As a follow up to the list of most overrated bands, this list has been composed to illuminate the names of bands that should be better recognized but somehow missed their chance at the spotlight. If you are anything like me and spend hours scouring the net for new bands to listen to, give some of these a try – especially if you have never heard of them – you may be pleasantly surprised.
Wolfsheim were a Hamburg, Germany industrial-pop band that took their name from a character in The Great Gatsby. They rose to fame in their native country in 1991 with “The Sparrows and the Nightingales,” and soon became MTV Germany mainstays with their song “Dream of You.” Their music was a hypnotic blend of Darkwave and synthpop. Thanks to such momentous tracks as “Find You’re Gone” and “Kunstliche Welten,” they remain a great impact on European industrial music.
Since their formation in 1998, South has become one of England’s most prominent alternative bands, their music encompassing everything from folk to hard rock to, at times, what could pass for Coke jingles, and are able to make it all come together. Each member is a multi-instrumentalist and are fond of trading instruments in order to change the flow of each song.
David Tibet conceived Current 93 in the early 80s and transformed it over time into a protean amalgam of folk and Coil-influenced dark ambient. Their subject matter accumulates mythology, religion, the occult, and British horror films. Though Tibet has been the only constant member of the band, his apocalyptic folk has developed enough over time for his songwriting abilities to take chameleon shifts.
Man Man are a primal rant-vaudeville act hailing from Philadelphia who gained cult status for their bizarre and supercharged live shows, in which band members dressed in war paint and white leotards, frantically playing horns, guitar and Ragtime piano. Thanks to the success of their performance at Lollapalooza, songs like “Feathers” and “Top Drawer” have affected almost everyone who heard them, and their stint on the main stage at the Voodoo Festival all but cemented their burgeoning rise as an underrated band. There really is no other band in the same category as this one.
Echo and the Bunnymen should have been recognized as the most seminal post-punk band band of the 80s, but instead were ignored thanks to the success of such bands as U2, Depeche Mode and The Cure. Thus, they are more popularly known in the American mainstream for contributing songs to the soundtracks of films like Pretty in Pink and The Lost Boys. Truth be told, Echo are a ferocious incarnation of Television’s guitar power and the Pixies’ breathtaking melodies, as songs like “Silver” and “Rescue” so clearly implicate; they are also one of many unsung influences on modern underground rock. Their one moment of mainstream success was a series of UK Top 10 hits in the early 80s, and then a gradual fade from the limelight, though they continue recording to the present day.
Before there was Grinderman, before there was Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, there was this haunting troupe of perverted, bleak and uncannily enjoyable misfits, fronted by Australia’s esoteric, quintessential frontman Nick Cave. Their songs could go at a slow ambient pace, build up to a tense ruckus of soundscapes, and then burn out in a mushroom cloud of distortion at breakneck speed. Every track was an assault, whether it crept up on you and bludgeoned you from behind or smashed into your conscious with full force. Another seminal influence on the goth/punk genres that deserve a wider fan base.
Although they are hailed as the most popular American indie band of the 90s, Pavement’s music still refuses to merge with the cultural masses despite such phenomenal and groundbreaking albums as Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain and Wowee Zowee. They were the acme of slacker rock, rivaling only the Sex Pistols in terms of, can they really play their instruments or is this a very imaginative sham? This genre-defying band demands the same mass recognition that critics have realized since the band’s conception.
The grandfathers of goth rock are still mainly credited for contributing the song “Bela Lugosi’s Dead” to the David Bowie film The Hunger. What most people don’t know is that the band had more than a handful of compositions that came close to outmatching that timeless track. Songs like “Burning From the Inside” vitalized the engine of black-on-black punk, while B-Sides like the incendiary “Boys” showed that as a lyricist, Peter Murphy was a bitingly satirical writer and didn’t always have to rely on funereal imagery to make a memorable tune.
Long hailed as Norway’s answer to Nine Inch Nails, Stephan Groth has been recording under the Berzerk moniker since 1989, creating a wicked and catchy combination of synth groove and industrial metal, turning out dance-ready songs like “Kathy’s Song,” slow ethereal ballads like “Nearer,” and the hard-rocking futurepop classic “Tuning to the Frequency of Your Soul.” His instrumental range is rather limited on the outset, but the styles that Groth usurps, he has perfected.
Following the success of outstanding albums like The Holy Bible and Everything Must Go, Manics were on their way to North America and instant stardom when core songwriter and troubled genius Richey James Edwards suddenly went missing in 1995. Since then, the Manics transformed themselves into something of a supertrio, churning out powerpop and indie-oriented compositions that made them heroes in their native Wales and darlings of the European media. Yet they never captured the dark, biting brilliance of those first four albums thanks to Edwards’ brooding confessional stream-of-consciousness around which the band was challenged to make the most phenomenal music of their career so far; thus a broader appreciation continues to elude them, without the writer of such timeless songs as “Yes” and “Faster” to keep them inspired to greater, more innovative peaks.
The new kings of New York goth-pop have been getting shortended since their conception for emulating bands like Joy Division and the Chameleons. What critics don’t see under the simulacra is a Fab Four in the making, creating atmospheres in their songs like no other band today. Their debut album, Turn On the Bright Lights, is unrecognized as a modern masterpiece of Velvet Underground/New Wave counterculture. Songs such as “Leif Erikson,” “The Lighthouse” and “Pace is the Trick” reinforce the necessity of emotion lacking in today’s corporate concoctions, while almost every other song from their first three albums deserved to be a hit single. Some may call the band formulaic and tedious. Only to those who aren’t listening.
Contributor: F. McClure































I think Gil Mantera’s Party Dream (now called simply GMPD) is a criminally overlooked. Those guy are easily one of the best live bands I’ve ever seen. I saw Man Man open for Modest Mouse a few years ago also. I have to admit though that I don’t get Bauhaus or Pavement as being underrated.
Hello, can you help me
Fab list, I love The Manics!!!
Great list. Have to say i have’nt heard of any of these bands besides for interpol. But it does give me something to check out. I am really sick of american music. The mainstream bands today just don’t have the same feeling anymore.
This list is pretty awesome. Never heard of Man Man but I will have to check them out :]
Man this list was the ***** im always into new music, Some other bands to check out, cold war kids, refused, one minute silence, the mr.T Experience, the Lawrence arms, just to name a few anyways good job on this list and keep the lists coming it gives my life here in Alaska a little happiness knowing I have something new and interesting to read everyday.
I saw Man Man last year and would recommend a live show over an album. You just can´t match that energy and random acts of crazy on a recording. Also, as much as I love Pavement, I´d never consider them underrated, same goes for the Bunnymen.
And by the way, before there was the Birthday Party there was Boys Next Door. Interesting list though.
We could also mention the band Gang of Four. Interpoll and the whole nu post-punk scene are influenced by this band!
I’ve actually heard of one of these! I really enjoy the sound of Manic Street Preachers. They got a little time on my favorite radio station in Tucson. If they’re any indication of the talent on this list, I’ll have to check out the rest.
Apoptygma Berzerk, excellent to them at #2. very cool list..
hahaha! love it!
F. McClure – awesome list!
Echo and the Bunnymen are a longtime favorite of mine, and Bauhaus is epic. There are a few bands here I don’t know, but I’ll definitely look them up. Thanks!
I suppose a lot of this is about what you consider under-rated. For me, a couple of bands who could’ve been/should be bigger are ‘Urge Overkill’ and ‘And You Will Know Us By The Trail of Dead’.
Another good example of being under-rated are ‘The Von Bondies’ who very much live in the shadow of the ‘White Stripes’ and I personally never rated them until I saw their London gig last year; the most surprisingly good show I’ve ever seen.
As for the bands on the list, Interpol is a good choice, but I’ve always considered Bauhaus to be over-rated. Also for us in the UK, the Manics can hardly be missed.
Yay Birthday Party!! I love them, wish I’d been old enough to see them when they were around. Nick Cave has mellowed somewhat in his older days. Check out The Dirty Three (Bad Seeds violinist Warren Ellis’ other band), Josh Pearson, Chrome Hoof, ***** Buttons….most of the bands I listen to are well underrated. Wouldn’t agree with the Manics being on this list, at least not in the UK and Ireland. They were huge in the 90s.
There’s a really good movie out there called ‘Dig’ which features the relative ego driven/drug fuelled decline of the ‘Brian Jonestown Massacre’ against the unstoppable rise of the pop friendly ‘Dandy Warhols’.
What you don’t get from the movie is how much better Brian Jonestown are than the Warhols. I’ve seen both in recent years and there’s no comparison.
The movie is really entertaining but it does a dis-service by overrating one band and underrating another.
Pavement and Manic Street Preachers!!!!!! This list wins just for having those two! Manics were underated in the States because Holy Bible was banned and their image wasn’t right in an era when the grunge look ruled all.
My contribution would have to be LostAlone, a little band from Derby, England who are absolutely incredible, check them out.
Under neon loneliness, I want a range life.
Good list but The Crimea should definitely be included somewhere
Man Man is my favorite! I was able to discover them when some of their songs were played on Weeds.
nice one!!!
echo and the bunnymen, bauhaus, pavement, manic sp and the bday party !!…theyre all on my playlist
What are good albums from each of these bands?
Manic’s aren’t underrated. Every album they have receives loads of mainstream radio airplay.
Interpol is definitely not underrated…at least not where I live…if anything, they’re overrated in my town.
I’m really happy that you included Pavement, here’s how’d i’d describe their albums:
Slanted and Enchanted – low-fi hippie punk C+
Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain – Folky grunge A-
Wowee Zowee – Post-punk masterpiece, genre bending A+
Brighten the Corners – Deep pop songs B+
Terror Twilight – Chill and earthy tones A-
Some songs to check out:
Range life, Conduit for Sale!, Cut your Hair, Gold soundz, 5-4=Unity, Rattled by the Rush, Grounded, Western Homes, Serpintine Pad, Fight This Generation, Father to a Sister of Thought, Stereo, Shady Lane, Date with Ikea, Passast Dream, Spit on a Stranger, Major Leagues, Ann Don’t Cry, Billie, Carrot Rope, Painted Soliders (no particular order)
I play music professionally (i don’t get paid alot, so maybe semi-professional, lol) and i’d have to say Pavement’s a heavy influence on my music, stephan malkmus is some kind of super genius.
Bauhaus underrated ?!?!?! Ahm… Bauhaus is one of the most popular bands !
i thought manic street preachers were huge! i saw them live last year at one of the biggest festivals in the UK, they were quite good but i ran back to the main stage to see the killers
haha
My favorite band is the Mentors. not many people have heard of them, but they have been around since 1976 with a great metal sound that was ahead of its time. though they go out of their way to be the most offensive band ever, they really do have talent. You Axed For It, Up the Dose, and To the Max are usually considered their best three albums. after To the Max, lead singer/drummer El Duce was killed in a suspicious accident and ever since then they have had four or five members instead of the classic three, changing singers on occasion. They are a lot like my band, three normal guys with a perverted sense of humor who just decided to pick up instruments. You can see their interviews and a few music videos on youtube, but the most important thing is to not take anything they say seriously as that’s the problem most people have with them.
Manic street preachers are not underated at all, everyone fully appreciates how good they are?
Not good
Bauhaus and Interpol definately
A hell of a lot better than the overrated bands list which should be *****ing removed.
At least this one sort of makes up for it…
I’m glad you included Interpol, I feel they don’t get the credit they deserve…Antics is one of their best.
The only band I had heard of was Echo & the bunnymen….I guess I have some research to do here. Thanks! Love being lead to new bands. Keep these types of lists coming!
Cool list. Seems like every guy I met in the early 90′s was into Bauhaus. My husband likes Echo and the Bunnymen, I never got into them. I also like The Church and Legendary Pink Dots for this list.
Man Man just basically is Tom Waits, but they are still great
Most underrated band of the moment I think is the Animal Collective, but hopefully their new album will change that.
there will definitely be a lot of requests for another list of underrated bands…..
how bout the pixies, they were really underrated back then..or the chameleons uk? the church were celebs in australia i think
I love this list!
Also, please check out The Servant. They’re a great british band that make fantastic music.
Great list!
I was siked to see Wolfsheim on here. I used to like them quite a bit. I recommend the song “Once In a Lifetime” by them. It’s got some of the most beautifully sad lyrics I have heard. (Specifically, ‘you took my wife my unborn son, torn into the deep of the ocean, I don’t pretend that i love you, ’cause there is nothing left to lose’)
There are a couple on this list I haven’t heard before, I’ll have to check them out!
Nice list, with some of my favorites included–Echo and the Bunnymen (I was a huge fan in college), Manic Street Preachers, The Birthday Party…
But Interpol? Agreed they may be “underrated” in a sense… but when I hear them I still can’t help thinking they’re just Joy Division wannabees.
Anyone like the Icelandic band Sigur Ros? Definitely an underrated band. Here are some of my favorite songs from the group, check them out:
Hoppipolla (Hopping in Puddle
Untitled #4 (Njósnavélin or The Nothing Song)
Saeglopur (A Lost Seafarer)
Bummer, I’ve heard of Echo and the Bunnymen. And I was going for the shutout!
nice list only knew half of them. Some others to consider: The Alarm, Blotto, *****Robin, Combichrist, DaVinci’s Notebook, Einsturzende Neubauten, Flipper, The Fools, Gang Green, Hawkwind, Honeymoon Suite, Joboxers, Lords of Acid, Mekons, Method of Destruction/Stormtroopers of Death, Mr Zipp, The Nails, Nash the Slash, Nightwish, OhGr, POD, Project Pitchfork, Psychostick, Screaming Blue Messiahs, Shriekback, Sigue Sigue Sputnik, The Smithereens, Stephen Lynch, 2 Nice Girls, Tom Lehrer, TPOH, Triumph, Voivod, Wolfgang Press, ad Zodiac Mindwarp.
I saw Man Man open up for Modest Mouse last year, and they put on one hell of a live show! If you get a chance to see them, I’d definitely recommend that you go.
Love South and Interpol!
Haha, never heard of any of these bands.
blaze fielding – I saw Manic Street Preachers at Leeds Festival last year, what they were doing on the NME Stage I don’t know, they’ve headlined the Main Stage before and easily could have again. Up against the overrated band The Killers they’re underrated these days.
And I saw them supporting Foo Fighters, dunno what that was all about.
Thanks for talking of Man Man!!!
I’m a big fan since a couple of years and it always seems like I’m the only one who knows about them.In every party I’m going I put discretely one of their records and I wait for reactions,it never takes too long for someone to ask what is this great band.Even my mom could’nt resist to their unsane greatness!!!I’ve seen them last year here in Montreal and it was one if not the best show I’ve seen in my life…their records are really great but live they are unbelievable!!!
I decided to check these bands on last.fm and I got the stats for a couple of them:
Wolfsheim: 2,225,785 plays (102,988 listeners)
Echo & the Bunnymen: 4,356,394 plays (356,482 listeners)
Manic Street Preachers: 10,155,610 plays (452,024 listeners)
Statistically Wolfsheim seems to be the most underrated, unless Wolfsheim’s just not that good.
Me too at first I thought Man Man sounded a bit like Tom Waits but the more you listen to them the more you hear their uniqueness.They’re not trying to sound like anyone,they really don’t need too.
You should divide this list and create a series by genre. This is far too broad.
I could rifle off about 100 underrated bands (of various types of musics) in my collection.
Echo & The Bunnymen’s cover of the Doors’ “People are Strange” is one of my favorite cover songs.
Underrated? Try unheard-of.
Any list that includes Bauhaus is the greatest list, ever.
Although I must admit, this list can be a little too open to interpretation.
Interesting list, I’ll check out those bands I hadn’t previously heard of. Honestly though, I scrolled downwards expecting someone fantastically obscure at #1 and was thunderstruck to see the Manics there (I realise others have said it but I’m in a redundant kind of mood today). They had a period of being fairly huge in the mainstream here in the UK and are still very well regarded.
I thought of a couple of bands I consider underated but it occurs to me it’s less a question of being underated and more one of being overlooked by the mainstream media outlets and labels which prevents them from achieving anything more than modest success. Further to that thought I wonder if some of the best little-known artists are only so good because they are not constrained by the demands of the mainstream. I think the powers that be think the masses only like dross and urge musicians to be as drossful as possible in order to make a buck.
Anyhoo, thanks for the heads up on some interesting sounding bands.
I realise I spelled it wrong, but the two Rs in underrated always seem to jar me somehow.
Yes!
The manics are amazin
I think Live should be on this list, with great tracks as ‘I Alone’ and ‘Lightning Crashes’ etc.
I’ve only heard about nr.1 and bonus
More music to DL…. but they all sound interesting in print
I think you could also consider ‘Bad Brains’ as underrated.
Hooray for Pavement!
THIN LIZZY
INTERPOL FTW.
Never heard of these, I could make a list of bands that are my favorite and no ones ever heard of either.
And pretty much every band that is good now is underrated because every band that is famous is over-rated. This this was an impossible list because of so many equally tallented groups that should have been recognized is in the thousands.