10 Dark Details of the “Bodies in the Barrels” Murders

In the quiet northern suburbs of Adelaide, a group of men led by the charismatic yet deeply disturbed John Bunting spent much of the 1990s waging what they claimed was a moral crusade. What began as a self-appointed campaign to “clean up” alleged pedophiles and social “undesirables” devolved into one of the most notorious serial killing cases in Australian history. Between 1992 and 1999, 12 people were murdered in crimes marked by prolonged torture, calculated fraud, and shocking cruelty.

Although the case became known as the “Bodies in Barrels” murders, most of the killings did not occur in Snowtown itself. The name comes from the grim discovery inside a disused State Bank building in the small wheat-belt town, where police uncovered barrels filled with human remains. The investigation exposed not just murder, but a culture of manipulation, financial exploitation, and escalating sadism that stunned the nation and led to years of suppression orders in South Australia.

Related: 10 Chilling True Crime Tales Involving Southwestern U.S. Hotel Rooms

10 The “Wall of Spiders”

Long before the first barrel was sealed, John Bunting was constructing what he believed to be a moral crusade. Inside his Salisbury North home, he maintained what became known as the “Wall of Spiders”—a crude network of names scrawled on paper and linked together with string. To an outsider, it might have resembled a conspiracy theorist’s evidence board. In reality, it functioned as a living hit list.

Bunting targeted people he personally deemed immoral or deviant, including alleged pedophiles, homosexual men, and individuals he labeled as “weak.” Many of these accusations were based on rumor, prejudice, or personal grudges rather than verified criminal records. Court evidence later showed that several victims had never been convicted of any sex offense at all. Bunting would reportedly sit for hours studying the web of names, deciding who would be subjected to what he chillingly called “rehabilitation.”

This pseudo-vigilante ideology gave his crimes a warped moral framework. It also made recruitment easier, as he convinced accomplices they were cleansing the community rather than committing murder. The “Wall of Spiders” was not just a list—it was the blueprint for a campaign of hate that would eventually leave 12 people dead between 1992 and 1999.^[1]

9 Ritualistic Dismemberment

When police began piecing together the forensic evidence, they discovered that the killings were only the beginning. Victims were typically strangled, often using ligatures such as electrical cords or computer cables. But what followed was a calculated effort to reduce bodies for storage.

Using hacksaws and knives, Bunting and his chief accomplice, Robert Wagner, dismembered their victims so the remains could fit inside plastic barrels. In several cases, feet and limbs were removed first to make handling easier. Forensic pathologists later testified that some cuts suggested familiarity with animal butchery, consistent with Bunting’s previous work in an abattoir.

Hydrochloric acid was poured into the barrels in an attempt to mask decomposition odors and accelerate breakdown. Ultimately, six barrels stored inside the disused Snowtown bank vault contained the remains of eight victims, while additional victims were buried elsewhere. The systematic nature of the dismemberment underscored the cold efficiency behind what was publicly framed as moral vigilantism.^[2]

8 The Cannibalism Incident

Among the most shocking revelations to emerge during trial proceedings was testimony alleging cannibalism. The final victim, David Johnson—Bunting’s own stepson—was murdered in 1999 after being lured to the Snowtown bank building under the pretense of helping with cleaning.

According to court testimony from accomplice James Vlassakis, after Johnson was killed, Robert Wagner cut a portion of flesh from the body and cooked it. He later claimed it tasted like roast pork. Bunting allegedly encouraged the act as a final humiliation of the victim. The detail was so disturbing that it was initially subject to suppression orders, only becoming widely reported years later when restrictions were lifted.

The cannibalism allegation further reinforced how the group’s violence had escalated far beyond any vigilante pretense. What began as self-proclaimed moral “cleansing” had devolved into acts designed purely to degrade and dominate.^[3]

7 Identity Theft and Welfare Fraud

Behind the rhetoric of moral purification lay a far more pragmatic motive: money. After murdering victims, the group often stole their identities to continue claiming government welfare payments through Centrelink. They forged signatures, maintained bank accounts, and contacted government agencies while impersonating the deceased.

To sustain the deception, they sometimes moved victims’ belongings to create the illusion that the person had relocated. In certain cases, family members were told the victim had left town voluntarily. By the time authorities dismantled the operation, the group had fraudulently obtained approximately A$97,200 (about US$63,000 at the time).

This steady stream of income helped fund living expenses and gave the killers an incentive to delay discovery. The fraud also explains why some victims were not reported missing for years—financial activity created the appearance that they were still alive.^[4]

6 The “Computer” Torture Device

The brutality of the Snowtown murders was not limited to strangulation. Investigators uncovered evidence of prolonged torture sessions designed to extract confessions or simply inflict suffering. Central to these sessions was a device the killers referred to as “The Computer.”

It was not technological in any meaningful sense. The device consisted of a car battery attached to jumper cables and electrodes. Victims were restrained—often to chairs or beds—while electric shocks were applied to sensitive parts of their bodies. The shocks were delivered intermittently, prolonging agony and psychological terror.

Court proceedings revealed that some victims were held for extended periods, enduring both physical abuse and lectures from Bunting about their alleged moral failings. The calculated use of electrocution underscored that these crimes were not impulsive acts but structured, escalating exercises in domination. The discovery of the battery apparatus, along with pliers and other implements, confirmed the existence of what was effectively a makeshift torture chamber operating within suburban homes.^[5]

5 The Murder of Elizabeth Haydon

The gang’s warped ideology offered no protection—even to their own inner circle. Elizabeth Haydon, the wife of accomplice Mark Haydon, became a victim after Bunting decided she “knew too much” and posed a potential threat. Despite her husband’s involvement in assisting with the disposal of bodies, he did nothing to stop what followed.

In November 1998, Elizabeth was tortured and murdered in her own home. Her body was later placed in one of the barrels stored in the Snowtown bank vault. Court proceedings revealed that Mark Haydon assisted in covering up her death, ultimately pleading guilty to assisting an offender to avoid apprehension.

Her murder demonstrated that loyalty to Bunting’s so-called cause was conditional and disposable. Even family members were expendable if they risked exposing the operation. The killing also highlighted the deep psychological control Bunting exerted over those around him, convincing accomplices to sacrifice even their closest relationships.^[6]

4 The 87-Mile (140 km) Corpse Caravan

Despite the name, most of the murders occurred in Adelaide’s northern suburbs, approximately 87 miles (140 km) south of Snowtown. As decomposition odors began attracting attention in residential areas, Bunting sought a more secure storage location.

In early 1999, the group rented a commercial van and transported multiple heavy plastic barrels filled with human remains and hydrochloric acid nearly two hours north to Snowtown. The chosen site was a disused State Bank building, whose reinforced vault they believed would contain both smell and suspicion.

The sheer audacity of transporting barrels containing human remains along public highways without interception remains one of the most chilling logistical details of the case. Ultimately, six barrels containing the remains of eight victims were stored inside the vault. Additional victims were buried elsewhere in South Australia, bringing the total confirmed death toll to 12.^[7]

3 Forcing Victims to Record “Good-Bye” Tapes

To maintain their welfare fraud scheme and delay suspicion, Bunting forced several victims to record farewell messages before they were killed. Under extreme duress—and often after prolonged torture—victims were made to state that they were leaving town voluntarily or “starting a new life.”

These recordings were later played to family members or used to reassure government agencies that the individuals were alive. The tactic was devastatingly effective. Some victims were not officially reported missing for years, as financial records and recorded messages created the illusion of independence.

Beyond the financial motive, the forced recordings added another layer of psychological cruelty. Victims were compelled to participate in their own disappearance, fully aware that the words they spoke would serve as a false comfort to loved ones after they were gone.^[8]

2 The Murder of Michelle Gardiner

Michelle Gardiner, a 19-year-old transgender woman, was targeted largely due to Bunting’s deep-seated hatred and prejudice. Initially befriended by the group, Michelle eventually became the focus of Bunting’s escalating bigotry. He falsely portrayed her as a threat, reinforcing his vigilante narrative to justify violence.

In September 1997, Bunting and Wagner took Michelle to a shed in Murray Bridge. Over several hours, she was subjected to repeated strangulation and assault. Witness testimony later described how she was forced to stand whenever she collapsed from exhaustion during the ordeal.

Her murder underscored that the supposed campaign against alleged child abusers had expanded into broader, indiscriminate hatred. Michelle’s death remains one of the most tragic and painful elements of the Snowtown case, highlighting the lethal consequences of Bunting’s extremist ideology.^[9]

1 The Snowtown Bank Discovery

The investigation culminated on May 20, 1999, when police, acting on information related to a missing person, forced entry into the Snowtown bank vault. Inside, they discovered six plastic barrels containing the remains of eight victims submerged in acid. Officers later described a powerful, sickly odor that lingered even outside the building.

The discovery shocked Australia. Media coverage was immediate and intense, and South Australian courts imposed strict suppression orders limiting publication of some trial details to prevent prejudice and public panic. As the full scope of the crimes emerged—including torture, fraud, and a total of 12 confirmed murders—the case became one of the most infamous in the country’s criminal history.

John Bunting and Robert Wagner were sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. James Vlassakis received life with a non-parole period, and Mark Haydon was imprisoned for his role in assisting the cover-up. The vault in Snowtown became a grim symbol of the case—a place where years of hidden brutality were finally exposed.^[10]