Top 10 Prophecies of Nostradamus Debunked
Published on September 14, 2007 - 22 Comments
In this list I have tried to be as honest as one can be with the text. Instead of manipulating it to make it suit, I am using what I consider to be a very accurate translation. The end result, I think, is that we can see that most of these predictions are so broad that they really can be made to mean anything we want. Nevertheless, many people consider these to be authentic predictions of real events. Decide for yourselves.
1. 9/11 #1-87 Original French
will cause trembling around the new city:
Two great rocks will make war for a long time.
Then Arethusa will redden a new river.
This quatrain has been so distorted that some examples barely resemble the real text. Some go so far as to mention New York city by name, and others describe flying metal machines. As you can see - neither of these things are actually mentioned in the true text. Many people say that the two great rocks are a reference to the planes used in the attack. Arethusa is a mythological Nymph who turned in to a fountain. Nostradamus knew this as can be seen clearly in the last sentence. A casual search on the internet will lead you to some of the most bizarre translations of this quatrain. For example, one site says this for line 2: “Will create trembling in the towers of the City of New York.”; and this for line 4: “This is when air-vessels spin-round to a new course.”
2. Hitler #4-68 Original French
The two greatest ones of Asia and of Africa,
From the Rhine and Hister they will be said to have come,
Cries, tears at Malta and the Ligurian side.
This is one of the more popular quatrains; it is said to describe Hitler (Hister) at a meeting with Mussolini in which they made plans for Italy for formally enter the Second World War. The problem here is that Hister is a term used in the time of Nostradamus to describe the Danube river. It does seem to describe a war that has some relation to Germany, but there is no way of connecting this to Hitler or the Second World War.
3. Louis Pasteur #1-25 Original French
the pastor will be honored as a demigod:
Before the Moon finishes its full period
he will be dishonored by other winds.
This is often cited as a prediction for the coming of Louis Pasteur and his work with microbes. The confusion is partly exacerbated by the fact that the French word for Pastor was Pasteur, but as Nostradamus never quoted anyone by name from the future, it is unlikely that he did so here - and the reference to a demigod in the same sentence suggests the religious interpretation of a religious Pastor. It is possible that Nostradamus may have been accurate with the date, however: Roussat, a Jewish Astrologer who work was known to Nostradamus put the end of the Moon cycle at 1887 - by which time Pasteur was applying his immunization technology.
4. Henry II of France #1-35 Original French
on the field of battle in single combat:
He will put out his eyes in a cage of gold:
Two fleets one, then to die a cruel death.
Four years after Nostradamus wrote this prophecy, King Henry II of France was killed by a lance in the eye at a match with the younger Captain Montgomery. However, the match was not a battle, it was held at a party to celebrate a peace-treaty (quite the opposite of a field of battle). Many people say that this quatrain made Nostradamus famous in his own time, but it was not until 48 years after his death that this was first printed.
5. Conquering of the Balkan Peninsular #1-49 Original French
those of the East by virtue of the Moon:
the year 1700 they will cause great ones to be carried off,
almost subjugating the Aquilon corner.
This is supposed to predict the Turkish taking of the majority of the Balkan Peninsular which was finally repelled by Peter the Great of Russia. They say that the Moon is a reference to the crescent moon - the symbol of Islam. Aquilon was a term known in the time of Nostradamus to mean the North wind. The biggest problem here? The Balkans are in the Southeast of Europe.
6. World War II / Atomic Bomb #2-6 Original French
there will be two scourges the like of which was never seen,
famine within plague, people put out by steel,
crying to the great immortal God for relief.
First, the original French uses the word “Portes” which means Gates or Doorways - this is usually misinterpreted to mean Ports - as in sea ports. This is clearly a description of plague and famine causing much death - not nuclear attack. In order to make this fit, people often translate it abominably. One example is line three which can be found to be rendered thus: “Intense in torment, an incredible proportion of human lives ended”. The only possible connection could be “steel” - but in the time of Nostradamus this would most likely have meant weaponry of some sort.
7. The Great Fire of London #2-51 Original French
burnt through lighting of twenty threes the six:
The ancient lady will fall from her high place,
several of the same sect will be killed.
The great fire of London was in 1666, so twenty threes the six could be taken to mean 20 X 3 + 6, however, regardless of the accuracy of the date, the fire was started accidentally in a bakery - so no one committed a fault. In addition, while it is true that many Dutch people were blamed and killed, it would seem that the Ancient Lady is a reference to London herself, in which case the sect would be either Londoners (which did not happen) or members of the sect that caused the fire (and none did). It seems very obscure to base a prediction on one interpreation of the numbers in the second line - the rest must be simply distorted to make a connection.
8. Oliver Cromwell #8-76 Original French
born of obscure rank will gain empire through force.
Coward without faith, without law he will bleed the land;
His time approaches so close that I sigh.
People say that this quote refers to the reign of Oliver Cromwell in England during the 17th century. This one is fraught with problems. Most important of all, Cromwell was born to the minor gentry - he was hardly a “butcher” (most likely a euphemism for a commoner). Also, while I agree that Cromwell was a coward and an evil man, he did have a faith - he was a protestant.
9. The Children of Henry II of France #4-60 Original French
The third will come to slaughter his child:
Because of his son two will be pierced by the point,
Genoa, Florence, he will come to confuse them.
This quatrain is often used in reference to the children of King Henry II of France. But if you do just a little research you will find two enormous problems here: 1) Henry had 13 children, 2) only one of his children died in an unnatural way (he was stabbed in the stomach).
10. The French Revolution #9-23 Original French
Return conflict to pass over the tile:
For five hundred one to betray will be titled
Narbonne and Salces we have oil for knives.
This is another case of bad translation from French leading to people wrongly believing that this quatrain refers to Queen Marie Antoinette of France and the revolution. The original reads: “Le part soluz mary fera mittre” and people wrongly translate mary to mean Marie. In addition, they translate thuille to mean the Tuillerie garden which Marie passed on her departure from the royal Palace, but in fact, the word means Tile. Narbonnes is a town in the South West of France that has no relation to the French revolution.
Technorati Tags: Nostradmus, prophecy
Related ListsTop 10 Self-Appointed Messiahs20 Famous Last Words Top 10 Old Wives’ Tales Debunked Top 10 Conspiracy Theories |
SubscriptionsLike this article? Subscribe to the RSS feed to keep 'em coming, or subscribe via email: |
If you find this site helpful, please leave a donation so you can enjoy the spirit of giving too.
Email This Post












1. Cat Skyfire - September 14th, 2007 at 8:42 am
I remember reading a book of Michel de Nostradame’s works. I could still read French then, and it was double columned: One column had the original French, the other the English version, and a line or two about the supposed meaning.
One that really stuck out said something about 1999 and disaster in English. The French verse, however, just send ‘end of a century’ which is a lot less specific.
Course, Prophecies are just fun. Bend them, twist them, anyway you want them.
2. mix2323 - September 14th, 2007 at 9:11 am
makes way more sense then how other people claim to translate these text to what they really mean
3. jfrater - September 14th, 2007 at 9:34 am
Cat: exactly - they have provided people for centuries with fun so they can’t be all that bad - as long as you take it all with a grain of salt.
mix: It does - I guess most people don’t bother to look at the original text.
4. Che - September 14th, 2007 at 2:35 pm
Thuille may well mean tile - but then the Tuileries (one “l” ) were so named because it was the site of a tile factory, before becoming a royal garden. So Thuille - tuileries is a legitimate connection.
Of course, that’s not to say that Nostradamus wrote sensible predictions of anything.
5. Todd Laurence - September 15th, 2007 at 6:57 am
In 1558., Nostradamus, writing to the King, included comments about the Chaldean Alphabet, (numerology). This system produced extraordinary
results, which were verified by senior researchers
at Princeton University, School of Applied Science.
According to Carl Jung, and Prof. W. Pauli, Nobel laureate, physics, number is the most primal
archetype of order in the human mind, i.e., pre-existent to consciousness.
This site offers more details:
http://www.centerforinquiry.ne.....read/2878/
I believe that this quatrain best explains what
I’ve experienced, and my conclusions about a coming supernova….
Century V #53
“The Law of the Sun, (a star) contending with
Venus, (the feminine) appropriates the Spirit
of Prophecy. Neither the one nor the other
will be understood. The Law of the Great
Messiah appears through the Sun, (star).”
6. jfrater - September 15th, 2007 at 7:30 am
Todd: that quatrain is so obscure it could mean virtually anything - what leads you to think we will experience a supernova when we are not due one?
7. ben - September 15th, 2007 at 10:58 am
Finally, someone who actually understands taht nostradamus just generalizing. There are so few details that all of his “prophecies” will be likely to come true sometime.
8. Todd Laurence - September 16th, 2007 at 6:42 am
I posted this site so that you could understand the
the nature of “acausal connections” - and how
I determined what the ‘message’ meant.
http://www.centerforinquiry.ne.....hread/2878
9. jfrater - September 16th, 2007 at 7:15 am
Todd: the minute he said he dreamt of the winning lottery numbers, I lost belief.
10. Milarc - September 29th, 2007 at 1:37 pm
I believe there is a way to connect Hitler to Hister. In a documentary on TLC i watched a few years back it was said that as a young boy Hitler would play by the river Hister.
11. adamlaa - October 28th, 2007 at 8:33 am
the oliver cromwell “butcher” comment, surely this refers to him being a butcher as in killing and butchering people, i.e. the irish campaign he waged was so indsicriminate as to be described as butchery.
12. rob - October 28th, 2007 at 3:37 pm
wow, talk about silly. While I don’t really believe in the ability to predict the future, your “debunking” hardly qualifies. These “quatrains” are hardly intended to be taken literally and yet much of your reasoning is based around taking it literally..
13. davo - December 2nd, 2007 at 10:04 pm
prophecy is a crok. end of story
14. Slammerworm - January 16th, 2008 at 2:18 pm
rob: People do take this stuff seriously, and if you stick around long enough, someone will bring them up in regard to some significant event (9/11!). It’s standard retrofitting, much like the several attempts to define the ‘Great Beast’ of the Bible as a modern, contemporary figure. I’ve heard Reagan, Gaddafi, Saddam and others be charged with being The Beast, and they all turned out to be human.
15. J. - February 6th, 2008 at 2:40 am
Nostradamus is an interesting figure in that virtually all his prophecies deal with negative or evil events. His heritage was Jewish, raised as a Christian, he studied the Kaballah. His divining was in the manner of the occult - so the source of his visions may very well have been Satan. They were written down in such an obscure manner as to make them virtually unintelligible or unverifiable.
16. Vodie - February 6th, 2008 at 1:46 pm
I saw that Lost Book of Nostradamus on the History Channel and all I could think about was the comic book guy from the Simpsons repeating “Nice work, Nostradumbass!”
Worst. Documentary. EVER! ;D
17. cristian - February 8th, 2008 at 10:40 pm
surprised diana didn’t make iy
18. Ghidoran - March 3rd, 2008 at 4:36 pm
In the City of God there will be a great thunder,
Two brothers torn apart by Chaos, while the fortress endures,
the great leader will succumb,
The third big war will begin when the big city is burning.
This is what many people thought that Nostradamus predicted and that it predicted 9/11
Actually it was made by an university student a hundred years after Nostradamus
19. shawn - March 28th, 2008 at 1:16 am
the first quatrain anf the one mentioned by Ghidoran are both incorrect. i have the book and i will write the quatrain later, as at the moment im in my office. i read it before 9/11 and the day i heard about the attack, it sprang into my head. its remarkable i accurate it was
20. rushfan - June 8th, 2008 at 9:00 pm
cool list. i’ve seen so many documentaries about him and as time goes by more and more seem to have come to the same conclusions
21. april a. - June 23rd, 2008 at 12:58 pm
I really love prophecy, in the bible it really breaks it down for u. Jesus already had set the stage for his people to let us know what is to come. Majority of the bible has been furfilled so really there’s no need to dispute Nostradamus predictions a lot of what has been said by him or a few of them can be found in the new testiment and some of the old. Which ever way we know that there’s one book we can count on for full accurancy and that’s the word of God.