The Medal of Honor is the highest military decoration awarded by the United States government. It is bestowed on a member of the United States armed forces who distinguishes himself “conspicuously by gallantry and intrepidity at the risk of his life above and beyond the call of duty while engaged in an action against an enemy of the United States.” Because of the nature of its criteria, the medal is often awarded posthumously.
In one of the most awe-inspiring displays of reckless bravery WWII has to offer the history books, Cmdr. Evans, three-fourths Cherokee from Oklahoma, led his destroyer, the USS Johnston, straight into the face of a gargantuan Japanese naval fleet, on 25 October 1944, off Samar Island, in the Battle of Leyte Gulf.
He was part of a very small fleet designed to support the marines currently assaulting Leyte. This fleet had 3 destroyers, very small ships, 4 destroyer escorts, even smaller, and 6 escort carriers, with only about 30 planes each. The fleet was not expecting a naval engagement because Adm. Halsey’s much larger fleet was supposed to be guarding the north flank. Halsey, however, had gone after another Japanese fleet and left the flank open.
Down came another Japanese fleet intent on destroying the marines on Leyte. Task Unit 77.4.3 (Taffy 3) initially tried to flee the area when confronted by such massive force. Evans, however, refused to yield to the enemy. As soon as the Johnston sighted the enemy, Evans came over the intercom, “A large Japanese fleet has been contacted. They are fifteen miles away and headed in our direction. They are believed to have four battleships, eight cruisers, and a number of destroyers. This will be a fight against overwhelming odds from which survival cannot be expected. We will do what damage we can.”
He ordered the Johnston to come about and attack at flank speed, charging the entire fleet alone. When Adm. Sprague, in charge of Taffy 3, saw this, he laughed and said, “Well, what the hell. You gotta die of something. Small boys attack.”
The rest of the destroyers and destroyer escorts turned and followed the Johnston, and the Japanese opened fire with 18.1 inch guns, 16 inch guns, 14 inch guns, 8 and 6 inch guns, blasting up the water on both sides of the Johnston. Astoundingly, Evans conned the ship through the splashes in a zigzag until he was within range with his 5 inch guns, which could not penetrate the hulls of the IJN’s battleships and cruisers. He ordered fire concentrated on the upper decks to do the most damage, and this succeeded in knocking down the superstructures and setting the ships afire.
Then the Johnston fired torpedoes and blew the bow off the Kumano, a heavy cruiser, which necessitated another cruiser leaving the fight to assist evacuation. Finally, the Japanese scored hits, a 14 incher, and three 6 inchers, which went clean through the entire vessel without detonating. The first knocked out half the engine power and the electricity to the aft gun turrets.
Evans was struck by one of the blasts and had 2 fingers ripped from his left hand and his shirt burned off.
The Johnston was crippled, but still refused to withdraw and set out a smoke screen. The other destroyers and escorts arrived and every man was consigned to death in order to enable the escort carriers to escape.
By the time it was over, the Johnston had slugged it out with titanic battleships and cruisers, and a line of 4 IJN destroyers, driving the latter off, until another salvo knocked the engine out and detonated several 5 inch shells in the forward magazine.
The Johnston was dead in the water and the IJN surrounded it and fired from all sides. Incredibly, Evans refused to order “abandon ship” until all remaining rounds had been fired, even the starbusts, which are like flares, and the sandbag rounds for practice. When the Japanese passed the survivors in the water, they threw them food and water and saluted them, shouting, “Samurai! Samurai!”
Evans was not among the survivors pulled from the water after the battle. His fate is unknown. He may have been eaten by sharks.
One of the more darkly humorous episodes of warfare occurred on 29 January 1945, in Holzheim, Belgium. Funk and his paratroopers were assaulting the town, and he left a rearguard of 4 men, while he scouted ahead to link up with other units, Those 4 men had to guard about 80 German prisoners.
Another German patrol of 10 happened by and overwhelmed the 4 Americans, freeing the prisoners and arming them. When Funk returned around the corner of a building, he was met by a German officer with an MP-40 in his stomach. The German shouted something at him, and Funk looked around.
There were now about 90 Germans, about half of them armed, and 5 Americans, disarmed except for Funk. The German shouted the same thing at him again, and Funk started laughing. He claimed later that he tried to stop laughing, but the fact that the German was shouting in German touched a nerve. Funk didn’t speak German. Neither did any of the other Americans. Why would the German officer expect him to understand?
His laughter and non-compliance caused some of the Germans to start laughing. Funk shrugged at them and started laughing so hard he had to bend over. He called to his men, “I don’t understand what he’s saying!” All the while, the German officer was shouting more and more angrily.
Then, quick as lightning, Funk swung his Thompson submachine gun up and emptied the entire clip into the German, 30 rounds of .45 ACP. Before the other Germans could react, he had yanked the clip out and slammed another in and opened fire on all of them, screaming to his men to pick up weapons. They did so, and proceeded to gun down 20 men. The rest dropped their weapons and put their hands up.
Then Funk started laughing again and said to his men, “That was the stupidest fucking thing I’ve ever seen!”
One of the hardest fights the Allies had in Europe was outside Aachen, Germany, the Battle of Crucifix Hill. The crucifix is still there, now a monument to the battle. Brown was placed in charge of Company C, with about 120 men, assigned to take the hill or die trying. The entire American force on the hill was a full regiment of about 500. They were facing an equal number of well entrenched Germans. If the hill was not taken, the Allies could not encircle Aachen. The Germans could pour down artillery on the entire town.
There were at least 43 pillboxes and bunkers, bristling with machine guns and plenty of men. Company C was assigned pillboxes 17, 18, 19, 20, 26, 29, and 30. The worst of these was 20, with a 360 degree turret on top armed with an 88 mm cannon. The walls were 6 feet of steel reinforced concrete.
After crawling 150 yards under heavy enemy fire to 18 and blowing it up with a satchel charge, Brown crawled again through heavy enemy fire, 35 yards to 19, and several mortar rounds landed around him, knocking him down. He got back up, climbed on top of the bunker and dropped a bangalore torpedo through a hole in the roof. This blew a larger hole, into which he dropped a satchel, and destroyed the emplacement.
20, however, had 45 men and 6 machine guns aimed out around it. When he returned for more demolition, his sergeant told him, “There’s bullet holes in your canteen.” He had been hit in the hip and was bleeding profusely. He crawled down a communications trench 20 yards from 19 to 20, and saw a German entering a steel door in the side. Brown was an ex-boxer, and knocked this man out with one swing, through him inside, and then threw 2 in satchel charges, and ran.
20 exploded so violently that flames flew out the top and caught a tree on fire. Brown personally led his men on a path of destruction through the rest of their assignments, and after an hour of tooth-and-nail fighting, Crucifix Hill was reduced to smoking rubble.
Brown shot himself in 1971, plagued ever since the war with bad memories and pain from his wounds.
On 2 May 1968, 12 Green Berets were surrounded near Loc Ninh, South Vietnam, by an entire battalion of NVA. They were thus outnumbered, 12 men versus about 1,000. They dug in and tried to hold them off, but were not going to last long. Benavidez heard their distress call over a radio in town and boarded a rescue helicopter with first aid equipment. He did not have time to grab a weapon before the helicopter left, so he voluntarily jumped into the hot LZ armed only with his knife.
He sprinted across 75 meters of open terrain through withering small arms and machine gun fire to reach the pinned down MACV-SOG team. By the time he reached them, he had been shot 4 times, twice in the right leg, once through both cheeks, which knocked out four molars, and a glancing shot off his head.
He ignored these wounds and began administering first aid. The rescue chopper left as it was not designed to extract men. An extraction chopper was sent for, and Benavidez took command of the men by directing their fire around the edges of the clearing in order to facilitate the chopper’s landing. When the aircraft arrived, he supervised the loading of the wounded on board, while throwing smoke canisters to direct the chopper’s exact landing. He was wounded severely and at all times under heavy enemy crossfire, but still carried and dragged half of the wounded men to the chopper.
He then ran alongside the landing skids providing protective fire into the trees as the chopper moved across the LZ collecting the wounded. The enemy fire got worse, and Benavidez was hit solidly in the left shoulder. He got back up and ran to the platoon leader, dead in the open, and retrieved classified documents. He was shot in the abdomen, and a grenade detonated nearby peppering his back with shrapnel.
The chopper pilot was mortally wounded then, and his chopper crashed. Benavidez was in extremely critical condition, and still refused to fall. He ran to the wreckage and got the wounded out of the aircraft, and arranged them into a defensive perimeter to wait for the next chopper. The enemy automatic rifle fire and grenades only intensified, and Benavidez ran and crawled around the perimeter giving out water and ammunition.
The NVA was building up to wipe them out, and Benavidez called in tactical air strikes with a squawk box and threw smoke to direct the fire of arriving gunships. Just before the extraction chopper landed, he was shot again in the left thigh while giving first aid to a wounded man. He still managed to get to his feet and carry some of the men to the chopped, directing the others, when an NVA soldier rushed from the woods and clubbed him over the head with an AK-47. This caused a skull fracture and a deep gash to his left upper arm, and yet he still got back up and decapitated the soldier with one swing of his knife, severing the spine and all tissue on one side of the neck. He then resumed carrying the wounded to the chopper and returning for others, and was shot twice more in the lower back. He shot two more NVA soldiers trying to board the chopper, then made one last trip around the LZ to be sure all documents were retrieved, and finally boarded the chopper. He had lost 2 quarts of blood. Before he blacked out, he shouted to one of the other Green Berets, “Another great day to be in South Vietnam!”
This battle lasted six hours. He had been wounded 37 times.
The first Medal of Honor recipient for actions during the battle of Iwo Jima, Stein charged right into the thickest parts of the fray on D-Day, with the 1st Battalion, 28th Reg., 5th Marines Div. in the assault across the narrowest part of the island, in order to cut off Mount Suribachi from the rest.
He was armed with a homemade .50 caliber machine gun that he salvaged from a downed American aircraft on another island. He fired this from the hip as he charged across the volcanic plains, and engaged the enemy at every pillbox and bunker that he saw shooting at him.
He was observed far ahead of the rest of his men, following, not fleeing, the dust-spots of machine gun fire all around him, disappearing and reappearing in mortar explosions, sprinting and firing at them face to face.
He deliberately stood upright from cover to draw enemy fire to him and away from pinned down marines, and to ascertain enemy locations, then charged them and killed 20 enemy soldiers before he ran out of ammunition. His weapon fired 100 rounds in 5 seconds.
He took off his helmet and boots, then ran back down to the beach to rearm, then returned and resumed fighting. He did this 8 times, and on every trip back to the beach, he picked up a wounded man and carried him on his shoulders. He destroyed at least 14 enemy installations on the first day of action.
He was killed almost 2 weeks later on a scouting mission, by a sniper, after having been given leave from the island, and then returning when he heard how hard a time his buddies were having.
When told about Stein afterward, Joe Rosenthal, who took the famous flag-raising picture on Suribachi, said, “Running through bullets and not getting hit is like running through rain and not getting wet!”
Thomas Baker personally shot 12 Japanese soldiers manning a machine gun behind his lines on Saipan. This was several days after he ran ahead of his men into the open fire of a pillbox, and fired a bazooka into it. Right after he killed those 12 men, he ran farther back to occupy a rearguard position for his men as they advanced across open terrain. He surprised a group of 6 enemy soldiers concealed and waiting to ambush the next group of Americans to pass. He shot all 6 dead.
Almost 3 weeks later, as the Battle of Saipan was drawing to an end, the Japanese staged a last-ditch banzai attack, the largest of the war, at night, and Baker’s perimeter was beset on 3 sides by at least 3,000 drunken, screaming soldiers. There may have been 5,000.
He dug into a foxhole and shot down scores of them until his ammunition was exhausted, by which time he had been shot in the abdomen. He then destroyed his rifle by using it as a baseball bat against a dozen more.
Another marine ran to rescue him and carry him back. He had gotten about 50 yards when a Japanese soldier shot the rescuer dead. Baker shot the Japanese dead with the rescuer’s rifle. A second marine arrived to help him, but Baker shoved him away, shouting, “Get away from me! I’ve caused enough problems! Gimme your .45!”
The marine handed it to him and propped him against a tree and fled. A third marine passed some time later and offered to help him, but Baker refused. When they found him the next morning, he lay dead against the tree in a pool of blood, his pistol empty, and 8 dead Japanese soldiers around him.
S/Sg Bob Howard is the closest anyone has ever gotten to 3 Medals of Honor for 3 separate actions. He was a Green Beret of the highly classified Military Assistance Command, Vietnam, Studies and Observations Group (MACV-SOG), and his men engaged in black ops all over North Vietnam, and into Cambodia at a time when these actions were very sensitive to world opinion of the United States.
This is why his first two actions were downgraded to the Distinguished Service Cross: the government did not want to draw attention to the MACV-SOG. His Medal of Honor finally came because of a rescue mission he led into Cambodia to find Pfc. Robert Scherdin. Howard was a Sfc. at the time, and after his platoon left the cover of its helicopter, it was attacked by 2 companies of NVA, about 300 men.
Howard took shrapnel to the fronts of his legs and forearms from a grenade, and his rifle was blown to pieces out of his hands. When he sat up he saw his platoon leader seriously wounded and exposed to fire, and proceeded to crawl through withering machine gun and small arms fire. As he administered first aid, a bullet blew one of his ammunition pouches off his belt, detonating several magazines of M-16 rounds.
He still crawled back with the wounded platoon leader, then crawled among his buddies administering first aid, and directing their fire to better places. This lasted for 3 and a half hours, until they actually fought the NVA off and permitted the arrival of two more helicopters. Howard refused to leave until everyone was aboard, all the while taking heavy enemy fire from within the jungle.
Howard was wounded 14 times in 54 months performing deeds like this. He died 23 Dec. 2009 in Waco, TX, from pancreatic cancer.
WWI’s most famous American hero could not stand talking about what he did to become so. He was a conscientious objector, claiming Christianity on his draft notice, and yet was still drafted because the U. S. military does not put much stock into Christian pacifism (though Jesus was quite clear on whether or not you should kill people).
He finally decided to go to war because he would be helping stop the Germans and save American lives. He became well known as the finest marksman at Camp Gordon, GA, scoring perfect bullseyes with open sights more often than the snipers did with scopes.
When his drill instructor how he did it, he said something one might expect from Yogi Berra, “I was born shootin’ a gun better than I could read, sir. I still can.”
York’s battalion was sent to secure the Decauville railway, just north of Chatel-Chehery, in North France, just south of Belgium, on 8 October 1918. 17 men, four non-coms, and 13 privates were ordered to flank the German line and destroy the machine guns from the rear. They captured about 70 Germans and were trying to disarm them, when the machine guns spotted them and turned around to fire on them. 9 Americans around York dropped immediately, 6 of them dead.
Corporal York was now in charge, and left the 7 Americans still fit for duty to guard the Germans while he ran from cover to cover up the hill, shooting the whole way.
“And those machine guns were spitting fire and cutting down the undergrowth all around me something awful. And the Germans were yelling orders. You never heard such a racket in all of your life. I didn’t have time to dodge behind a tree or dive into the brush… As soon as the machine guns opened fire on me, I began to exchange shots with them. There were over thirty of them in continuous action, and all I could do was touch the Germans off just as fast as I could. I was sharp shooting… All the time I kept yelling at them to come down. I didn’t want to kill any more than I had to. But it was they or I. And I was giving them the best I had.”
He shot 15 men dead with his own rifle, and was out of ammunition. He then pulled his .45 and shot 8 more that charged him with bayonets. He then grabbed one of their rifles and fired on a few more machine gun nests, until the Germans surrendered.
When a friend back home, who did not enlist, asked him how many Germans he killed, York started sobbing so hard he threw up. He had killed at least 28.
WWII’s answer to SG York was a man only 5 feet 5 inches tall, and 150 pounds. He earned every major combat award the U. S. has to offer, fighting in Sicily, Salerno, Anzio, Rome, and France. He got the DSC in Normandy, when a German called down from a hilltop that he was surrendering. One of Murphy’s buddies took the bait and stood up, right into a sniper’s bullet. This infuriated Murphy, who jumped up and shot the sniper dead, then charged up the hill and wiped out a machine gun nest of 6 men, firing and throwing grenades at them. Then he picked up the MG-42 and charged over the hillside spraying it from the hip, killing 10 more men.
When asked how it felt to have the DSC, he said, “I got the DSC. All he got was dead.” It was on 26 January 1945, in Holtzwihr, France, almost on the German border, that he earned the Medal of Honor for ordering his men to retreat as the German assault on the town began. His unit had only 19 fighting men left out of 128. He stayed behind and shot the Germans as they emerged from the woods to cross a clearing, until he was out of ammunition. He then climbed onto a burning tank destroyer and used the .50 caliber machine gun to push them back. The Panzers and mortars started blowing up the ground all around him, but he continued this one-man assault for an hour, until he started calling in artillery strikes over the tank destroyer’s phone.
He called these strikes in closer and closer to his position, blowing up Germans and tanks less than 50 yards from him. He finally called a strike on his position, prompting the man on the other end to say, “That’s right on top of you! How close are they!?”
“Hold the phone! I’ll let you talk to them!” he shouted and jumped from the vehicle, and ran into the woods as they overran his position and were struck down again by American cannon fire. As the Germans were in disarray, he called his men out and organized a counter-attack, driving the German’s back.
His men estimated that he had killed 50 men.
William Hawkins waged one of the most furious one-man army assaults on enemy positions in the history of modern warfare. When the marines went ashore on Tarawa atoll, Betio Island, Hawkins told Robert Sherrod, who later became an editor for the Saturday Evening Post, that he would put his platoon of 40 men against any company of 150 men on Earth and guarantee to win.
“He was slightly wounded by shrapnel as he came ashore in the first wave, but the furthest thing from his mind was to be evacuated. He led his platoon into the forest of coconut palms. During a day and a half he personally cleaned out six Jap machine gun nests, sometimes standing on top of a track and firing point blank at four or five men who fired back at him from behind blockhouses. Lieutenant Hawkins was wounded a second time, but he still refused to retire.”
These machine gun nests were pyramidal huts about the size of a large trash can, made of 6 inch-thick steel, up into which a Japanese soldier could pop from underground and man the heavy or light machine gun through a 4 inch slit.
They were everywhere on the island, and the preparatory bombardment had missed most of them. While most of the marines dug in and kept their heads down, Hawkins stood up in full view not more than 5 yards from these pillboxes and fired his M-1 Carbine at them, killing the soldier and allowing his men to move forward to the next one. He refused to keep his head down, and when he ran out of ammunition, he ran up to their mouths and threw in grenades and satchel charges.
These machine guns fired explosive rounds, about .30 caliber, when a simple lump of lead isn’t enough. He destroyed 7 pillboxes and one blockhouse by himself, despite being wounded early in the engagement. The first was shrapnel as he disembarked the long Betio pier. Later in the day, one of the pillboxes caught him in the chest.
He was helped back to a medic, who bandaged him and demanded he get on a first aid boat and leave. He refused, and said, “Don’t tie it so tight that I can’t shoot.” The medic radioed Col. David Shoup, who also won the Medal of Honor for his leadership on the island, and Shoup asked Hawkins to leave.
“I’m not doing it, sir! I came here to kill Japs, not go home!”
Shoup relented and the medic complied, and Hawkins destroyed three more pillboxes by the end of the day. He was throwing his fourth grenade at another one when the gunner inside shot him dead. He was 29. Sherrod said later, “To say that his conduct was worthy of the highest traditions of the Marine Corps is like saying the Empire State Building is moderately high.”






























Oh come on people, you’re reading a list on a website for FREE. They have the right to post whatever the hell they want. Yes the list IS centered around Americans, well so *****ing what? Tough *****, DON’T READ IT.
And NO, I’m NOT an american.
Boooring, don’t care about us medals, there are bigger heroes in this world that deserved honors.Almost all of US heroes are from wars that they started. The stories are interesting but only men from US, come on…they forgot what they made in Vietnam with all the killings, rapping and stuff. American soldiers… even their army is full of gay and lesbians now, that country is going to hell.
man, arguing online makes me happy. i feel like i have a purpose. like i’m important…even though i’m just another dot in the world trying to make my point stick out among the numerous others.
In response to everyone’s concerns, I’ve written this Listverse haiku:
I’m Dazed and Confused,
As to why United States sucks.
Try Beaver Ass Juice now!
DAMN, I hate when I don’t stick to the 5, 7, 5 rule. *****!
wow, the haiku guy is stupid. can’t you count? you ignorant phuck? haha
@bucslim (120):
Bnognk was a visionary on par with the guy who invented low-slung skinny jeans, you pretentious anti-cro-magnan bastard!! Tapir dung remains the umatched standard in prehistoric cave decoration, and all of you idiots who don’t recognize this probably still use beaver urine!!
Awesome list FlameHorse if you were here I would buy you a double of whatever you fancy, and we can invite bucslim @(115) – we have chips and snacks aplenty.
Great job on the list thanks F.H.
@Si Si (48): Thanks.
I’m disgusted by the idiocy of the zit-faced twits dishonoring the memory of these men and trying their best to hurt Americans’ feeling in the comments section.
I’ve never seen anything like it. I thought of mentioning, “This list is too American,” just for fun, but I didn’t think anyone would actually be bothered.
ok, i’ll bite the bait… to avoid the US-centrism comments, why not simply rephrase the title? e.g. “10 astounding actions earning the american medal of honor”. otherwise, some europeans (like me), those who lost *****loads of relatives in the ww2 (like me), might feel a little left out, to put it mildly, especially since we all know that the us made a point out of underplaying the nazi threat in the beginning and actually joined the war way after the eleventh hour, after hundreds of thousands had already been killed. there, i bit the bait. sorry guys…
@Those who are proponents of “the website is free, so you don’t have the right to complain” theory:
Air is free, that does not mean one has then the right to pollute air.
@undaunted warrior (128): Thanks, I might take you up on it.
Thanks, everyone.
Complain all you want to. America is great.
I had a look at this at about 9 a.m. I was going to leave a comment about an honourable mention for Joshua Chamberlain (Little Round Top – Gettysburg). Had a look at the first few posts and thought “Nah – forget it – too many idiots today.” Sure enough, popping back at 4p.m. I can see I was right.
@someone (9): It was for the Medal of Honor an American award the author delivered on the subject matter.
Great list. Too bad people have to complain so much everytime anybody writes anything about America. If you don’t like it , don’t read it.
What a shame that these soldiers have turned in to a stupid argument about being too american. Also for those who say that soldiering is murder I respect your opinion however imagine if you where drafted in their place. What would you do?
@Scratch (127):
Well . . . that’s just like you’re opinion man.
your, did it again.
Top 10 *****y reasons why europe is *****y.
Wow. I’ll bet every one of these heroes would have rather been home having a BBQ and mowing the lawn. But they rose to the challenge of trying to keep themselves and their fellow soldiers alive.
…
Wow. I’ll bet everyone killed by these heroes would rather have been home having a BBQ and mowing the lawn. But they rose to the challenge of trying to keep themselves and their fellow soldiers alive.
War is hell.
oh- by the way, great list!
I just followed a link from another site, so I don’t know this one well. Is all of the writing this bad? Not only do the grammar and spelling make it painful to read (“…he through it in…”), but the random embellishment ruins the point (decapitating someone with one swing of a small knife, being drafted and later “finally deciding to go to war”). The unexpected injection of christian opinion at the beginning of story number three (of a list glorifying extreme violence) is the last nail in the coffin.
I am a huge fan of our military, and of recipients of the Congressional Medal of Honor. I love over-the-top “manly” humor about beards punching out grizzly bears. This article does neither justice.
This is the best list FlameHorse has done, but I still wish he’d learn a few basic rules of writing, like never start a sentence with a numeral, or find a proofreader.
Flamehorse: Good list. I wrote a paper on York and conscientious objectors while I was in college. I found through research that York’s pastor convinced him that serving his country did not conflict with the tenets of Christianity.
Jamie, count me in as one of those who are pretty sick of these flame wars. They detract from your site. If someone wants to post Euro-centric lists, I will read them with interest. If you disagree with a ranking, post a well-reasoned statement as to why you feel that way. If, like “Someone” et al., you just want to engage in diarrhea of the mouth/brain/keyboard, keep your comments to yourself.
Great list, flamehorse-as usual
The topic of war is [almost] always interesting to me.
I think I’ll take a break from listverse for a while. The ignorant and insulting comments make me want to act out like a spoiled rotten little jerk. And I really don’t want to go down that road.
I thought this list was absolutely grand!! I am sorry for all of the anti-American rhetoric, but you know, there are *****s everywhere…
Benevides,(sp) was the absolutely bravest man on here, and he was only trying to SAVE LIVES…
Great list, if you can overlook the comments from the USA haters….
Fantastic list.
People like these deserve to be honored and remembered for their actions.
As far as the whole “too American” thing is concerned, I’m all for a list of other foreign hero’s. In fact, if someone would make one I would love to read it. However, the fact that these were Americans should neither add nor detract from their amazing actions.
Of course its a FlameHorse list. You got a lot of good ones out there. Keep it up!
@Yodz (#113)
I yield most of my comments to what you have already mentioned in your post.
While many of the comments about this topic have been brash, I read them all. People are entitled to their opinions and sometimes, selfish beliefs.
I really quite enjoyed reading this list and it made me think about how easy it is for me to judge the actions of those who take another human life. It is much easier for me to look at this act as an atrocity because of the very politically correct, socialized world I live in. But then I think about what kinds of places these men were in, physically, mentally, and emotionally. They didn’t wake up, grab a coffee at their local shop, and shoot someone on the way to the office.
I think about what I would do, if armed men broke into my home and threatened the life of my wife or children. Would I beckon to rationally discuss the pros and cons of engaging in violent behavior? Would I fight to defend their lives, and mine? I don’t really know the answer to that right now, I guess. I suppose it really comes down to the nature of intent.
Often, decisions made by a government do not always align with the beliefs of its citizens. I am a free citizen. I determine the choices I make each day and am held accountable for those choices. Those serving in the Armed Forces, engaged in highly stressful, life-threatening environments may not be entitled to such freedoms, where it comes to “kill or be killed”. That presents an individual with the utmost selfless act; to sacrifice ones life for the sake of peace. Military enlistment does not altogether forfeit our ability to make those same decisions, but faced with the alternative, it is my belief most would defend their nation, their communities, and family against those who mean to do them harm.
Thank you for the post, it was very thought provoking.
@bucslim (138):
Whatever. And I hope you don’t find my opinion too “pedestrian”.
I honestly find it hard to believe that so many people would be compelled to whine about a list on a website. Pick up a hobby maybe? Make some friends? Step away from the computer?
@63jax
“Boooring, don’t care about us medals, there are bigger heroes in this world that deserved honors.Almost all of US heroes are from wars that they started. The stories are interesting but only men from US, come on…they forgot what they made in Vietnam with all the killings, rapping and stuff. American soldiers… even their army is full of gay and lesbians now, that country is going to hell.
8 out of the 10 listed in this come from either WW1 or WW2. I didn’t realize that the US engaged in the practice of secret treaties that ultimately led to the First World War. And I totally forgot about the US installing Hitler in power and then funding his massive buildup of the army. I guess I also forgot how the US told Japan to attack Pearl Harbor. Learn your history before you engage in that kind of an idiotic statement. Oh and the Gay and Lesbian comment makes me think you have some internal issues to figure out. There are a number of support groups out there that can probably help you out.
Wow! The dumbassery I’ve read in the comments today is astonishing! Awesome list Flamehorse, those guys are sitting around a campfire in heaven stirring it with their bare hands. This list seems to have really stirred up the geeks, nerds and dip*****s though. While I’m at it I’ll reiterate what several others have tried to get through to the numbskulls out there; OF COURSE IT’S TOO AMERICAN…IT’S AN AMERICAN DECORATION! I’m from Canada, but it doesn’t make a difference, these men had balls of solid rock and deserve the world’s admiration.
People get too emotional about these lists
Flamehorse — Ths was a great list, like so many of the others that I’ve read. It was informative and a good read.
Commenters — why on earth do we have to turn this into a bashing of any kind? Why can’t we just enjoy the posted list or if we don’t like it move on, there’ll always be another posted tomorrow. For some reason, we’ve turned this particular list into the ‘Great War of the Commentors’ (I doubt anyone will win any medals for postig a rant at great personal risk to theirself). So what if it was american specific? I didn’t see such an uproar over the Italian Movie list the other day. I agree with so many of the others who’ve already commented that if you don’t like it, don’t read it and submit your own list. What purpose is served by posting comments full of venom and cursing? Does it really make you that happy to have your ranting out there for all to read? Hey there’s an idea for your list: Top ten greatest rants I’ve ever posted on listverse. I for one wouldn’t bother reading something like that since I have a life and much better things to do with it.
Anyway, FH… keep up the good work.
Very awesome list Flamehorse. My fave of yours thus far. Number 7, Benavidez struck me the most. I kept seeing the scene from We Were Soldiers playing over in my head – but in real life – not just some Mel Gibson vehicle.
What bothers me, even more than the wah, wah, War is bad crap, (sometimes its justified, you *****s what would you do? let Hitler have his way?) are the people who say “not interested, *****ty list, didn’t even bother to read it”. How the hell can you know if you’re interested until after you’ve read it? It’s not like you’re embarking on a 800 page tome on military history. Lists like this are designed to help you decide if you’re interested. Unless of course you folks are all learning disabled – and it takes you half a day to read it. Geez, you guys are some lazy. And do you all not realize that knowing ***** just for the sake of knowing it, is an end unto itself? So now we have not only lazy, but ignorant to boot.
A note about Alvin York
The US was allowing consciences objectors fro religious reasons, but Sgt. York put down something like Kentucky Mountain Chrisitan or something like that, which wasn’t recognized by the US as an established denomination, had he been a seventh day adventist, he would have been excluded from service
I visit this site every day. Do I read the list everyday? No I do not. Why? Because if I read the title or the intro and don’t think I will enjoy the list guess what I don’t read it. Therefore if you hate Americans and the list is on an American medal then maybe you shouldn’t read the list and you should especially not leave dumb comments. Great list today by the way I personally enjoy historical list of any nature which is why I read them!
This might sound bad but list 9 made me laugh. I enjoyed this list though I expected at least 1 Navajo to be on here. As for the rude comments I just skip over them.
[deleted]
Too American
I think if one of our British brethren put up one on VC winners it would make quite interesting reading.
@thejesuslizard (42): Good luck. Personally, I don’t complain about the national bias of any list because firstly, I would be sinking to the level of the other ignoramuses who do that; and secondly, I find nearly all information worth learning.
So the comments section here is beginning to look more like a 4chan subsidiary than a place for intelligent dialogue. So what. The folks who post here have the greatest control over this problem. Simply ignore the little bastards. If you stop feeding them, they go away.
Jamie & Flamehorse – Thank you for the hard work and for keeping it going! I still read the lists, even though I rarely post a comment.
@Osama (160):
Are you sure your parents know that you are using the internet? Seems like you may have a poopy diaper.
@someone (9): The medal of honor is an American medal – it makes sense that it will only go to Americans. It is ridiculous that we would have to exclude all lists that apply only to Americans.
Finally someone talking sense. Although really. Delete the comments. To say that europe is a waste of space? Thats like me saying the sky is green. I would need to be blind.
As someone who was here from the earliest LV lists…
I’ve always come back day after day not only for the great lists but the community of regulars. But, as many have already pointed out, the quality of the discussion has really declined. I am not a reader who posts daily but only when I can add something to the conversation…I like to lurk more than anything. But honestly, I feel like contributing less and less the last few months.
Perhaps this is the inevitable result of LV’s great success…I don’t know. All I know is that, at least when it comes to the comments, LV is kind of at a turning point. Either something changes or LV turns into the flamefest that most other sites are and in turn loses one of the things that made LV such a great little corner of the net.
Great list FH.
Leonard Funk looks like Jason Schwartzman…
One does not “earn” a Medal of Honor. One is awarded a Medal of Honor. I realize this is a that’s a pretty small semantic difference, but, to me, it’s the difference between winning the Medal and being awarded the Medal. Perhaps I’m incorrect?
I am amazed at the bravery of those who sit behind their keyboards and type with such vitriol. Americans are the scum of the earth. Soldiers are murders. Etc, etc, etc. What has happened to respect and proper discourse? I guarantee such internet bravado is not be carried over into real life.
Thank you, JFrater.
If you can read, thank a teacher. If you can read in English, thank a Marine.
I love this list. Very informative. Amazing what these guys did in the face of almost certain death.
Whatever your politics, I don’t think you can denigrate these soldiers. The veterans from the 442nd, for example, still went to fight for the US even though their own families were in internment camps. How can you despise these people? They fought against a pair of brutal regimes that needed to be defeated.
I’ve met a 442nd veteran, and I can tell you it was more of an honor and more memorable than any movie star.
awesome list flamehorse. i gotta say i expect a lot when i see your name as the list author. good thing you live up to expectations.
As for the offensive comments, ignore them. Comments like those are probably made my adolescent zit faced anger filled kids who think its fun to swear constantly. they feed on your anger to fuel their own. they revel in joy when their immature remark is commented on. its a cry for attention we are unwittingly satisfying by trying to fight them. so when you see a bad comment, just let it go. They will probably be more disappointed that no one took notice of their posts.
@Max #96 and the other offended guys – lets not get discouraged. lets not let trolls stop us from enjoying the sites we love. go listverse!
@knight_forked (4):
YOU ARE A GODDAMNED IDIOT.
For your consideration, entry #0: Desmond T. Doss, Sr., the first Conscientious Objector to receive the Medal of Honor.
Combat medic (Army) in the Pacific. Saw action on Leyte, Guam and Okinawa. Initially ridiculed by his fellow soldiers because he refused to carry a weapon. Later revered by them for his bravery.
From the citation:
“…He was a company aid man when the 1st Battalion assaulted a jagged escarpment 400 ft high. As our troops gained the summit, a heavy concentration of artillery, mortar and machine gun fire crashed into them, inflicting 75 casualties and driving the others back.”
“Pfc. Doss refused to seek cover and remained in the fire-swept area with the many stricken, carrying them 1 by 1 to the edge of the escarpment and there lowering them on a rope-supported litter down the face of a cliff to friendly hands.”
He was later severely wounded and spent 5 years in recovery.
I have tremendous admiration for this man. Throughout all of this, Pfc. Doss remained true to himself, his principles and his fellow soldiers in the purest and most selfless way.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desmond_Doss
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/25/national/25doss.html
@mom424 (156): “What bothers me, even more than the wah, wah, War is bad crap, (sometimes its justified, you *****s what would you do? let Hitler have his way?)”
Well mom im sorry to say that you must catch up on some history yourself. The us in the aftermath of the great crash has retract all the funds invested in germany. This determined a severe crisis in germany that helped hitlers rise to power. Also hitler was given a “do what ever you wish in europe” pass by england, france. Lets not forget the ribbentrop molotov pact that resulted in the polish invasion. Dictators dont appear out of a sudden. Especially not Hitler. Of course when war started the fighting had to be done.
The list was good. People just get it wrong. Killing soldiers is the game/job. And you go to war to do that. So i dont see the difference between one side and the other speaking in STRICTLY military terms. (when one army faces another army/ strategy, technology etc. Not when an army faces civilians. That IS the terrible side of war and that is what shows us that if aliens would exist then we would be their pets).
Ps i hope people get the difference i tried to highlight here.
For MOH buffs please look up a few of my personal favorites, Jimmy Earl Howard, Desmond Doss (Who should be on this list), Angelo J. (Charles) Liteky. For all of the folks that have so much hatred in thier hearts that they feel as though they have to communicate it via this forum: It is that very hatred towards one another that caused these very engagements, is causing them now, will cause them forever. Shout out to a few of my non American brothers, warriors, heroes: Simo Häyhä and his comrades, All of the brave soldiers of the French Foreign Legion at The Battle of Cameron, Harry Patch and all of the brave soldiers at The Battle of Passchendaele. We fight, regardless of ethnicity, for our brothers in the trench, to the north, south, east and west of us, with pride, until either the enemy or we expire. Life rather than courage will abandon us. All of us. Peace.
@someone
When I saw the list heading today, I thought I would pass on it, but then I read it, and was surprised at how well the list was written, and astounded at the bravery of those who were put in such bad situations, thank you flamehorse for opening my eyes.
To some of the commentors here, and you know who you are, it is better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt. Some of you have indeed removed all doubt.
What a great list! And what a bunch of bad asses!
Great list, Flamehorse! Really well done. Really makes you think about a lot of things – war, destruction, heroism, memories, freedoms, life. Nothing’s free. I think this particular list will be on my mind awhile.
That Leonard Funk, though, he looks like a stinker.