Top 10 Composers Who Died Unnatural or Odd Deaths
- Published May 21, 2009 by ChevalierDupin - 63 Comments
Over the years of reading and research, I’ve come across some rather interesting facts about the great classical composers, especially regarding several who unfortunately left this life in rather ungraceful manners. Since this website tends to thrive on some of the more unusual and bizarre cases of human history, I felt it appropriate to share some of the more shocking ends to some of the world’s greatest composers. Several of the names included are little known but have provided interesting subject matter, and I would like to point out that I have included several who had attempted suicide and/or spent their final years in asylums for the insane, as we can sufficiently argue that suicide is not a natural cause of death, and being committed to an asylum is not exactly the place many of us would hope to take our final breath. The list is in no particular order and musical examples are provided as available. I apologize that some of the musical examples are not the ones I would have preferred, but I had to go with what was available on YouTube, and unfortunately many of these are rather obscure composers, so there is not much to choose from.
Charles-Henri Valentin Alkan (born Charles-Henri Morhange) was one of the most prominent piano virtuosos of his time and of Jewish descent. He was highly talented and child prodigy, who was admitted to the Paris Conservatoire at the age of 6, won numerous awards during his youth and later developed close friendships with noted persons such as Frederic Chopin, Franz Liszt, George Sand, and Victor Hugo. Alkan was considered by his contemporaries to be one of the most masterful pianists and subsequently, he composed almost exclusively for the piano. He was also well known for being rather eccentric and hypersensitive. At the height of his performing career, several episodes including his failure to secure the position as head of the piano department at the Conservatoire and the death of Chopin pushed him into reclusion; he no longer performed and interacted little with society. He also spent much of his time studying the Bible and the Talmud and for many years, it was believed that his death occurred while reaching for a copy of the Talmud on a high bookshelf causing the shelf to topple and crush him under the weight of the books. This tale was recently been disproved upon the discovery of a contemporary letter from his concierge who said that he had found Alkan in his kitchen moaning under a coat rack (possibly from fainting, a stroke or heart attack) and then died later that night. He was 74 at the time of his death.
Another famous virtuoso of his time, Leclair was one of the most celebrated violinists in Europe during the 18th Century having composed one opera, 48 violin sonatas and an assortment of other chamber works. Leclair had remarried after his first wife prematurely passed away, however, the second marriage didn’t last and the couple separated in 1758. Leclair was forced to purchase a small apartment in an otherwise rough neighborhood of Paris and in 1764 he was found stabbed to death in his home. His death has always remained a mystery but it was believed that his estranged wife was somehow responsible for financial gain. His nephew, Guillaume-François Vial, was the primary suspect, but according to my research, was never arrested or put to trial.
Sticking with the Baroque era, Lully (born in Florence as Lulli) was Louis XIV’s favorite and main court composer. Lully was famous as a dancer, violinist and composer and composed numerous ballets, operas and even incidental music for Moliere’s comedies. He was the founder of French opera and responsible for determining the elements that would develop overtime to create Romantic French Grand Opera (for which Rossini is considered the founder with his opera Guillaume Tell) such as the inclusion of ballet music, faster plot development, an expanded orchestration than previously employed, and a revolutionary method of combining recitatives (the sung dialogue of opera where most of the action takes place) and arias (the main set pieces which served to showcase the singer and the character portrayed). Lully was also well known for his many sexual escapades with both men and women and there has been rumor for centuries of an illicit affair with the Sun King himself. In January 1687, Lully had been conducting a performance of his Te Deum in honor of Louis XIV’s recovery from illness where he inadvertently struck his foot with the pointed staff he had been using to keep time (this is long before batons were used to conduct). The wound became gangrenous and Lully refused to have the affected area amputated which ultimately led to his demise on 22 March of that year.
His life and death the subject of a great opera by Friedrich von Flotow, Alessandro Stradella was one of the great Italian composers of the early Baroque. A predecessor to the likes of Arcangelo Corelli and Antonio Vivaldi, he was a highly respected and famous composer of mostly operas, oratorios and cantatas as well as church chamber music during a time when the Vatican had outlawed secular musical dramas, namely opera. As a result, Stradella pioneered much in the oratorio and cantata genres, as setting Biblical subjects to music was not considered heretical or sinful. For all of his musical success, Stradella’s life had a darker side. In 1677 he was employed by a powerful Venetian nobleman to tutor his mistress. The two had a torrid affair and Stradella fled after it was exposed. The nobleman had hired several hit men to kill the great composer, but he managed to escape unharmed. He settled in Genoa where he continued to compose great works for the church and stage until yet another affair caught up to him. He was chased through the streets of Genoa by a hired assassin who did manage to catch up with him and brutally stabbed and murdered him.
While Beethoven’s hearing loss happened gradually overtime, Smetana lost his in a matter of a few weeks after suffering an awful tinnitus for years (he was subjected to an extremely high, unending pitch through most of his life). A highly talented and nationalistic Czech composer, Smetana is mostly famous for several operas, his enormous orchestral symphonic suite, Ma Vlast (My Country), and an array of chamber music, namely his first String Quartet “From my life” where each movement depicts a pivotal event from his life including the onset of his deafness. His music style was the first to really steep itself in Czech folk music, dance rhythms, myths and fairytales.
Smetana, like several other prominent Czech composers, had a very difficult time developing his reputation and fame and struggled against many intrigues from his opponents in Bohemian musical circles. Ultimately, his professional hardships and his deafness preyed on his mind and he began to suffer severe neurological illness. Family life was not easy either as 3 of his 4 children from his first marriage as well as his first wife had died by the time he was 35 years old. He did remarry and had two more children with his second wife. Smetana suffered a stroke-seizure in 1882 and was forbidden to compose any further. He ignored this and attempted to finish his last opera, but the strain on his mind drove him to a breakdown and he spent his last months in the Prague Insane Asylum where he died of a progressive paralysis, possibly caused by complications from syphilis.
A German eccentric known for his prolific song writing skills, Hugo Wolf led a very sad and disturbed life. He was a child prodigy having studied piano, violin and composition but whose rebellious nature, severe mood swings, and bouts of depression impeded his completion of his studies; he was constantly dismissed from the various musical institutions where he enrolled. He managed to survive through the financial backing of noted patrons who were swept away by his musical talents. He was most strongly influenced by the music and compositional language of Richard Wagner but was not inclined to compose large scale works and focused mainly on songs for voice and piano. He had a great passion for poetry and was determined to set many poems neglected by other composers. When he did use text previously set to music, it was because he felt that the other composer did not do the words justice. He made numerous enemies with his outspoken criticisms of other composer’s works he considered inferior such as Anton Rubenstein and Johannes Brahms, although, paradoxically, the time he served as a critic, he composed very little.
It was from 1888 to 1892 that Wolf was most productive as a composer, with an output of his most famous song cycles (the Mörike-Lieder, Eichendorff-Lieder, Goethe-Lieder, the Spanish and Italian Songbooks) and he began to receive high recognition for his talents. In early 1897, Wolf finally began to show signs of mental derangement, brought on mainly by syphilis, and eventually had to stop composing altogether. He attempted to drown himself before requesting admission to an insane asylum where he eventually died completely and utterly mindless. It’s also interesting to note that Wolf had an affair with the wife, Melanie, of his good friend and patron, Heinrich Köchert. The affair was exposed after time, but Heinrich remained Hugo’s friend. Melanie had visited him frequently during those last years, but she was so struck with grief over Wolf’s death and guilt for cheating on her husband that she committed suicide in 1906.
The composer of the famous and beloved Poème for Violin and Orchestra as well as many songs and orchestral works, met his end from a freak accident. Chausson came from a very wealthy family and originally pursued a career in law, but he was unhappy and eventually turned to music when he was 25 years old. He began his studies with the great Jules Massenet at the Paris Conservatoire and eventually his music evolved into very dramatic, poetic and psychologically emotional pieces drawing much inspiration from Richard Wagner, Johannes Brahms, and César Franck. He is credited for being the first composer to use the Celeste in an orchestral setting (made most famous by Tchaikovsky’s “Dance of the Sugarplum Fairy” in The Nutcracker ballet). He was not the most prolific of composers, but his music is still regularly performed today. He held the position as secretary of the Société Nationale de Musique and became friends with the majority of the Paris musical and artistic elite. He also had an affinity for Russian literature and French Impressionistic artwork. At the age of 44, Chausson was out for a bicycle ride outside his property in Limay when he lost control of the bike on a downhill slope and crashed into a brick will. He died instantly.
The most famous and recognizable composer on this list, Tchaikovsky was a Russian composer whose music still pervades our lives today. Constantly faced with exposure of his homosexuality, he tried to force himself into very unhappy relationships with women and even married, but the couple separated without divorce after short time. In 1877, he came into contact with a devoted fan, Nadezhda von Meck, a very wealthy widow who would become his patron and, in a way, soul mate; however she insisted that the two never meet face to face. They embarked on a remarkable journey together, exchanging over 1000 letters that have provided great insight into the personality and the emotional tribulations of this great man until she finally severed their correspondence claiming bankruptcy in 1890. This was devastating to him as she provided emotional and financial stability for him.
After several years of traveling around Europe and composing, Tchaikovsky mysteriously died a mere 9 days after the premiere of his 6th Symphony, the Pathétique, which is a highly personal and autobiographic work. The circumstances of Tchaikovsky’s death remain a mystery. It was believed for many years that he died of cholera and there were over 8 completely different “eyewitness” reports of him taking that “fateful sip of un-boiled water.” It is believed that Tchaikovsky may have had an illicit relationship with a young nobleman/royal he was tutoring at the time and several alumni from the School of Jurisprudence held a Court of Honor to discuss the punishment options of which two were proposed: exile from Russia (something Tchaikovsky could not bear) or suicide with a cover-up. It’s more widely accepted that to protect both his and the school’s reputations, Tchaikovsky was forced to commit suicide. Unfortunately, the exact circumstances around his death will never be truly known.
Most famous for his piano suite, Goyescas, and his opera of the same name, Enrique Granados was a Spanish nationalistic composer who sought to captivate not only the flavor and culture of Spain into his music, but was also heavily influenced by the paintings of Francisco Goya (whom he also modeled his painting style after). He led a rather successful life that ended tragically. His opera’s premiere was canceled in Europe due to the outbreak of WWI and subsequently received its premiere at the Metropolitan Opera in New York City where it had a huge success. He was invited to give a piano recital at the White House by President Woodrow Wilson, but in doing so, he and his wife missed the boat back to Spain. Instead, they took a boat to England where they boarded the French ferry Sussex to take them to France.
On March 24, 1916, while crossing the English Channel, the Sussex was victim to a German U-boat torpedo. Granados, despite a life-long fear of water, drowned after he jumped out of his lifeboat in a futile attempt to save his wife, Amparo, who also drowned. Ironically, the area of the boat where his cabin was located did not sink and the passengers in that part of the boat survived the attack.
This very influential and important Austrian serial composer lost his life in a very unfortunate manner. Webern studied with Arnold Shoenberg at Vienna University where he also met Alban Berg. These three composers were responsible for creating a mathematically-based musical compositional language and style known as Serialism, or the 12-Tone Technique. There are 12 tones in the Western Musical scale and so the basic foundation of this compositional style was to use all 12 tones of the chromatic scale in various permutations to create subversive atonal atmospheres. Of the 3, Webern took Serialism the furthest into what is known as Total Serialism, and his music is still not well-received by many today.
At first he was privately outspoken against the Nazi party, who had called his music “degenerate” but after the advent of WWII became a supporter of Adolph Hitler. He continued to struggle to earn his living as a composer as his music was considered far too radical to be enjoyed. He had moved to Salzburg towards the end of the war to ensure his safety. In an effort to not wake his sleeping grandchildren, Webern left his house to enjoy a cigar, oblivious that a curfew had been established by the Allied occupying forces, when he was shot dead by an American soldier who saw him light the cigar. Webern was 61 when killed on 15 September 1945. The soldier who shot him was so distraught after the event that he turned to the bottle and died of alcoholism 10 years later.
For those who have seen the movie Amadeus, they might be thinking they know all about this guy. How he worked Mozart to death and was sent to an insane asylum to pay for his nefarious deeds. Well, the Salieri portrayed in the play/movie isn’t anything like what we know of Salieri the man. A highly prolific composer, Salieri was one of the most famous and well-respected musicians and teachers of his time. He composed over 50 operas, numerous sacred works, concertos, sonatas, chamber music, and over 100 arias and scenes that were inserted into other composer’s operas. He enjoyed enormous success throughout Europe and held his position as Royal and Imperial Kapellmeister for 36 years in the Viennese court. He was also one of the most sought-after teachers in harmony, counterpoint, and prosody and some of his more notable students included Ludwig van Beethoven, Franz Liszt, Carl Czerny, Franz Schubert, Giacomo Meyerbeer, and Franz Xaver Süssmayr (the real man who completed Mozart’s Requiem, not Salieri).
There is little evidence to support the infamous feud between Salieri and Mozart. The two men were quite collegial with each other and, in fact, Mozart left his children in Salieri’s custody upon his death. Salieri even tutored Mozart’s son Franz Xaver, and Salieri had done all he could to help Mozart’s widow clear away her debts and made sure she lived comfortably until she remarried. It should also be noted that the two composers wrote a cantata (now lost) together that was published and Salieri had even conducted some of Mozart’s pieces after securing performance venues for them.











May 22nd, 2009 at 1:13 am
This sort of morbid, but interesting!
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:37 am
disturbing.. BUT a great List!!!
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:38 am
Have we not had list before ?
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:44 am
So, how did Salieri die ?
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:45 am
I’m glad I’m not a composer. Not a heavenly way to die…
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:47 am
4 Ernest Chausson, he crashed on a brick wall? there’s a typo but, common sense..
Wow, Why should the Greats Die so… Weird and some in just a snap!
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:47 am
HOt tamales list amigo! HA! and they say driving a motorcycle is dangerous!
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:48 am
caliente tamales list amigo! HA! and they say driving a motorcycle is dangerous!
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:51 am
number three cause of death is common..i think..
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:52 am
Smurff: listverse had lists with odd deaths but this list only focuses on composers. Great Lists huh.
Muzli: yeah i didn’t saw any deaths on the info. I think it’s just about the Guy’s contribution.
May 22nd, 2009 at 1:58 am
If I only had the power to make the dead come back to life(not to be a zombie).This people will be the first
May 22nd, 2009 at 2:19 am
I’m trying to understand this. A guy cycling downhill, crashing into a wall. Couldn’t he have jumped off the bike instead? What on earth was he doin’ goin’ downhill at that pace neway!!! Could it possibly have been suicide, and if so, would have been a really novel way to go. I’m still thinkin’ here…
May 22nd, 2009 at 2:30 am
Seems that the deaded syph had a lot to do with it!
May 22nd, 2009 at 2:46 am
Alexander Scriabin (transliterated in various ways) either cut himself shaving or had a boil on his lip, but either way scratched it until it became skeptic and he died of blood poisoning.
Isaac Nathan, regarded as Australia’s first “classical” composer, fell under a horse-drawn tram in Sydney.
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:05 am
astraya wow I didn’t know that about Scriabin! He wrote some fantastic music. As for the Aussie composer – the “first”? Is there even one famous outside Aussie? I thought you guys were as destitute as us when it came to good classical music
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:13 am
I guess it’s bad that all I could think of while reading the bonus was the Simpsons episode with Bart & Lisa as Mozart & Salieri…
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:14 am
& Nelson as Beethoven of course.
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:37 am
joe mama: A reference to Morrissey?
Also, great list- I learned a lot. Enrique Granados’ death is so romantically tragic. All of them were tragic, but his story resonated with me the most- maybe because I just went through a breakup.
I never knew that Mozart and Salieri composed together. It is too bad we don’t still have the piece. I’m sure it would have been fascinating.
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:54 am
jf: I’ve never played any of Scriabin’s music. He gets trotted out at the Sydney International Piano Competition once every four years, second only to Chopin, it seems.
I move on the fringes of the classical music scene in Australia, so I could list many who are known to some extent in Australia, but I don’t know how many of them have any sort of profile overseas. The best resource for Australian “modern classical” music is http://www.australianmusiccentre.com.au/ I have a page there, but it’s pretty basic. Have you performed the songs I sent you way back? Have you looked at the songs I sent you way back. wikipedia has a list of over 100 Australian composers. I’m not on it (yet).
The only NZ composer I could name off the top of my head is Clare McLean, but only because she moved to Australia!
May 22nd, 2009 at 4:44 am
Great list, really enjoyed it.
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:21 am
Cool list this morning. I only knew of Lully and Tchaikovsky. Of course I have almost all of Tchaikovsky’s work on my ipod. I will be adding a few others from this list as well.
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:34 am
Wow! Murder, syphilis and suicide. Those guys really lived on the edge.
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:35 am
Great list, I like the ones where I learn about something I don’t know a lot about, or common misconceptions that are corrected.
Although I do have two criticisms with this one:
I tried searching for information on Antonio Salieri’s death. The only thing I’m finding is that he suffered a physical and mental breakdown. I’m not sure he really fits this list.
#10, Charles-Henri Valentin Alkan if he actually died of a stroke or heart attack, doesn’t seem to fit either.
May 22nd, 2009 at 6:05 am
I’ve always loved Smetana’s, Ma Vlast, but didn’t know he suffered from tinnitus or went deaf suddenly.
I’ve suffered from tinnitus for twenty-some years (After standing WAY too close to the speakers at a heavy metal concert) and wonder if deafness is in my future…
May 22nd, 2009 at 6:08 am
I teach college Music Appreciation, and some of these that I didn’t know are going straight into my lesson plans. Thanks!
I’m still not convinced about that Tchaikovsky death, though. Although he was ashamed of his homosexuality, I find it hard to believe that it took him that long to finally kill himself over it.
Great list!
May 22nd, 2009 at 6:41 am
I’m impressed that you did not only mentioned Bedřich Smetana, but wrote his name correctly. Most english speaking people wouldn’t have bothered with “ř” or in fact any diacritic.
May 22nd, 2009 at 7:33 am
Mozart?
May 22nd, 2009 at 8:23 am
Hey! I was getting ready to do the same list! Good job, though, and thanks for saving me the trouble.
That said, I don’t agree with the revisionist view of Tchaikovsky’s death. While it’s beyond doubt that he killed himself, it’s a real stretch to say that his alma mater forced one of the biggest musical superstars of the day to commit suicide, especially after so many years.
You came up with some I hadn’t found yet, but you missed my two favorites:
1. Johann Schobert (?-1767)
Johann Schobert was a German composer and clavichordist. His date and place of birth are disputed. Some sources say he was born in 1735 in Schlesien, Austria;[1] others have him from Silesia, as suggested by Friedrich Melchior von Grimm, or from Nuremberg, as claimed by Christian Schubart in his autobiography. The date of Schobert’s birth is given variously as about 1720, about 1735, or about 1740.
In 1760, Schobert moved to Paris where he served in the household of Louis François I de Bourbon, prince de Conti. He composed many books of sonatas for his instrument, most of them with an accompanying part for one or more other instruments. Schobert also wrote harpsichord concertos, symphonies and the opéra comique Le Garde-Chasse et le Braconnier.
In Paris, Schobert came in contact with Leopold Mozart. Reportedly, Schobert was offended by Mozart’s comments that his children played Schobert’s works with ease.Nevertheless, Schobert was a significant influence on the young Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, who arranged a number of movements from Schobert’s sonatas for use in his own piano concertos.
One fine day in 1767 (obviously) Schobert, according to the historical account, had gathered some mushrooms in Pré-Saint-Gervais near Paris with his family and proceeded to a restaurant to have the chef prepare them. When he was told that they were poisonous, he proceeded to a second restaurant with like result. Undeterred, he went home to Paris and made mushroom soup for dinner. He was joined in death by his wife, one of his children, and a friend, a doctor; fittingly, it was the doctor who had made the mushroom identification in the first place.
2. Anton Fils (1733-1760)
An early Mannheim symphonist, Fils is said to have died from his habit of eating spiders, which he claimed tasted like strawberries.
May 22nd, 2009 at 8:31 am
Really cool this today! And not controversial for a change!
I´ll admit my ignorance and say that I only knew Tchaikovsky and Salieri. I´m guessing this is nothing out of the ordinary, but I have loved The Nutcracker since I was a little kid. My husband, on the other hand, cannot stand it. His sister is a professional ballerina so he´s had to see the darn thing more times than he cares to remember!
Oh, and the story of Enrique Granados is so romantically tragic…
May 22nd, 2009 at 8:45 am
Yo I am working on an awesome new list. It will be tits
May 22nd, 2009 at 9:16 am
Anton Fils died from eating spiders? Unfortunate lmao
May 22nd, 2009 at 9:34 am
Thanks to Jaime for posting my list.
I did include further information about several of the composers like Salieri, but they seem to have been shortened, understandably as I did go on at length about them. My point in including Salieri as a Bonus is that the (false) rumors of his being responsible for Mozart’s death had begun already during his lifetime and it ultimately sent him to the insane asylum and the man’s name and reputation have existed in infamy ever since. So rather than just a tragic demise, he has been considered a musical villain for over 150 years…and it’s completely unjustified!
May 22nd, 2009 at 10:34 am
Great list. Enjoyed it, apart from the bit about the American soldier who was so riddled with guilt he became an alcoholic and drove himself to death…10 years later. 1) I suspect the soldier had shot a few people previous to this one. 2) When riddled with guilt (ahem) I would rather kill myself nice and quick, not turn to booze, and a decade later, blame my own personal demise on the pesky drink and the terrible things I was forced to do as a soldier. If he felt that bad he wouldn’t have pulled trigger.
Other than that, nice list
May 22nd, 2009 at 10:40 am
General # 30 Im A WAITING WITH ABATED BREATH
erikap # 10 thanks for pointing that out
May 22nd, 2009 at 11:28 am
Gotta love me some culture in the morning. I actually appreciate the music more than the stories. These are not pieces I would ordinarily be exposed to – Great Job! I am certain that I recognize the von Webern piece; it has to have been used as part of a movie score more than once.
May 22nd, 2009 at 11:41 am
So many of the great composers died tragic deaths. This list could easily have been the Top 25, instead of the Top 10. Still, a great list. Congratulations, and thank you for the links.
I will send this to my flutist/rugby player daughter. I’m sure she’ll get a kick out of it.
May 22nd, 2009 at 12:57 pm
Interesting list, and I had never heard of most of them. I think though, that out of all the classical composers in history, it would not be hard to find 10 (or more) unusual deaths. This is true in any group. Like the list of rock and roll stars that died in airplanes. They probably travel in planes more than other people, so I would expect more accidents.
Also, in centuries past, people died of things that are easily curable today. Like the guy that stabbed his foot and it turned septic. These deaths would not raise an eyebrow if they were not famous.
May 22nd, 2009 at 3:54 pm
Mozart didn’t die an unusual death. HC Robbins Landon devotes a whole chapter of his book “1791 – Mozart’s last year” to Mozart’s health. The only question I had after reading that was “Why didn’t Mozart die a lot earlier?”. His health had been fragile pretty much all his life. Legend has loomed larger than fact here, thanks to Salieri, Pushkin and Shaeffer.
May 22nd, 2009 at 4:00 pm
Useless knowledge is only fun if you can tell it to a group of people and they think your funny, interesting and intelligent…… This list is the kind of useless knowledge that when you tell it to said group, that group makes up poorly thought out excuses to avoid you…forever.
FYI
May 22nd, 2009 at 4:18 pm
Oh NOeeessss: There is room for all types of knowledge – musical knowledge included. It is very arrogant to dismiss classical music as uninteresting and unintelligent. A well rounded person will seem much more intelligent than one who scoffs at someone’s interest in the arts. Oh – and you forgot an apostrophe in “think your funny”. This list might help (item 3)
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:01 pm
Those crazy people from the olden days writing their wills on bricks…
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:05 pm
Oh NOeeessss:
your friends suck.
May 22nd, 2009 at 5:15 pm
ChevalierDupin – Sorry about the criticism. It is interesting to realize that Salieri was unfairly thought to be a villain all this time, and that could have contributed to his mental and physical illnesses and ultimately his death. I guess that qualifies him for this list.
So often, as in Amadeus, movie makers seem to feel they have to have a villain. They either invent one or exaggerate a character for that tension and conflict they like to have.
May 22nd, 2009 at 6:37 pm
I like this list! What about Schumann? I wrote a huge paper all about him for music history a couple of semesters ago. Oh, and my cat’s name is Tchaikovsky…
He’s cool.
May 22nd, 2009 at 8:38 pm
One only dies once… why not hope for a interesting way, or at least one worth mention? I don’t expect my compositions or myself to become famous, but I’d hate it very much to die in a boring way.
May 22nd, 2009 at 8:41 pm
Hm, just read Oh NOeessss’s ignorant comments… having trained in classical music, I am offended. =[ Why can’t you see past your own nose, dear child?
May 22nd, 2009 at 9:19 pm
Rosa, I considered Schumann for the list, and perhaps at some point I might compile a follow-up list to include some of the other individuals, but I felt that Wolf having requested admission to the asylum was more unusual than when someone is just admitted to one against their will or without them realizing it.
Moonbeam, I included Alkan on the list because the story of the bookshelf falling on him was legendary and was only disproved recently, which I mentioned…and because I love his music!
Astraya, I did not include Scriabin because although it is arguably unusual, I didn’t think it to be as interesting as the ones listed here, but he certainly could have been mentioned.
Warrrreagl, if I am reading your comment correctly, you seem to be suggesting that Tchaikovsky should have committed suicide much earlier in life if he had been unhappy with his homosexuality? It seems a rather unfair assessment and a cruel generalization that if someone is unhappy or struggles with an aspect of their being (such as homosexuality) that therefore they should end their lives to end the alleged suffering. We cannot ever truly know what exactly happened to Tchaikovsky, but we can infer with confidence that he did not die of cholera and that something more sinister was at work. He was a man of great honor and dignity, and although in the modern world, ideals of family and professional honor have diminished greatly from the standards of generations past, one should attempt to be more compassionate of his situation. Homosexuality is still very taboo in Russian culture and a century ago it was even less tolerable. For a national figure such as Tchaikovsky to have been openly homosexual and to have (allegedly) made romantic or sexual overtures towards a member of the noble class would have been seen as a grave offense. It has been suggested by historians and several cohesive eye- and ear-witness accounts of the said “Court of Honor” (including a woman whose husband confided in her the details of the meeting which she later revealed in an interview many years following her husband’s death and shortly before her own) that Tchaikovsky was given those two options to avoid tarnishing his name, the reputation of the School of Jurisprudence (of which he was a graduate), and his national honor as being one of the most important and respected composers in all of Russian history. We know from his letters and writings and various contemporary accounts that Tchaikovsky was always depressed and miserable when away from Russia and therefore permanent exile could have been seen as worse than death. Whether it was officially suicide is unknown, but it may very well have been assisted, even perhaps by his own brother, Modest, who is primarily responsible for the cover-up story of cholera.
May 23rd, 2009 at 8:51 am
Thank you ChevalierDupin for responding to my comment. It is interesting how those stories like the one about (list #1) Charles-Henri Valentin Alkan take on a life of their own and are believed to be the truth for ever after. I see now why he was included.
Comment #33 from Not a Drunk refers to an American soldier who drank himself to death over guilt from accidentally killing Anton von Webern. I know that often alcoholics are reported as having been driven to drink over guilt, some tragedy, or an especially difficult childhood. I imagine ChevalierDupin is relaying the information as it would be in historical records. A friend of mine who is in a 12 step program tells me that he believes that he had a propensity for addiction, and used the facts of his childhood as a justification for continued abuse of alcohol. Not being an addiction expert myself, I wonder if both thing are true. Maybe the seeds of addiction were present and the guilt fueled the fire. I know I’m pretty far off the original topic, but any way … just a thought.
May 23rd, 2009 at 3:51 pm
So how did Mahler die?
May 23rd, 2009 at 4:30 pm
According to my Dictionary of Great Composers, Gustave Mahler, perhaps my favorite of the late romantic composers, died of a streptococcal blood infection.
His last word was “Mozartl” which is a pet name, a diminutive for Mozart, meaning, approximately “dear, sweet, little Mozart”.
May 23rd, 2009 at 6:25 pm
Here is a good performance of Tchaikovsky’s 4th symphony
May 24th, 2009 at 12:45 pm
That was one of the better lists I’ve read recently. Thanks for including the music as well.
I knew about number 8. I also knew that Salieri and Mozart were not enemies. I always thought that they would both be highly amused by “Amadeus.”
May 26th, 2009 at 3:05 am
Sussmayer (?spelling) is probably pissed off completely at being left out of the Amadeus story. Ignored by posterity then left out of the play and movie.
May 26th, 2009 at 5:09 am
Since this is a list about composers dying odd deaths, should we assume that Salieri also died an uncommon death, lest why would he be mentioned as a bonus?
These list are getting really specific. Whats next? Top 10 left-handed musicians who were born out of wedlock and played in bands comprising of less than 4 individuals and had more than 10 chart topping hits and may have done drugs and trashed their hotel rooms…
May 26th, 2009 at 5:20 am
54. Tomo : “Another 10 Fascinating Facts That Are Wrong” – May 23rd
Rather specific I agree, hey Jamie, let’s get some ambiguity here!
May 27th, 2009 at 1:32 pm
54. Tomo — please see my comment number 32. Salieri is not “on” the list, he is a bonus and I explain why I put him here.
May 30th, 2009 at 7:58 am
How could you miss gershwin? brain tumor and death in the 30’s of a genius composer…
June 2nd, 2009 at 11:31 am
What an interesting historical view of classical music!
Goes to show the politics and juicy events that have formed classical music.
June 15th, 2009 at 10:52 am
I’m actually very glad to read that the movie Amadeus had it wrong. It’s good to know that they were at least cordial, and that Salieri was not the manipulating jerk that the movie portrayed him to be. I guess he just got a bad rap.
June 28th, 2009 at 4:40 pm
Techniclly, a classical composer was one who composed between 1750 and 1827…Sorry, it’s a pet-peeve.
August 24th, 2009 at 2:44 am
whats the fuck where the is amadeus mozart you must be just as sick as some of the composers up here because he should be in place number 1
November 21st, 2009 at 1:27 am
Claude Vivier was murdered by a male prostitute…