This list is my tribute to underrated or lesser known great female vocalists. These are all women who are unlikely to make it to most people’s top ten lists and I really would like to give them some exposure if possible. I must confess that this list is a little self-indulgent as these are some of my favorite singers.
9. Émilie Simon
In May 2003, she released her debut album Émilie Simon. The electronic album was critically acclaimed and went on to become a commercial success. To promote her album, she did numerous live performances and TV appearances all over France. In 2004, she was rewarded with a Victoire de la musique in the ‘Electronic Album’ category for the album. This girl needs to get the acclaim she deserves outside of France!
8. Anika Moa
Anika Moa is well known in New Zealand but not outside. She was given a contract with Atlanta Records in New York, but returned to New Zealand to pursue her music in a more relaxed way. Her albums have all been very successful in her home country and she deserves a lot more international attention. The clip above is “Falling in love again” one of the best songs on her double platinum album “Thinking Room”. One of the coolest parts of the clip above is when Anika is standing outside a 4 Square – one of New Zealand’s oldest grocery store chains – well – cool for me for reasons of nostalgia!
7. Melanie Safka
Melanie had a number of hits ultimately faded from the a list of rock music. She continues to perform to this day but is only known to her most devoted fans from the past. When first released, the song above (Brand New Key) was banned by some radio stations due to the lyrics being interpreted as being sexual innuendo.
6. Julee Cruise
With a distinctive, airy voice, Cruise has recorded three albums, but is probably best known for the lead vocal on “Falling,” the theme song for the cult U.S. television series Twin Peaks. Until recently, she was a frequent collaborator with composer Angelo Badalamenti and film director David Lynch, who produced and wrote the lyrics for most of her songs.
5. Peaches
[WARNING: The clip above contains language that will almost certainly offend some readers] Peaches is not very well known outside of her own genre (electroclash) but she is an astonishingly talented woman. This track was featured in the movie Lost in Translation. Peaches’ music is preoccupied with genderchange identity, and she often plays with traditional notions of gender identity, gender roles, and gender presentation. Her lyrics and live shows self-consciously blur the distinction between male and female; she appears on the cover of her album Fatherfucker with a full beard.
4. Janis Ian
Janis Ian’s most successful single was “At Seventeen,” released in 1975, a bittersweet commentary on adolescent cruelty and teenage angst, as reflected upon from the maturity of adulthood. “At Seventeen” received acclaim from record buyers — it charted at #3 on the Billboard Hot 100 and #1 on the Adult Contemporary chart — and critics, as it won the 1975 Grammy for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance, beating out the likes of Linda Ronstadt, Olivia Newton-John and Helen Reddy. Janis is still performing regularly and recording – for a fee she will even travel to your home and give you a private concert. I have had a number of communications with Janis and she is a lovely lady with a great talent that needs to be more widespread. I recommend visiting Janis’ website and buying some of her music. Alternatively most of her albums are on iTunes – why not contribute some money to increasing her popularity!
3. Carolyne Mas
Carolyne Mas had a great career ahead of her. Unfortunately due to marketing decisions, her career was cut short. She has suffered a great deal in her life – being stabbed nine times in a break in at her home. It is a tragedy that this rising star of rock music had her career cut short by bad marketing decisions. This clip above was actually submitted to Youtube by Carolyne herself. Visit Carolyne’s website and download some great music!
2. Edie Brickell
Edie Brickell made some fame through her song “Goodtimes” which was included as a video clip in all copies of Windows 95 to demonstrate its new video abilities. The clip above was while she was with the New Bohemians before her solo career (she has since rejoined the group). I hear this song on the radio and fell in love with her voice instantly. Brickell is married to Paul Simon and they met while she was performing this song on Saturday Night Live.
1. Cass Elliot
Admittedly Cass Elliot was famous as part of the 60s group the Mamas and the Papas, but I have chosen to include her here because many younger readers won’t know who she is and many people don’t know that she had a solo career after the group split. In the clip above we see one of her great songs California Earthquake – we see her characteristic movement style and her truly astounding voice. What an icon! You may also be unaware that she played a part in the children’s movie Pufnstuf – she even has a large solo singing part in it. You can watch the clip here. Sadly, Cass Elliot (who I think could almost be considered the greatest female pop vocalist of the 20th century) died before her time at the age of 32 of a heart attack (1974).
1. Your Choice
You might have noticed that I only have 9 women on this list. I have spent the last five hours trying to think of a tenth and I can’t. Can you give my tenth lady? Tell me in the comments and I will complete the list!
Afterword
I think the talent of the women above really puts modern music to shame – all of the women above have achieved their greatness through vocal talent – not marketing or publicity. It would be great if the music industry were to return to those days.




















FIRST!
Emmy THe Great is… uh… great.
Free Dominguez from Kidney Thieves has the most haunting voice I’ve ever heard Flyleaf is close but Free is the original
Good to see Anika on there, not just a great talent but generaly great person from what ive been told
Also, Natasha Khan of Bat For Lashes. Check out “What’s A Girl To Do” on YouTube. Linky:
Ooh oh oh!!! Linnea from Those Dancing Days. Linky:
Mindy Smith is my favorite. She is, in my opinion, very underrated.
http://www.myspace.com/mindysmith
Eva Cassidy could make the list.
>
great list! i love emilie simon! never heard of the others though except for Cass Elliot.
I’m so happy Peaches made this list.
That Susan Tedeschi is underrated is is demonstrated by how well she sounds despite the crappy recording equipment used in this clip, and by the funky venue she’s toiling in.
romerozombie: very bjork like video – I like it a lot! The second one is great too!
danielle: I love peaches! She is so unique!
Linda Perry is underrated. People see her piercings and overlook the talent. She’s a singer, a songwriter, and a good producer.
Jane Olivor. Her interpretation of “Some Enchanted Evening” is breathtaking. I saw Melanie Safka twice at Massey Hall in Toronto back in the seventies. I still love her music. And I had one of Cass Elliott’s solo albums. It was great.
Check out the band “Freakwater”. Two great female singers that together are phenomenal.
Lisa Gerrard, check her on youtube, the best female singer ever
So glad that you put Peaches on the list. “***** the pain away”
My favorites are definitely. . .
Imogen Heap – I kept her cd in my player for close to a year. Can’t get enough
Kate Havnevik – Norwegian goddess. Check out her song New Day, so ethereal.
Anya Marina – Very unusual voice
Leona Naess – not much to say, just evokes a very cool vibe.
Feist – indie queen. She actually wrote her latest album while touring with Peaches
Greta from The Hush Sound – so bubbly and fun
Beth from Portishead – sings while chain smoking and still sounds amazing
Angela McCluskey from Telepopmusik – here voice gives me chills
Patti smith maybe…
Wow, that Peaches vid was flippin HORRIBLE!
Nanci Griffith would probably make a list of women with the most beautiful eyes, but her singing talents are underrated.
though known VERY well to the men and women of WWII and most french. In america, Edith Piaf has really died and almost no one of the new generation has any idea who she is. She was and is the voice of france especially in a time of trouble. Edith Piaf gets my vote
geat list though
Allison Sudol from A Fine Frenzy, gets my vote. Her lyrics and voice are truly amazing.
See if you can spot Schiesl in this old film clip. YouTube, what will these young whipersnappers think of next.
I’ve never even heard of any of these people. :/
goof_ball: that is why they are on this list
A fan gave a good tip. Here’s Lisa Gerrard
Oh darn, the links in my other comment didn’t copy and paste correctly. I’m sorry. Here they are, properly now.
Music Box-
Samson-
Better-
No Janis Joplin?
How do you delete a post? I just realized the title was “underrated” female singers.
Em: you don’t – but if you really want me to remove the comment you can ask me and I will
though your last comment made it clear that you added Janis by mistake
Umm… Top 9?
Em, in the battle of singers who sound like Janis Joplin, this woman lost, Genya Ravan
whttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NQX8x5q2cKI
Nm…
I did not notice the bit at the end at first.
Damn multi-tasking!
Anne Previn-Ednaswap
Kirsty MacColl
Genya Ravan’s link doesn’t work
Thank you! And thank you for showing that America’s belief that female singers need to be skinny and blonde doesn’t necessarily mean talent!
Edie Brickell, God I had totally forgotten about her. Usually not my type of music but she’s cool, I can’t resist her voice.
I love Peaches and for number 1 i would have to say regina spektor
violettta villas “oczi cziornyje” (black eyes)
Quote:
In her best years Violetta Villas was a mezzo-soprano whose voice had an extraordinary register and a very wide range of vocal color. It covered four octaves from the tenor middle D3 to the soprano E7. Villas’ best range was from C4 to C6. In her songs she showed a remarkable ability for naturally assimilative styles, and for eliciting a multiplicity of voices. Villas could perform at times as a tenor, alto, mezzo-soprano, and soprano, a unique attribute amongst singers of any gender, in the fields of both classical and popular music.
wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violetta_Villas
I absolutely HATE Peaches. A guy at my school sang it every day last year.. And her voice is so annoying. It makes my ears bleed.
Kimya Dawson:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5bhnG4aqpY
Very under rated local From Durham NC, US. Her voice is just enchantingly Angsty. I wish I could make it to more of her shows.
i agree with ya me, spektor is way underrated, does katie melua count as being underrated
Katie Melua is amazing and definitely underrated.
Yes yes Emmy the Great, I completely agree. She is stupidly talented.
And Kimya Dawson too, although I suspect Juno may go some way to correcting that.
And how Charlotte Hatherley isn’t a huge success is very confusing to me. Bastardo is a classic.
Em..think i might have messed up some of your comments. some comments w/ links have to been approved before they show. might’ve deleted ‘em by mistake. so resubmit if you like.
i’m sorry.
aimee mann, but she might be too famous for this list. some of her songs for ‘magnolia’ were really good.
or Johnette Napolitano from concrete blonde. everybody knows from the movie pump up the volume one of my faves
ani difranco!
This is a Great list!
Excellent choices.
I had some singers in mind.
Beth Gibbbons, Portishead
Erika Winnerstrom, The Harteless Bastards. Must check them out.
Jane Siberry!!!
All of her output is worth seeking out, but her 1988 album “The Walking” is a masterpiece. Here is the video of the title track.
Mac: Read her discography. Juno is Recent, She’s been Playing for years. Just because she’s got a few songs here and there doesn’t mean she’s Rated. How many other people here Know of her???
Martina Topley-Bird
Oumou Sangare
Horrible taste in music. Peaches appears to be a male and so should be removed from the list, or simply removed from the list for lack of real talent.
51. Lyric
as was stated in the 1st paragraph, its his choices. and as was encouraged in the paragraph following his choices…you’ve the option to post your own choices in comments. so if you want your taste in music judged, why not share your selections?
Lyric: peaches likes to dress as a man but she is a woman and she creates her songs 100% alone – she is a masterful musician and deserves a place on this list!
Beth Hart
Toni Childs
Amanada Marshall
Ashley Cleveland
Ellen Foley
Tobey Torres of Snake River Conspiracy
Tairrie B of My Ruin
Sophie B Hawkins
Cass Eliot was before my time but I’ve heard of her because one of her songs is played on Lost at a certain part
The Pierces is my pick
Hi, Great List! I have a few highly underrated female singers to add:
Linda Perry (4 Non-Blondes – Listen to “Fill Me Up” After Hours
Johnette Napolitano (Concrete Blonde)
Sarah Jane Morris (Song: A Horse Named Janis Joplin)
Beth Hart (from Starsearch on TV) (Song: Skin, LA Song, Sky Full of Clover)
And last but definitely NOT least: Carrie Rodriguez – (Song: Keep Your Hat on Jenny – sung with Chip Taylor – Album: Red Dog Tracks
Beth Hart http://youtube.com/watch?v=SrZw8RToN2Y
Toni Childs http://youtube.com/watch?v=Fn-OcqIbHYc
Amanada Marshall http://youtube.com/watch?v=WB8m-y7exww&feature=related
Ashley Cleveland http://youtube.com/watch?v=oBhDJdeXS2U (this is a *****ty live video but all I could find)
Ellen Foley http://youtube.com/watch?v=O7GGXT6StQU
Tobey Torres of Snake River Conspiracy http://youtube.com/watch?v=tEYL8nUjLCs or http://youtube.com/watch?v=OH3qrMnpYD0&feature=related
Tairrie B of My Ruin http://youtube.com/watch?v=8NArCvlFcbA or http://youtube.com/watch?v=OSVe2NHVhhs
Sophie B Hawkins http://youtube.com/watch?v=fVllKtvNHFs
Tracy Chapman http://youtube.com/watch?v=1xZEbcELgpQ
Cristina Scabbia of Lacuna Coil http://youtube.com/watch?v=ixxtnrWb17Y or http://youtube.com/watch?v=Lx58hXh4pVA
My favourite Melanie song is There’s A Chance (Peace Will Come)
52: Cyn
Here’s a few that blow away all but two on this list.