I must confess, as much as I love British writers, the ones that I always come back to are American. America really has dominated modern English literature – not just in the pulp fiction arena but in serious literature as well. From the moment that America found its voice in the world of writing, it has had an incredibly significant presence. This list looks at ten of the masters of the short story genre from the USA.
The author of “Fight Club” is not necessarily known as a “Short Story Writer,” however Palahniuk is a believer in the Ray Bradbury ritual of writing a short story every day. Many of his stories have ended up in his novels without the reader realizing they were originally independent tales. In one novel “haunted” he used a short story about a writers convention to bridge together 23 different short stories. This book features his infamous story “Guts” which has caused several people to faint when read aloud at book signings.
Washington Irving was an American author, essayist, biographer and historian of the early 19th century. He was best known for his short stories “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” and “Rip Van Winkle”, both of which appear in his book The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. His historical works include biographies of George Washington, Oliver Goldsmith and Muhammad, and several histories of 15th-century Spain dealing with subjects such as Christopher Columbus, the Moors, and the Alhambra.
Asimov is certainly one of the most prolific writers in the English language. He is known for many different works from his series “Foundation”, and “Fantastic Voyage”, to text books and everything in-between. He is primarily known as a science fiction writer, however he is one of the few people to have their writing span every major category of the Dewy Decimal System except Philosophy. He wrote an estimated 515 books in his lifetime. As far as writing short stories goes, he has 3 well known stories. “I, Robot”, “The Bicentennial Man”, and “The Last Question.” The first two have been turned into movies. He wrote 19 Short Story collections, spanning a total of 284.
Bradbury is a very well known Science Fiction writer. He is famous for writing a short story every day, a ritual that many other writers have attempted to follow. He has written 11 novels, 3 of which are made up of loosely connected stories, and over 40 short story collections, for a grand total of over 400 short stories and novellas. But it’s not just quantity that earns him a place on this list. His best known short story “A Sound of Thunder”, is the origin of a common science fiction theme called “the butterfly effect”, it is also the most republished science fiction story of all time.
King is one of the most popular authors in America, and a very prolific writer as well. He is a huge fan of the short story. “1408″, “The Mist”, and “Hearts in Atlantis” are just a few of the 35 short stories he wrote that have been made into movies, though perhaps the most famous is “Stand By Me”. He has written 8 story collections and a total of 124 short stories and 17 Novellas in his career. He was also selected to be the editor of The Best American Short Stories of 2007, and also won the O. Henry Award in 1996.
Salinger is known for his novel “Catcher in the Rye”, this is actually his only published novel. A very eccentric writer, he has written a great deal of material in his life, but much of it has never been seen by any one but him. He has 3 other books available to the public. “Nine Stories”, “Frannie and Zoey”, and “Raise High the Roof Beams, Carpenters and Seymour an Introduction”. All 3 of these books are short story collections. He also has about 2 dozen other uncollected short stories. Salinger is considered by many to be the greatest American writer of the 20th century.
Real name William Sydney Porter. O. Henry is known for writing flash fiction with wit and a strange twist ending. His most well known story is “The Gift of the Magi” which is a story about a young poor couple who each sells their most precious object in order to buy a Christmas gift for their partner, but in doing so they end up making each others gift worthless. This story has been retold in many different forms over the years. The O. Henry Award was established in his honor, it is a very prestigious award given to outstanding short story writers. Two writers on this list have won this award.
Updike was an extremely gifted short story writer, he published over 150 short stories in his career, his last collection “Tears of my Father” was published in June 2009, about 6 months after his death. He has also won over 30 different awards in his lifetime including: the Pulitzer, the Rea Award, the PEN/Falkner award, and the aforementioned O. Henry Award to name a few.
F. Scott Fitzgerald was an American writer of novels and short stories, whose works are evocative of the Jazz Age, a term he coined himself. He is widely regarded as one of the twentieth century’s greatest writers. Fitzgerald is considered a member of the “Lost Generation” of the Twenties. He finished four novels, including The Great Gatsby, with another published posthumously, and wrote dozens of short stories that treat themes of youth and promise along with despair and age. If you want a recommendation for his greatest two short stories, I suggest reading “Bernice Bobs Her Hair” and “The Diamond As Big As The Ritz”. You won’t be disappointed.
Poe is probably the most famous English short story writer of all time. Poe only wrote one complete novel in his lifetime, and it is not very well known, however his short stories are. Most people can tell you the story of “The Tell Tale Heart”, “The Masque of the Red Death,” or “The Pit and the Pendulum”. Poe has over 65 short stories to his name. Poe is also considered to have invented the detective genre.






























Yo, I knew stephen King would be on here. Cue the fans!
these stories are great:)
SO apparently to write well one must have a huge pair of mutton chops, can do.
Man, you should have seen them kicking Edgar Allen Poe. I am the egg man – they are the egg men – they are the paperback writers – coo coo cachoo.
list of top ten commenters….lolz
No Raymond Carver? Seriously? That’s an unforgivable omission!
While Raymond Carver is certainly an interesting omission, to diss Ernest Hemingway and John Cheever on this list is unforgivable.
This list is great! Poe is the man!
I love this list. #10 is by far my favorite author of all time. I am reading the Catcher in the Rye right now, and as soon as I opened this list I knew #5 would be on it. These are some of the greatest writers ever, even if a couple on the list are a little overrated.
ummmm… I think hemmingway should have made his way on here… the snows of kilimonjaro, hills like white elephants, both classics. And Herman Melville is an unforgivable atrocity. Stephen King can;t hold a candle to Bartleby the scrivner, Billy Budd and the piazza tales.
Reading about The Tell Tale Heart reminded of The Simpsons whilst it was good (shame about now).
I am pleased that three of my favorites are here – Poe, Fitzgerald,and palahniuk.
Yes!!!!! I know who all these writers are!!! Whoohoo!!!!!!
@#9 Norman, thats exactly what I thought when i saw The Tell Tale Heart LoL
Stephen King looks like a chipmunk!
Maybe I am a masochist but I can’t wait to see Randall and bucslim take on this list
Poe looks a little odd in his photo!
I’m not certain I’d go with Asimov; Douglas Adams has pointed out he wasn’t technically that good a writer – although he had strong ideas and was remarkably prolific.
@jfrater (14): Yeah – quick! Change ‘corer’ to ‘career’ in 3, and ‘by’ into ‘buy’ in 4 – before they notice!
Number one, the first sentence says that he the greatest “English short story writer” but he is american?
Wicked list though!
@apepper (15): let’s not forget that Shakespeare’s peers thought him a hack. I think Asimov is amazingly entertaining. That is good literature. I couldn’t put his stories down.
@Lifeschool (16): bugger – I am too drunk to correct them now – I will have to do it in the morning
@Jordan (17): Perhaps the author meant English as in the written language, rather than English as in the nationality?
@jfrater (19): That’s ok, you deserve your alcoholic compulsive disorder. Cheers! Bottoms Up.
Right, I’ve done my little bit for today – still chuffed at getting No.1 (sorry, I couldn’t resist.
) – on with the show.
Hard to disagree with any of this
@jfrater
English isnt my first language but shouldnt there be “their most precious objects”. Sorry if im wrong
Edgar Allan Poe is truly the best American Writer! His work of art is very creepy but good. I like his stories.
It’s Edgar Allan Poe, not Edgar Allen Poe
I thought that Stephen King’s most famous one made into a movie was The Shawshank Redemption..it’s a short story. In the same collection as The Body (Stand by me).
as i read the title of this list, 5 names immediately popped into my mind…and in this order:
Poe
King
O.Henry
Bradbury
Asimov
nice to know that another LVer has the same appreciation for this masters of the genre!
happy Thursday, everyone!
rtr
Great list. I’m glad Salinger is on here. I love his short stories. I hate Catcher in the Rye, though. I’m pretty sure that I’m the only American who could not stand that book as an adolescent. Still can’t.
Also, Asimov may not be the best technical writer on this list, but he’s a far sight better than I am (or say, a certain writer who authors books about vampires), and his stories are pretty entertaining.
James Thurber should be added to the list.
Are you serious?
No Hemingway?!
Good list. Somehow I had a hunch that Poe would be there. And he’s brilliant so I don’t mind.
Now, I always seem to find grammatical and spelling errors in the lists so here we go:
Isaac Asimov (8): ‘he is one of the only people to have their writing span every major category of the Dewy Decimal System except Philosophy.’
That one of the only people really bugs me. It should go ‘he is one of the only few people’ or ‘one of the few people’ or ‘he is the only man’ etc.
O. Henry (4): ‘” which is a story about a young poor couple who each sells there most precious object in order to by a Christmas gift for their partner’
Their, not there: buy, not by
“I, Robot” isn’t a short story. It’s a short story compilation of Asimov’s early robot short stories, and bares almost no resemblance to the movie of the same name except for the presence of the Laws of Robotics.
Good choice with Poe. Totally agree.
@jfrater (19):
another typo (#4) “… sells there most precious object..” sh/be ‘their’.
Other than that, excellent list. thank you, ZachS.
i love this site, and have never had an issue with a single list….BUT—-HOW is Flannery O’Connor not on this list?!?!
Amazing that “Stand By Me” is listed as King’s most famous short-story-turned-movie… since it’s not. The Shawshank Redemption is, by far, his most popular short-story-turned-movie and the movie itself is, without a doubt, the best film adapted from a King story, short or otherwise. Despite the great nostalgia of Stand By Me, a quality, beloved film in its own right, the story of Andy Dufresne, Red and Shawshank prison will forever go down as King’s greatest adapted work.
Please correct under the Salinger entry the name of one of his published novels to “FRANNY and Zooey” NOT “Frankie and Zooey.” This is an atrocious typo.
I love Isaac Asimov, Ray Bradbury, King, John Updike and Poe. Glad you added them, ZachS. I have all of King’s books and most of the others. I really haven’t read any of the other authors on this list, but will have to give them a try.
I confess that most of the writers I read from are outside the USA, but there are a few good ones from here.
Also, I just noticed you have “FRANKIE and ZOEY” – again, should be Franny and Zooey.
Thank you.
Have to disagree about King’s Stand By Me. The Obvious choice is Shawshank Redemption.
I’ve read all of these guys except one. Wow. Not bad for me.
Oouchan, you can come back home now. The bear has promised to tame the children.
No Raymond Carver or Flannery O’Connor, Booooooooooooooooo!
Seriously, where’s Flannery O’Connor?
I think there’s an unhealthy obsession with these authors’ heights here. Can’t they be considered as “story writers” on their own merits without having to “measure up” to their rivals, the “tall story writers”?
how can you omit Mark Twain from this list?!
@warrrreagl (40): Thanks, warrr dear. I will join you guys later.
@astraya (43): I agree. Let them stand on their own two feet based on their stories…no matter what the size.
What about Flannery O’Connor? She was one of the greatest masters of the American (especially the Southern) short story. I especially recommend “Good Country People,” in which a cynical young woman is conned out of her artificial leg.
Good list, a little patriarchal, though.
ok I’m not usually one of those “you forgot dazed and confused!!!” people, but….I was expecting Truman Capote.
Miriam, Shut a Final Door, The Walls Are Cold, all amazing short stories. Also, if we’re including novellas, Breakfast at Tiffany’s. I’m sad now.
Great list; for once I’ve actually read at least one or two pieces from each author listed. Yeah for me! I actually love short stories – takes a ton of skill to be succinct and still have sufficient character development for us to care. Personally I don’t consider Shawshank or The Body to be short stories – they’re novellas. Great ones but still.
All grammar, punctuation and content errors have been fixed up – I think. I’m sure someone will notice if I’ve missed any.
oouchan, warr; Thank goodness for “The Bear”
I truly do apprieciate those on the list I would have found room for Carver.
Ambrose Bierce anyone? he’s like the American Shakespeare.
Great list! I was soooo ready to kick some butt if Poe wasn’t in here! I didn’t expect him to be #1, actually… so YAY!
astraya – Hahaha. That comment literally made me laugh out loud a little.
“Guts” doesn’t need that apostrophe. Just remembering reading that makes me twitchy. It’s a good read, but definitely gross.
I totally agree with all of these, being an Lit nerd myself. You could also add that one of Fitzgerald’s short stories was “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.” I never saw the movie, but the story is quite good. Poe couldn’t be anything but #1.
I could see a sequel here with Bierce, Carver, Hawthorne, Twain, Cooper, Crane, and maybe Faulkner. But like I said, I’m a lit nerd.
Good thing Stephen King writes such a good short story – ’cause his long ones SUCK! – personal opinion: I’m allowed one.
American writers over British writers?? HA! So ridiculous.
Where’s Flannery O’Connor?
Isn’t Shawshank technically a novella? I think it goes by word count. I’m pretty sure everything in the Different Seasons collection is technically a novella but that might just be me being a pedant.
“gut’s”? really? come on, dude.
great list, appreciate the reminder about some of the great short fiction works I haven’t yet read. have to add my voice to the chorus lamenting the absence of Raymond Carver and Flannery O’Connor. Flannery would have been an especially nice addition to the list, you know, just to balance out all of the testosterone and mutton chops. regardless, I enjoyed the list, thanks : )
Good selection here, ZachS.
Read Bradbury’s The Illustrated Man earlier this year. It’s a real treat for any lover of short fiction.
O. Henry is great, witty and a master of the twist ending. I “re-discovered” him late last year after all but ignoring him during high school English classes. Terrific stuff.
And Poe is fantastic. The Cask of Amontillado is my favorite Poe tale. It’s told from the point of view of a cold-blooded killer. The introduction, one of the finest beginnings to a short story, says it all:
“The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult I vowed revenge.”
Marvelous.