[WARNING: some images may disturb] Whether you believe in miracles or not, there is an enormous amount of documentation for seemingly inexplicable events over the centuries that many people believe to be the work of God Himself. In this list I have tried to pick the ten most interesting of these cases. This list is partly in response to the numerous people who have emailed me complaining of an atheistic bias on the site. Hopefully this will finally prove, once and for all, that we will write and publish lists on any topic and that we are open-minded enough not to exclude certain points of view. Finally, for obvious reasons (see item 1 here), this list does not include any tele-evangelist “faith healers”.
A Marian apparition is an event in which the Virgin Mary is believed to have supernaturally appeared to one or more persons regardless of their religious faith. They are often given names based on the town in which they were reported, or on the sobriquet which was given to Mary on the occasion of the apparition. They have been interpreted in psychological terms as pareidolia, and in religious terms as theophanies. Probably the most famous of these apparitions were the visions of St Bernadette at Lourdes (related item 6 on this list), and three children in Fatima (related item 1 on this list). In both cases, the people involved said that the Virgin Mary gave them predictions of future events and preached prayer and penance. The famous case of Our Lady of Zeitoun took place in Zeitoun, Cairo, and contrary to the norm, the apparition was witnessed by millions of people over a period of 2 to 3 years. The apparition was even caught on film (as seen in the photograph above). The Coptic Orthodox Pope of Alexandria in Cairo issued a statement that the apparitions were real. The Catholic Church has yet to issue an official statement. You can view video footage here.
Incorruptibility is the name given to the situation in which a dead person does not decay after death. The orthodox church consider it essential in considering a person for canonization as a saint, and the Roman Catholic Church consider it as sign of sainthood but not a necessity. Additionally, the Catholic Church believes that a body is not deemed incorruptible if it has undergone an embalming process or other means of preserving the dead, or if it has become stiff, as do all normal corpses, even when the best preservation techniques are used. Incorruptible saints remain completely flexible, as if they were only sleeping. Incorruptible bodies are often said to have the Odour of Sanctity, exuding a sweet aroma. Over the years there have been hundreds of Saints whose bodies have been found to be incorrupt – some many hundreds of years after their death. In the image above we see St Bernadette as she appears today – 129 years after her death. For more astonishing pictures of incorruptible corpses (including the incorrupt body of St Silvan who died over 1,500 years ago), visit the Top 10 Incorrupt Corpses. You can also read a much more indepth article with a photo and video gallery of incorrupt corpses here.
Therese Neumann was a German Catholic mystic and stigmatic. On March 10, 1918, Therese Neumann was partially paralyzed after falling off a stool while attending to a fire in her uncle’s barn. She sustained more falls and injuries during this period. After one particular fall in 1919, she lost much of her eyesight. Therese reported that her eyesight was fully restored on April 29, 1923 — the day Therese of Lisieux was beatified (the first step to sainthood) in Rome. She said that on March 5, 1926, the first Friday of Lent, a wound had appeared slightly above her heart, but that she had kept this secret. However, she did report a vision of Jesus at Mount Olivet with three Apostles. On Easter Sunday, she claimed a vision of the resurrection of Christ. For several consecutive Fridays after that, she stated she was experiencing the Passion of Christ, supposedly suffering in her own body along with all his historic agonies. She especially suffered the Passion on Good Fridays each year. By November 5, 1926, she displayed nine wounds on her head as well as wounds on her back and shoulders (most of which are visible in the image above). According to several sources these wounds never healed or became infected and were found on her body at death. From the years of 1922 until her death in 1962, Therese Neumann said she had consumed no food other than The Holy Eucharist, and to have drunk no water from 1926 until her death. In July 1927 a medical doctor and four Franciscan nurses kept a watch on her 24 hours a day for a two-week period. They confirmed that she had consumed nothing except for one consecrated sacred Host a day, and had suffered no ill effects, loss of weight, or dehydration. Formal proceedings for her beatification were begun in 2005. [Source]
In 1973, Sister Agnes Katsuko Sasagawa in Akita, Japan had visions of the Virgin Mary. On June 28, 1973, a cross-shaped wound appeared on the inside left hand of Sr. Agnes. It bled profusely and caused her much pain. On July 6, Sr. Agnes heard a voice coming from the statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary in the chapel where she was praying. The statue was carved from a single block of wood from a Katsura tree and is three feet tall. On the same day, a few of the sisters noticed drops of blood flowing from the statue’s right hand. The wound in the statue’s hand remained until September 29, when it disappeared. On September 29, the day the wound on the statue disappeared, the sisters noticed the statue had now begun to “sweat”, especially on the forehead and neck. Two years later on January 4, 1975, the statue of the Blessed Virgin began to weep. It continued to weep at intervals for the next 6 years and eight months. It wept on 101 occasions. Scientific analysis of blood and tears from the statute provided by Professor Sagisaka of the faculty of Legal Medicine of the University of Akita confirmed that the blood, tears, and perspiration are real human tears, sweat, and blood. They come from three blood groups: O, B, and AB. Sr. Agnes was also completely cured of total deafness. In June 1988, Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) – head of the Office of Inquisition – judged the Akita events and messages as reliable and worthy of belief.
The apparitions of Our Lady of Lourdes began on 11 February 1858, when Bernadette Soubirous, a 14-year old peasant girl from Lourdes admitted, when questioned by her mother, that she had seen a “lady” in the cave of Massabielle, about a mile from the town, while she was gathering firewood with her sister and a friend. Similar appearances of the “lady” took place on seventeen further occasions that year. During one of the apparitions, she was directed by the “lady” to dig near a rock and drink from the spring there – there was a small puddle of mud in the place but as Bernadette dug in to it, a large spring appeared – this is the source of the water in the grotto to which millions of people flock for miraculous cures every year. The Lourdes Medical Bureau have declared 68 cases of inexplicable cures (out of thousands tested). You can read more on the scientific bureau here. [Source]
Joseph of Cupertino is an Italian saint. He was said to have been remarkably unclever, but prone to miraculous levitation, and intense ecstatic visions that left him gaping. In turn, he is recognized as the patron saint of air travelers, aviators, people with a mental handicap, and weak students. He was canonized in 1767. On October 4, 1630, the town of Cupertino held a procession on the feast day of Saint Francis of Assisi. Joseph was assisting in the procession when he suddenly soared into the sky, where he remained hovering over the crowd. When he descended and realized what had happened, he became so embarrassed that he fled to his mother’s house and hid. This was the first of many flights, which soon earned him the nickname “The Flying Saint.” Joseph’s most famous flight allegedly occurred during a papal audience before Pope Urban VIII. When he bent down to kiss the Pope’s feet, he was suddenly filled with reverence for the Pope, and was lifted up into the air. He experienced ecstasies and flights (witnessed by thousands) during his last mass which was on the Feast of the Assumption 1663. Apple Inc.’s headquarters are in the California town of Cupertino, which was named after this saint. A film (the Reluctant Saint) was made about St Joseph – you can see a small clip of it at youtube (warning: it contains some serious over-acting – but has some humor too). [Source]
Saint Juan Diego Cuauhtlatoatzin was an indigenous Mexican who reported an apparition of the Virgin Mary as Our Lady of Guadalupe in 1531. He had a significant impact on the spread of the Catholic faith within Mexico. According to Juan Diego, he returned home that night to his uncle Juan Bernardino’s house, and discovered him seriously ill. The next morning December 12, Juan Diego decided not to meet with the Lady, but to find a priest who could administer the last rites to his dying uncle. When he tried to skirt around Tepeyac hill, the Lady intercepted him, assured him his uncle would not die, and asked him to climb the hill and gather the flowers he found there. It was December, when normally nothing blooms in the cold. There he found roses from the region of Castille in Spain, former home of bishop Zumárraga. The Lady re-arranged the roses carefully inside the folded tilma that Juan Diego wore and told him not to open it before anyone but the bishop. When Juan Diego unfolded his tilma before the Bishop roses cascaded from his tilma, and an icon of Our Lady of Guadalupe was miraculously impressed on the cloth, bringing the bishop to his knees. The bishop acknowledged the miracle and within two weeks, ordered a shrine to be built where the Virgin Mary had appeared. The original tilma (pictured above) is on display in Guadalupe today and is one of the most frequently visited pilgrimage sites in the world. [Source]
Francesco Forgione, later known as Padre Pio, canonized as Saint Pio of Pietrelcina, was an Italian Roman Catholic Capuchin priest who is now venerated as a saint in the Roman Catholic Church. He was given the name Pio when he joined the Order of Friars Minor Capuchin, and was popularly known as Padre Pio after his ordination to the priesthood. He became famous for his stigmata. Based on Padre Pio’s correspondence, even early in his priesthood he experienced less obvious indications of the visible stigmata for which he would later become famous. Though Padre Pio would have preferred to suffer in secret, by early 1919, news about the stigmatic friar began to spread in the secular world. Padre Pio’s wounds were examined by many people, including physicians. People who had started rebuilding their lives after World War I began to see in Padre Pio a symbol of hope. Those close to him attest that he began to manifest several spiritual gifts including the gifts of healing, bilocation, levitation, prophecy, miracles, extraordinary abstinence from both sleep and nourishment (One account states that Padre Agostino recorded one instance in which Padre Pio was able to subsist for at least 20 days at Verafeno on only the Eucharist without any other nourishment), the ability to read hearts, the gift of tongues, the gift of conversions, and the fragrance from his wounds. Rather than using an image, I have used a video clip of St Pio – you can see his hands concealed by fingerless gloves to hide his stigmata. You may also be interested in this clip in which St Pio’s grave and coffin are opened (on March 3, 2008) revealing that his body is incorrupt. His body is now on display in San Giovanni Rotondo. [Source]
In the city of Lanciano, Italy, around A.D. 700, a Basilian monk and priest was assigned to celebrate the Eucharistic sacrifice in the Latin Rite in the small Church of St.Legontian. Usually celebrating in the Greek Rite and using leavened bread and having been taught that unleavened bread was invalid matter for the Holy Sacrifice he was disturbed to be constrained to use unleavened bread and had trouble believing that the miracle of transubtantiation would take place with unleavened bread. During the Mass, when he said the words of consecration, he saw the bread change into live flesh and the wine change into live blood, which coagulated into five globules, irregular and differing in shape and size. Various ecclesiastical investigations have been conducted upon the miracle, and the evidence of the miracle remains in Lanciano to this day. In 1970-71, Professors from the University of Siena conducted a scientific investigation into the miracle. They concluded that the flesh and blood are human flesh and blood. The Flesh is a heart complete in its essential structure. The Flesh and the Blood have the same blood type, AB, which is also the same blood type found on the Shroud of Turin and all other Eucharistic Miracles. The Host-Flesh, which is the same size as the large Host used today in the Latin Church, is fibrous and light brown in color, and becomes rose-colored when lighted from the back. The Blood consists of five coagulated globules and has an earthly color resembling the yellow of ochre. [Source]
The Miracle of the Sun is an alleged miraculous event witnessed by as many as 100,000 people on 13 October 1917 in the Cova da Iria fields near Fátima, Portugal. Those in attendance had assembled to observe what the Portuguese secular newspapers had been ridiculing for months as the absurd claim of three shepherd children that a miracle was going to occur at high-noon in the Cova da Iria on October 13, 1917. According to many witness statements, after a downfall of rain, the dark clouds broke and the sun appeared as an opaque, spinning disk in the sky. It was said to be significantly less bright than normal, and cast multicolored lights across the landscape, the shadows on the landscape, the people, and the surrounding clouds. The sun was then reported to have careened towards the earth in a zigzag pattern, frightening some of those present who thought it meant the end of the world. Some witnesses reported that their previously wet clothes became “suddenly and completely dry.” Estimates of the number of witnesses range from 30,000-40,000 by Avelino de Almeida, writing for the Portuguese newspaper O Século, to 100,000, estimated by Dr. Joseph Garrett, professor of natural sciences at the University of Coimbra, both of whom were present that day. The miracle was attributed by believers to Our Lady of Fátima, an apparition of the Blessed Virgin Mary to three young shepherd children in 1917, as having been predicted by the three children on 13 July, 19 August, and 13 September 1917. The children reported that the Lady had promised them that she would on 13 October reveal her identity to them and provide a miracle “so that all may believe.” The event was officially accepted as a miracle by the Roman Catholic Church on 13 October 1930. In the image above you can see some of the many witnesses photographed during the event. [Source]
This article is licensed under the GFDL because it contains extracts from Wikipedia (as cited within the body of the text above).




























Funny how, with all the people in the world, miracles are only listed for Catholics…
i guess because this is a catholic site…..
miracles happen to catholics more than others because they are the largest christian group and the oldest. And the reason you hear about catholic miracles more is also because catholics have the most documented miracles with the most evidence. And its funny how all these people on this site like to just throw dumb explanations out their like tens of thousands of people were mistaken about seeing a miracle. just about all of these miracles especially the miracle of the sun and marian apparition were seen by both christians and nonchristians even atheists saw these miracles. And the miracles on the list especially miracle of the sun and marian apparition had many documented healings such as the healing of the blind and handicapped people being able to walk normally and people with deadly diseases healed. IF SOME OF YOU PEOPLE DONT UNDERSTAND THE MIRACLES THATS OKAY BUT DONT MAKE UP SOME CRAPPY EXCUSE TO TRY TO DISCREDIT THEM AND TRY TO DISCREDIT ALL THE PEOPLE WHO SEEN THEM. IF YOU DONT WANT TO BELIEVE OKAY BUT UNLESS YOU CAN FIND HARD EVIDENCE THAT DISCREDITS THOUSANDS OF PEOPLES TESTIMONY EVEN NONCRISTIANS,ATHEISTS,SCIENTISTS,JOURNALISTS AND MANY HIGHLY RESPECTED INDIVIDUALS THEN DONT SAY ANYTHING.
I agree with Anony, I wouldn't believe it unless I saw it.
The incorrupt corpses always looked like wax to me, Have they sone any sort of, exam on the bodies?
These incorruptible bodies have been, yes, thoroughly examined by doctors and scientists. I have seen the body of Bernadette myself in Nevers; she is simply amazing. Sometimes, a thin layer of color is added over the skin because the skin darkens or becomes sickly grey over time. In the case of Bernadette, when they first dug up her grave, the entire coffin was rotten through, as was her clothing. The links of her rosary were all rusty; and yet, she gave off a rosy smell. They washed the body and buried it again. They dug up the body once more years later, and her skin had taken a greyish hue (in part because of the humidity). The covered her skin with a fine layer of colorful wax. All her internal organs, if I recall correctly, are preserved.
Hey. Isn’t it WONDERFUL that the church likes digging up dead people and disturbing their PEACE. Yep so great. So glad I’m not a part of that crap.
Ummmm… Yeah… Actually, the face and hands that you’re seeing ARE wax. Do a bit more research there. Her body is in fine shape for its age, but is still mildewed, mummified, and missing patches of skin.
stevenh: try as I might, there were no astonishing miracles I could find otherwise. And coupled with the fact that the Catholic religion is larger than all the other Christian groups put together, I guess the chances are higher
Oh – the first one is Coptic Orthodox as well – so that is one non-Catholic religion
By “first one” I mean number 10 btw.
stevenh: true – it is interesting – perhaps it is to do with the mysticism side of Christianity – which is an especially large part of Catholicism and lesser so in others. Wikipedia says this:
True on the Coptic. It’s just that I’ve noticed that the followers of Jesus seen to have a lot more appearances (aka apparitions, visions, goasts, images in toast) than other humans on this planet.
so this is the top 10 astonishing things people made up?
anony: I am sure that even a logical non-believer wouldn’t take that line – at least 30,000 people witnessed number 1 – if you are a non-believer surely you would be arguing for something like mass hysteria rather than presuming that many people would just make it up.
The crying, sweating, and bleeding statue doesn’t appear to be a miracle; it’s more like a nightmare! Seriously, how creepy is that?
Very good list Jfrater. I’m always freaked out by miracles cause sometimes they are very convincing and I have to remind my self that there is always an explanation for things.
I think I heard about nr 6 in a Richard Dawkins documentry. Nr 7 is very weird. The flying saint is sort of a fun miarcle
I wouldnt want to be nr 8. It looks messy..
Very cool list. Pretty interesting things to think about for the day. I didn’t realize incorruptible corpse had no embalming processes at all and weren’t stiff.
Interesting List, well thought out and informative.
In order to see a miracle, one must be of a frame of mind that accepts them. I see someone bleeding from wounds of mysterious origin, I’m thinking crack addict picking at imaginary bugs or some sort of mental affliction that causes you to wound yourself consciously or sub-consciously. (Most likely explanation if you ask me) Miracle is not the first thing that pops into mind.
I wouldn’t call #1 mass hysteria. More correctly an atmospheric anomaly (and a pretty common one too! at least in Fatima) coupled with grand expectations and religious fervor. Thus the differing accounts of the same phenomena.
Some Christian sects consider jabbering in Tongues and flailing and flopping around in religious ecstasy to be a miracle of possession. Goes to show you the difference point of view makes.
I wouldnt say this site has an atheist bias. What a silly thing to say.
I appreciate the comments so far – I really wasn’t sure what to expect – but as usual, listverse readers show themselves to be thoughtful in their comments!
Scar: yes – they manipulate the bodies to check for rigormortis – the other unusual feature of them is the smell – people who see the bodies often describe an odor of flowers coming from the corpse.
jfrater: As you said at least 30,000 people witnessed this “miracle” and does the fact that the majority were farmers and poorly education people, with christianity on their minds make a difference? I think so, if UFO’s landed in Saudi Arabia at the time of mohammed, it would have been deemed an act of Allah…
Although the evidence is still somewhat compelling for some of these “miracles”, the witnesses are mostly uneducated, the places are usually rural areas and the times are always long ago.
I’d much sooner believe the account of thousands of witnesses of a “miracle” which appeared above London, New York, Paris, Tokyo or any other widely developed, advanced and populated area, where cameras are readily active, and intelligent people will surely be at hand.
The article points out Intellectual Educated skeptics from the newspaper witnessed the event also idiot.
Just because a person lives in a poor area does not make one uneducated. There are other ways to educate yourself besides school. Its called books.
It never says anywhere that those observing fatima were largely uneducated. This is what is referred to as a straw man argument. Also, "long ago" is a relative term. Fatima may be long ago to many of us but it wasn't "long ago" to those alive when these people claimed to have witnessed this. Many of these miracles were as recent as the 1970's…hardly so long ago that there is no one yet alive to refute them. I find it odd that you assume that a person's geographical area deems all the people who live there as being idiots. I'm sure the likes of Neitzche, Ghandi, Einstein, Darwin, Nelson Mandela, and the many thousands of other geniuses who were born and raised in rural areas would be inclined to disagree with you on your assertion.
Raz: there were scientists and skeptics present – who were there in order to debunk the whole thing and report that nothing happened – but then something did happen. Here is a quote from wikipedia:
This is one of many from Doctors, Priests (who were certainly not uneducated), and reporters of highly respected papers. Something definitely happened – I guess the question is – what?
Someone said of miracles “To the believer, no explanation is necessary; to the unbeliever, no explanation is possible”.
Compared to the extensive debunking of psychics elsewhere, this list tends to accept at face value all the claims made.
So far as I have read, all these occurrences happened in communities where strong faith was already part of the group conscious and subconscious. People were brought up with the belief that “miracles happen”. They may not have been expecting to see a miracle, but they were open to the possibility. The physic debunker (I’ve forgotten his name) expects not to see physic powers, so therefore doesn’t.
I have a few more comments, but I’ll sleep on them first before I start treading on toes, or deciding not to.
astraya: the psychic debunker is mentioned in the intro – with a link to the list of his debunkings
I appreciate what you are saying about expectations – but how does a person’s expectation cause a statue to bleed? The secretions were tested in a science lab.
Surely there is a better explanation than simply “people were ignorant” or “people were brainwashed” – the explanations so often given without a thought – something more firm would be nice
Incidentally – that is not a criticism of you specifically – it is a criticism of people who don’t believe but aren’t willing to try to find evidence for their views.
I don’t say these are real or not – I am just presenting them – but the fact remains – in all of the above cases no hard evidence can explain conclusively the cause of the events.
from a believer’s standpoint, i can concur that they happened, but what was the source is a different question. the purpose of a miracle, as reported in the bible, is to bring glory to God, not the person demonstrating or experiencing said miracle. the response in the miracle of tilma of juan diego is to build a shrine to mary? most of the books of 1 and 2 kings in the old testament talks about how one kings sets up “high places”(altars and shrines to other gods) and was seen as doing evil and then how another king tears those places down and is seen as doing pleasing things in the sight of God.
i definately have a place for the acceptance of miracles done by God in my theology. i’m not so sure these qualify.
Interesting list, Jamie. I had never heard of incorruptibles. I must have missed your prior list but now I am all caught up.
I believe miracles are what you make of them. Who am I to say what others believe is false or dumb? I say this because I can already see the heat this topic will cause and I think we all need to remember that none of us is better than any other. Let’s respect each others rights and beliefs. Mmkay?
one of the funny thing i think about skeptics is that they assume that all involved are idiots.
how arrogant is it to believe that the only reason people believe is because they haven’t been enlightened to your powers of rationality. do you not think that the other skeptics in the area have shown up to try and disprove these phenomena also?
about Padre Pio: a italian historian has written in a book that the ‘more or less’ Saint buyed a lot of phenol acid from a pharmacist for making wounds on his hand. And also another critical point of view argue on the wrong position of the wounds.
sorry for english errors
(
The miracle of the Sun is what nowdays will be considered a first contact, an UFO sighting. Maybe there’s something out there that we still don’t undersand, but in any case we’ll reach it through real science some day.
Some others are just fake. So many bleeding statues have been appeared and they were all fake. Ah! Of course, after 99 demonstrated fake ones the number 100 wouldn’t have any trick and will be a miracle.
Trying to relate all this incidents with religios miracles is just hilarious. Every time someone makes his invention, Vatican authorities send some “experts” to report it. If the trick isn’t obvious they will say it’s a miracle and use it as propaganda for the dying faith.
Sad to say, I wasn’t expecting much, bt after reading number ten I expected great things. Then I read the rest of the list, and I felt it to be too similar in terms of content. Also, some parts suggest it to be an excuse for the aethist lists/biases on this site. But overall, 3/5
Wow, Jamie is defending this list like there’s no tomorrow…
Anyways, I found it quite interesting, given that these miracles seem to be well-documented. I liked #1 the most, and I hadn’t heard of it before (although I’d heard of story of the Lady of Fatima’s visions). Even if it was some sort of unusual atmospheric phenomenon, how the hell would anyone, let alone three shepherd children, know exactly when it was going to happen?
I consider myself deeply rational and skeptical. I don’t ascribe myself to any religion, but I do believe in God in a way that religions do not define. Some have already said that these things happen only in communities that expect these kind of things to happen at some level. I think that being open to the possibility is certainly a factor that somehow allows these phenomena to happen: not because people have been brainwashed into seeing things that aren’t really there, but because they have a mindset that allows them to expect and see these phenomena.
I believe that the power of the mind has been severely underestimated especially in modern times; so if thousands or even millions of people strongly believe in the same thing with fervor, isn’t there a slight chance that their minds alone may be able to somehow trigger strange effects in reality?
If we already knew the answers to oh-so-many mysteries yet to be explained in this world, I would say no. But there’s still so much we don’t know or understand yet, that I’m compelled to say at least “maybe”.
Keep an open mind, everyone. You might end up being witness to things you never expected to see…
PS. I want to see the video footage of the Marian apparition, but I’m too scared!
I love pseudo-skeptics. They spend all their time screaming, “There’s no evidence,” but when someone DOES present evidence (like this list) they all just grumble about how the witnesses are uneducated rubes, victims of brainwashing, or make the even more absurd claim that they all just “made it up.”
Atheists are no different from Creationists. Both groups decide offhand that fact which contradict their beliefs are not “facts” at all, and dismiss them without a second thought.
At least Theists have the decency to ADMIT that we make leaps of faith.
When I think of miracles I always think of fraud, halucinations, drugs or disease in the water or food.
Illusionists create miracles all the time and in view of hundreds of people. So, why can’t these miracles be Illusions as well?
Also, incorruptible corpses seems amazing! But I don’t understand no.2, does bread and wine still turn into flesh and blood?
The Incorruptible corpse is pictured wearing a wax mask I think. The skin stills rots away does it not?
#31 Ghidoran
Catholics believe that the bread and wine is the body and blood of Christ, but in most cases this is a spiritual change, not a physical one. It’s more than a symbol, but anyone with taste buds can tell it’s still physically the same as it was before the blessing. Even for the most devout Catholic an actual physical change, like what happened in #2, would be an immensely shocking experience.
Did anyone else really like the religious muzak that plays when you open up the video of the Marian Apparition in Zeitoun?
Also to Warning Don’t Read This (#10),
I’ll bet that Richard Dawkins was VERY accepting of this miracle in his film.
yun: i was thinking the same thing
Kowzilla: Oh you know Dawkins he smiled and was very nice and complimented the nice americans that sat on their chairs waiting to be blessed.
Kreachure: Me too.
There is always an explanation. Cant say that enough.
And now we’re talking about UFOs? This keeps getting better.
I am not Catholic and I am highly skeptical of supposed Catholic miracles. I do believe, however, that God both can and does perform miracles, so I do not immediately discredit the items on this list. The incorruptible corpses is particularly interesting to me as it could potentially be studied and verified. Sitings of apparitions, however, are difficult to reproduce. The miracle of the sun is also intriguing and clearly not an eclipse or some such phenomenon.
As both a Christian and a student of Psychology, I see an interesting pattern where those who believe in miracles are the ones who see them. Christians call it the power of faith. Psychologists describe it as our expectations becoming a sort of self-fulfilling prophesy. But we should understand that just as the mind and body are not separate creatures, a person’s spirituality and cognition are also tied. An explanation for one does not negate the other, but enriches the experience for both. In other words, Psychology may be right about how the brain functions in order to allow the belief in the supernatural, but that does not necessarily mean there is not also a spiritual component. And I would guess that there is! After all, if God made us and wanted us to believe, he would have given our brains the capacity to think in that way.
So how could all of those people stand there for all that time looking directly into the sun in mid afternoon without some sort of protection for their eyes?
Great list JFrater.
I always believe that there are many things in life / nature / universe that we do not know about. Just because we don’t know, or cannot comprehend them, doesn’t mean they are fake or fraud.
A tribe living in the amazonian rain forest would be equally disbelieving about an aeroplane, as we are about so called visions and apparitions.
It’s also funny how we take electricity, telephones, wireless, air & space travel, computers, internet, almost everything in our daily lives as matter-of-fact, when just a few hundred years ago all these everyday things would have been deemed as miracles.
Miracles do happen… I have witnessed them twice when was in IOW…
but the things I see India which people say they are miracles are actually not!!!
My Cousin Pat’s wife who is an Indian took me to some one who is famous for doing healings and miracles (ppl who want to know what my problem is can check a list(amazing facts about dreams)
the place were went was horrible or I say more than that…it was very scary… it was a small dark room and many people sitting out side in a row… and If anyone remembers the movie of Indiana Jones and the temple of doon – in that you will have an idol called Kalimaa… I saw that idol in *Place* and there was fresh blood on it…
and i almost fainted the very moment…
I didn’t agree to stay there at all as I thought they are devilish…
So Miracles do happen even by Bad people!!!
That is incredible. I’m not Catholic (rather, Jewish) but I do believe that many of these events are beyond scientific explanation. Incorruptible corpses? That lady has been dead for 129 years! That’s unbelievable.
Some of these should be able to explain, however, the incorrupt bodies just baffles me.
I looked for some explanation, however, people can only hypthoesize that its “very slow decomposition”
JB: You believe in UFO’s but you dismiss everything on the list as fake and “just hilarious”. The same could be said about your UFOs.
Quote: “Every time someone makes his invention, Vatican authorities send some “experts” to report it. If the trick isn’t obvious they will say it’s a miracle and use it as propaganda for the dying faith.”
Skepticism relating to this list is great, and engaging in dialog between believers and non-believers is very positive and healthy, but this close-minded tirade is damaging. It angers the believers and it discredits the non-believers.
DicHuker: I agree with your comment one hundred percent. It is often a sign of overwhelming arrogance as well as stubbornness that leads people to not only completely dismiss the views and beliefs of others but insult them as well. Its funny how you never see believers going on to the lists which have a more or less atheistic angle telling everyone who doesn’t believe that they are going to hell. Everybody always scoffs and laughs at those who believe asking us to prove outright that there is a God, and then laugh when we can provide no evidence which lives up to their standards. However, I have yet to see any athiest or skeptic give convincing and definitive evidence that God, or a god does not exist. The fallacy can work both ways people.
Jfrater: I find this list very interesting, just like 99% of the lists on this site! I’m not a catholic myself, but I am a Baptist and I find a few of these to be persuading(#10 #2 and #9). I often don’t believe eyewitness accounts unless there are multiple accounts of them which agree. It is just too easy for someone to fabricate a miracle for their own glory, not God’s. And yes I am an educated person and am quite skeptical about many things as well. I choose, however to believe in a higher power which humans, as of yet cannot explain, and probably never will.
JB: Get over yourself, where is all of your evidence proving that each of these miracles is fake? Other than your “impressive” powers of reasoning you have provided nothing which supports your claims. Also I find it funny that someone can dismiss claims such as these (and any religious claim, miraculous or not) so easily, yet believes in UFOs which have even less recorded accounts and evidence for their existence.
wow, great list, very well thought out, #1 I would classify as mass hysteria though.
*DiscHuker not DicHuker, ha ha sorry!
If God appeared in the sky and said, in what has to be a de facto booming voice, “I am God, believe in me.”….would you? If you saw God for yourself, would you believe..just like that? Would you start praying everyday, listening to Him, acting like He wants us to? Or would you blame the experience on drugs, or a gas leak, or a sign of your pending insanity?
Miracles aren’t a one shot cure for skepticism or hostility.
Raz: re#29- “I’d much sooner believe the account of thousands of witnesses of a “miracle” which appeared above London, New York, Paris, Tokyo or any other widely developed, advanced and populated area, where cameras are readily active, and intelligent people will surely be at hand.”
Are you saying that rural, uneducated people are not intelligent? Are you saying intelligent people are only found in large, developed cities? If so, that is a very prejudiced comment to make. Formal education does not equal intelligence. There are many intelligent people who have had no formal education. Just because someone lives in a rural, under-developed area does not automatically make them unintelligent.
Nice list and well researched jfrater. There is a pretty good movie called “The Song of Bernadette” staring Jennifer Jones about the Lourdes miracle
as always a fantastic list, but it saddens me to see so many people being so rude about others beliefs. if you don’t beleive thats fine if you do thats fine as well, but mocking or disrespecting is not a great way to start any kind of conversation/debate, just my two cents worth
DiscHuker: you hit the nail on the head. Many of these “Miracles” don’t bring glory to God, but rather to the recepient of the event, such as candidacy for sainthood, or the desire to worship someone other than God Himself (i.e. Mary). We have been specifically warned about such deceptions by God himself.
To those who profess no faith in the supernatural whatsoever, I say that it takes a much bigger leap of faith to believe that things arrived at the current order from chaos than to believe a creator was involved. Evidence of a creator is the creation itself, or perhaps you think that the computer you are looking at right now “just happened”.
As a final note to the non-believers, when I say you have more faith than believers, I really mean it. You have so much faith in your viewpoint that you are willing to risk punishment for eternity without any payoff. Good luck with that.
I can’t believe some people would e-mail in saying the site is too atheist. Have they not seen all the unbiased religous lists, especially the one listing quotes to support faith?
I’ve always thought atheism (or agnosticism) was pretty much the default setting for people. After all, you can only believe in what you’re taught to believe in.
Joey Ramone believes in this list.
Holly crap!
my high school is named Our lady of lourdes High school after the lourdes miracle!
I certainly do not think that offering skeptical alternatives to the described miracles above is in any way arrogant, stubborn, or ignorant. I think that doing so in a cock-sure, arrogant, conceited way is stubborn and ignorant. Those who so readily dismiss the beliefs of another and all the peripheral evidence as bunch of hooey are deluding themselves into a kind of superior knowledge. This is disingenuous. There have been thousands of people, thousands of times smarter than any one person on this board who have pondered theological questions and never arrived at a satisfactory answer. To operate as if you are one of the privileged few that have a bit of knowledge so far above the heads of everyone else that all who are not privy are somehow “beneath” you is ignorant. Those that do this are often trying to prove something to themselves, so if you are a believer, pay no attention to these persons. They will eventually dig their own holes.
However, that being said, I also think it is disingenuous for believers to so readily accept these “miracles” as true signs from God, without asking any questions whatsoever. It is not arrogant to suggest that suggestive psychology and lack of education might have parts to play in the perception of a miracle, as the suggestive power of the mind has been scientifically proven to be incomprehensibly powerful, and the lower the level of education, the greater the reliance on religion as a tool of social solidarity. As someone has suggested already, magians have concocted elaborate illusions that, if the base audience was not already aware of our present technological capabilities, would appear to be miracles, or works of powerful magic. There are many phenomena that have been observed that occur for one reason or another that can function parallel to one another and produce the results of what we see here. Coupled with powerful imaginations and strong, base desires for spiritual vindication, there is a strong possbility that scientific, natural explanations exists for all of the events listed above.
jfrater:
This was a great list Jamie… deserving of a spot somewhere in some future book of lists, even. Well done and well-researched.
I’ve never heard a convincing explanation for what happened at Fatima, though I’m open to ideas. Earth lights never did it for me.
The fave explanation for stigmata, of course, is that it is self-inflicted–even unknowingly so. Perhaps, but it too always fell a tad short for me… that is, if all stories about stigmatics can be wholly believed. (pardon the pun).
I wish people could just act like the adults they tell themselves they are in their more self-important moments. I am an atheist, but I absolutely hate those of us that go around acting as if all religious people are ignorant. That is simply untrue, and anyone who would suggest that are themselves ignorant. That being said, I also find quite annoying those fervent believers that are as arrogant to believe that atheists care even a little bit about the reasons they will supposedly “go to hell.” I find it also quite hypocritcal that those people charge atheists with “leaps of faith,” as if they themselves were making the obviously more rational and logical choice and atheists are simply deluded. If anyone even has the guts to read this far into the passage, I would like to ask all the reasonable adults out there to please respect the beliefs of other people. This has become a problem on both sides around the LV recently, and it needs to stop. Anyone who does not wish to conduct themselves with a bit of deference can navigate away to another site. If these rampant problems don’t change, drastic measures might be in order.
This might be one of the best lists on listverse. Very interesting, creepy and thought inspiring.