven. There were bloodstains in the car and a pipe matching the one found at the scene, but Lord Lucan was nowhere to be found. If he is still alive, he would be 74 years old.
The daughter of a wealthy perfume importer went shopping for a new dress in New York on December 12, 1910. She visited several stores and those who saw her said she seemed to be in a good mood. Her well-to-do family suspected she may have run away with her boyfriend, but when confronted, he claimed to have no idea what happened to her. The last person to see her on the street said she had planned to walk through Central Park, but she never made it home. It took her family six weeks to notify the police of her disappearance.
Benjamin Briggs was the center of one of the most significant maritime mysteries of all time – the disappearance of the members of the Mary Celeste in 1871. Briggs was the captain of the ship when it was found inexplicably abandoned in the Atlantic Ocean. Briggs, his wife, two year old daughter, and the remainder of the crew were never found. Briggs has been referred to frequently in fiction and in conspiracy theories surrounding the old mystery.
Many mysteries surround Etta Place, girlfriend of the notorious Harry Longabaugh aka The Sundance Kid. No one is even sure what her real name was, but she most likely met the Wild Bunch while working as a prostitute. She accompanied Butch Cassidy and Sundance to Argentina, and became the first woman landowner in that country under a new law enacted in 1884. She was last known to have been in San Francisco when she tried to obtain a copy of Longabaugh’s death certificate in order to settle his estate. After that, it is believed that she changed her name and may have returned to prostitution.
Hunter S. Thompson immortalized his friend in his novel “Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas”, Acosta was the basis for Dr. Gonzo, the Samoan attorney. In May 1974, Marco Acosta, spoke with his father by telephone before he boarded a boat “full of white snow” in Mexico. Although they never found the body, the family believes that he was most likely the victim of violence by the people he was traveling with.
Thompson was a businessman who revitalized the Thai silk industry by inventing color-fast dyes and bringing modern weaving equipment to Bangkok. He kept his business cottage-based which allowed his weavers to make money while staying home with their children. On Easter Sunday, 1967, he left his home to go for a walk and was never heard from again. The mystery surrounding his disappearance eventually spawned a book.
“Honest Dick” Tate was the Treasurer of Kentucky who vanished in 1888, along with about $250,000 that belonged to the state! He had a sterling reputation until the gubernatorial race of 1887, when candidate William O. Bradley (pictured above) brought up the need to audit the treasury. Tate said he needed a little time to get the books in order. Instead, he headed to Louisville where he boarded a train. Years later, his daughter admitted to having received letters from him postmarked from Canada, Japan, China, and San Francisco. The last communication from him was in 1890.
Jean Spangler was a bit-part actress in Hollywood. She left her young daughter in the care of her sister-in-law on October 7, 1949. She said she was going to meet her ex-husband to talk about an overdue child support payment and later, to work at a movie set. Two days later, her purse was found near the entrance of Griffith Park. It contained an unfinished note addressed to a “Kirk,” which read, “Can’t wait any longer, Going to see Dr. Scott. It will work best this way while mother is away,”. No one knew who “Kirk” or “Dr. Scott” was, and no body was ever found.
In the 1930′s there were still sections of the American Southwest largely unexplored. Everett Ruess became one of the first non-Native Americans to see these places and document them, as an artist and a writer. He was a contemporary of Dorothea Lange and Ansel Adams, and was well-known for his love of nature and solitude. One day, he ventured out into the Utah desert with two burros and never returned, leaving behind only the corral he built. He was only 20 years old. Update: this is certainly a first for Listverse! The body of Everett Ruess has been found and his cause of death was murder by Navajo Indians. A full report on the discovery is here.
Contributor: Nicosia





























No Harold Holt?
i love listverse, been following it daily for more than a year. Somehow i just feel like i like the old lists better. This one is alright, but i guess not in my area of interest?
wow,there are so many people who have disappeared, i have only heard of lord lucan on this list. I wonder if they actually dies or whether they ran away and lived happily ever after!?!?!?
Dissipated guns on the list, g – I’d sell my original pressing of Bathory’s ‘Blood Fire Death’ LP if some sucker MC could let loose where I put my caboose last nite yo
This is a good list; I’ve only been folowing this site for a few months; I’m not sure what people mean by “old lists”, does “ListVerse” have an Old List and New List, much like the Old Testament and New Testament of the Bible….
Love this type of list. Makes you wonder if someone, friend-relative, now reads about these people and might know their final disposition.
i love lists like this
keep’em coming:D
I can not believe you did not put Jimmy Hoffa, he has got to be the most famous disappearance case of all time.
Harold was on another list somewhere…
Plus I don’t know if the contributor knows of him.
Nice list.
i remember when tom hanks dissapered but then he came back.
they never found the volleyball though….
jfrater-
i have a general list idea: could you post the contributor’s name at the end of the list’s introductory blurb (or maybe after the title, even?) as well as at the end of the list (before the comments start)?
i find myself scrolling to the end/contributor spot before i even read the lists now, so that if the list itself references “my other lists” “from my other comments” etc. i won’t be as confused. i still sometimes slip-up and miss the contributer (and then find myself open to calls of “rookie mistake!” in the comments. -i have no hard feelings about that, it was my mistake, rookie or not.)
just a thought. i’ll take time to find a more direct way to send it to you tomorrow, if need be.
now i’m scrolling up to read the real list.
cheers
Hadn’t heard of ANY of these – shows how ignorant I am I suppose
A really fine list. You can Google Everett Ruess and get a lot of info about him.
I think that Judge Crater ran off with his mistress.
Jimmy Hoffa was covered in a previous list.
Idve though walter collins would be in this, especially in light of angelina jolie’s movie “changeling.” Read up about it. its darn interesting. better yet, watch the movie.
Maddo, EsBravo – Both Jimmy Hoffa and Harold Holt are on the 10 Notable People Who Disappeared list, the link is in the intro
I’ve seen “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” and if Etta Place was anywhere near as hot as Katherine Ross…….ROWRRRR!!!
Sorry, I just don’t see most of these as “bizarre disappearances”. They seem completely natural to me, most are easily explained and few distinguish themselves from any other missing persons case. Perhaps this should have been Another 10 Notable People Who Disappeared, but “bizarre” is just not accurate in any sense of the word.
i totally agree’, i would say bizarre disappearences would be more eerie, like they disappeared infront of someone, most of these seem like if you really do some good detective work youll find they were murdered or ran off to live life somewhere else.
Great list.
“It contained an unfinished note addressed to a “Kirk,” which read, “Can’t wait any longer, Going to see Dr. Scott.” – Jean Spangler
Has to be the earliest known Star Trek reference ever. So early (before the show was even on air) it adds to the mystery……
Intriguing list, Nicosia. And very well written too.
Shouldn’t Osama Bin Laden also be on these lists, or has he already been covered?
I’m sure everyone spotted Ms. Spangler’s cleavage.
I will be the first one however to go wooowzaaaaa!
Ehmm.. anyway.. nice tits.. I mean list..
good list, but i agree with frank, a lot of these arent bizarre
I don’t now if is especially bizarre, but the disappering of Madeline McCann is also one of those unsolved mysterie things….
Dr. Scott, eh? Jean Spangler is probably in Transylvania with Frank-n-Furter then.
willy- Wilson went for a swim and never came back.
Jean Spangler….I’ve been reading about her mysterious disappearance as it relates to a connection with the Black Dahlia. It is believed that the Dr. Scott that is referred to has something to do with a ring of abortionist doctors. I could go on, but…
Great list! I love these types of lists. Keep them coming.
Absolutely love the mystery and bizarre lists. I’ve never heard of the Lord Lucan one before. I’ll have to read up on that one.
Not much of a mystery for most of these “disapperances”. Man killed wife and ran away. Man stole money and ran away. Prostitute changed her name and ran away. Etc.,etc.,etc. Good try though.
i usually love these sorts of lists, but it kind of feels like there wasn’t enough information on most of them. i had to re-read number 5 before i understood what was written. sorry but i miss jfraters lists!
Hi guys! I almost mentioned Hoffa, but he has been discussed ad nauseum and I learned about Holt on this very site, so I didn’t include them. Char, to paraphrase- Acosta told his son he was getting on a boat with drug dealers. Jamie- would you care to fix my punctuation misplacement on that one? I was editing it at midnight while sleepy
Thanks for a great list! Gives me lots to Google!
ronsantohof- aww yes i always get teary eyed during that scene, there is nothing more heart breaking than losing your vollyball smeared in your on blood.
Cool list. I visited Jim Thompson’s house in Bangkok two days ago, and the tour guide said he disappeared while on vacation in the Malaysian mountains. The leading theory was that he was eaten by a tiger while on a jungle stoll. Then she talked about his involvement in the OSS and CIA…
I’ve heard of Briggs and the Marie Celeste, and I do recall hearing about the Lord Lucan business. Judge Crater used to be the poster boy for missing persons before Jimmy Hoffa assumed that mantle. One might imagine that Crater, Tate, possibly Arnold as well, packed up their tents and stole away in the night — off to greener pastures. (Then again, judges do turn up missing for other reasons, especially if they’re sitting on cases of racketeering or corruption.) Ruess, Spangler, Thompson and Acosta, I suspect met with misadventure or foul play. Briggs remains the strangest of these cases. My understanding was his boat wasn’t just found in the Atlantic Ocean, but in the Mediterranean — having come under full sail through the Strait of Gibraltar with no one at the helm.
Still, nobody beats Benjamin Bathurst for outright weirdness. (He’s on the Top 10 Bizarre Disappearances list.) Harlan Ellison turned him into the short-lived plaything of a sadistic little girl in the far future in “A Toy for Juliette.”
2007 Mets
How about Ambrose Bierce? Writer of strange fiction and stranger non-fiction in the late nineteenth century. Sometimes wrote about bizaare dissappearances. Bizaarely disappeared himself.
bizarre!
Interesting list. Like the comment about RHPS…Frank-N-Furter beamed her back to Tran*****ual! ha!
what about margaret thatcher where did she go?
Nicosia, I´m sure you´ll find this fascinating:
http://strangetrue.blogspot.com/2005/05/psi-captured-on-eeg-research-of-jacobo.html
RE: Jajdude @ 4- We MUST have a list of jajdude’s greatest/most incomprehensible/ most hilarious comments.
@ 34 Bucslim- Hilarious!
JIMMY HOFFA!!!!!
Jean Spangler is strikingly pretty
What about MICHEAL ROCKIFELLER and JIMMY HOFFA they to disapeared with any clue to what happened to them
Since number 5 admittedly got onto a boat with a bunch of drug dealers, it hardly seems like a mystery what happened to him…glug glug glug. Interesting list, though
Nice List. I like the 1st mysterious disappearances list better! I wish there was more information regarding the investigations and theories the authorities may have had.
I love these lists… never knew Dr Gonzo disappeared, but I guess he was just too weird to live.
To everyone who is whining about Jimmy Hoffa not being on this list – why not read up on the other two lists linked in the introduction? Morons.
Damn, Jean Spangler is hot. I would of never knew about her if it wasn’t for this list. Thank you listverse!
I remember Oscar Zeta Ocosta. Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is one of my favorite movies and Benico Del Toro did a good job of portraying him. Apparently he was a Mexican lawyer with a bad temper who liked to defend a lot of dangerous clients, so it’s no wonder he possibly ended up as a victim of foul play.
Nice list.
Mystery disappearances never cease to be compelling. : )
JIMMY HOFFA WAS ON ANOTHER LIST!!!
Holy crap!
Anywho very interesting list…
it will give some stuff to look into!
thanks:)
Why isn’t my mind on this list?
I don’t know what it is about these disappearance lists, but they fascinate me. I think that some could always be chalked up to abduction or even retribution or something along those lines. Instances where a person really is just… gone. That fascinates me.
Bucslim: I now despise you. Even though it did make me laugh. Just waiting for 3 years in a row now.
Now THIS is an interesting list
I am sure Tex was involved in something very boring that this list caught his eye…
I am sure thousands and thousands of people are missing every day and night..and unless and untill some bizarre incident is not involved such as aliens, supernatural blah blah…it will not be interesting at all….
So i agree with some of the others that none of these disappearances are bizzare, though they are notable and intriguing and i did enjoy reading about them.
Jean Spangler has manly arms.
other than that, a good list.
What don’t people understand about “ANOTHER 10 Bizarre Disappearances”?! ANOTHER!!!
why are these bizarre? simply because they haven’t been found? I mean… is a known drug fiend boarding on a boat full of cocaine in Mexico and never coming back really a bizarre disappearance? a bunch of these guys/girls are running from the law because they stole stuff or murdered someone…that’s not bizarre, it happens all the time!
Bizarre would be someone disappearing from a plane while it’s in flight or someone walking into a windowless room and not coming out…anyways, that’s my two cents…entertaining list regardless
why are these bizarre? simply because they haven’t been found? I mean… is a known drug fiend boarding a boat full of cocaine in Mexico and never coming back really a bizarre disappearance? a bunch of these guys/girls are running from the law because they stole stuff or murdered someone…that’s not bizarre, it happens all the time!
Bizarre would be someone disappearing from a plane while it’s in flight or someone walking into a windowless room and not coming out…anyways, that’s my two cents…entertaining list regardless