The following list compiles ten of the best documentary films relating to the United States, released in the last 25 years. The documentaries here are shown in no particular order. Be sure to add your own favorites to the comments.
This 9 episode epic chronicles the U.S. Civil War which took place from 1861-1865. Extremely well crafted, it includes an original theme ‘Ashokan Farewell’ that will haunt you long after the final chapter. It includes narration by some of the finest actors and academics of the last half century including Sam Waterston, Arthur Miller, and Shelby Foote. This documentary also featured on our previous list: Top 10 Greatest TV Documentary Series.
Darryl Hunt is a man from Winston-Salem, N.C. who was wrongly convicted of the rape and murder of a young white woman in 1984. A shocking indictment of the criminal justice system in the U.S., the film shows how a lack of physical evidence, faulty eyewitness testimony, and racism can overcome the search for actual truth. Did I mention he was falsely convicted…twice!
Yes, it is more propaganda by possibly the most polarizing fimmaker since Leni Riefenstahl, but Sicko hits all the right notes. Focusing on the state of the U.S. healthcare system, the film interviews former insurance claim agents, victims of insurance company negligence, and foreign healthcare workers. In the most inspired moment Mr. Moore takes uninsured Americans to Guantanamo Bay where they are refused entry, then to Cuba where they are helped free of charge.
Tony Kaye’s first film since the unrelenting American History X, Lake of Fire is a 2 1/2 hour pontification on the abortion issue in America. Interviewees include noted anarchist Noam Chomsky and lawyer Alan Dershowitz. Extremely unsettling in its portrayal of the two sides of this issue, it leads one to believe that there is no middle ground.
Full titled: “Paradise Lost (The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills)”, Paradise Lost recounts the trials of 3 teenage boys for multiple counts of murder in Arkansas. In hoping that my less is more approach will encourage readers to watch these films, I will keep spoilers minimal as there are many twists and turns. But let it be said, a bloody knife as a gift is not normal, even in Arkansas (kidding).
Virtually the antithesis to the other noted Iraqi war documentary Farenheit 911, No End in Sight takes a more evenhanded approach at American involvement in Iraq. Legitimacy is added by the fact that many of the interviewees are former George Bush Jr. staff members who reveal the crucial initial mistakes that they and others had made. This caused what many thought would be a quick and clean military exercise into an eight years and counting war. Heartbreaking in its candor.
The Staircase is an eight part documentary series that began filming initially with the indictment of its protagonist Michael Peterson. He was an author living in North Carolina when his wife died of injuries related to a fall down a flight of stairs at the home. Honestly, not even the best scriptwriter could come up with the revelations that followed in the police investigation and eventual trial. If you like true crime dramas watch this film.
“Indian Point: Imagining the Unimaginable” is a nuclear power plant that has drawn quite a bit of attention since the 9/11 attacks due to its lack of security. There is not a ‘no-fly zone’ required for the air space above it, safety violations have been common, and the security officers are undertrained. At least it is not within spitting distance of one of the biggest cities in the world, right? Well, no. It is located just 35 miles from New York City. Fascinating. This documentary was made by Rory Kennedy (pictured above), youngest daughter of Bobby Kennedy.
Capturing the Friedmans is proof positive that truth is stranger than fiction. Simply stated, it tells the story of Great Neck, New York family man Arnold Friedman who taught computer classes in his basement to local children. After child pornography is delivered to his house during an FBI sting, he is indicted for mulitple counts of child sexual abuse. Along with The Staircase, this film causes the rug to be pulled out from beneath the viewer the most, truly amazing. One fact to note is that the director had initially planned to make a film about the relatively normal brother to Jesse and son of Arnold, David Friedman who is a clown for hire in New York City.
A true master of his craft, Ken Burns The War was his latest directorial effort. It chronicled World War II and premiered on PBS in the U.S. in 2007. Due to the enormous scope of the war, its causes, and the aftermath, the director decided to focus on segments of troops from 4 American cities and followed them to the conclusion of the war through all three major theaters. The all-star cast of narrators includes Tom Hanks, Adam Arkin, Ernie Hudson, and Keith David.






















Average list…Paradise lost and the staircase seem interesting though
america home of the brave indigenous holocaust and the home of the slaves
very interesting list.
But i guess the last few lists are hard to beat. I like your lists the best usually JFrater
Oh man I haven’t seen any of these.
#2 reminds of the police delivering a package of ***** to the mayor of Berwyn Heights, Maryland. Later that night, they invaded the house, shot the dogs, and tried to frame the mayor and his wife of drug *****. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/07/AR2008080702161.html
I like the list. I enjoy a good documentary every now and then.
“I Like Killing Flies” Is another documentary about a New York restaurant owner Kenny Shopsin who recently fell into mild celebrity after a lifetime of personal isolationism. Really great filming about a crotchety old man who spends his time cooking and waxing philosophic.
I dunno, thought I would mention it since, having watched it, I’ve become a huge fan of Shopsin’s. He’s a neat character.
No Frederick Wiseman? Don’t like this.
Great list; I’m finally in the top 10′s, I hope.
Nice list. 9 is interesting… 6 would probably freak me out.
boring list
Am I to understand from #6 that I could give bloody knives as gifts to people in Arkansas and not raise eyebrows because you are kidding about them not being normal?
I’ve seen a few american documentaries here in the UK but to be honest none of them can touch the British documentary makers in this area.
not so good list, one notable exception must be The Fog of War, a truly masterpiece of a documentary.
amazing oversight.
my favorite documentary, which is about america in some ways, is murder ball.
if you have seen it, you know the emotional range it covers, the amazing subject matter and the wonderful characters you meet.
if you haven’t seen it, i’ve got two words for you…quadrapalegic rugby. that’s right, kiddos. full contact rugby by guys in wheel chairs.
Taxi to The Dark Side
How can people comment that these lists are “average” or “OK”? Be thankful that someone else is doing the research and jfrater is publishing this little slice of internet goodness.
Just leave a comment, no need to give your personal rating.
Better yet, submit your own list.
“Brother’s Keeper” was great too.
Poor list…
I recommend Dear Zachary.
it’s guaranteed you’ll be balling your eyes out by the end of it.
well said teacherman (17):
Let me guess that this will be far less controversial that the Michael Jackson list. I haven’t seen any of these. I know that Civil War was shown on Australian TV, and Sicko is the only other one I’ve heard of. British documentaries, especially from the BBC, get shown far more often in Australia.
I thought ‘Hoop Dreams’ (1994) by Steve James would be on the list. It had the most appearance in Critic’s top film list in 1994, and some critics favor it better than Forrest Gump. Even though it earned no Oscar nomination, this film is considered as one of greatest documentary ( Wikipedia). It won awards in Sundance, Peabody, etc. It was a great American documentary..
Interesting list; however, you left out probably one of the most important documentaries ever made. “Grey Gardens” (1975) was not only groundbreaking in narrative and style, but it radically changed the direction of documentaries – taking it from a more “educational” perspective to a personal interaction. For those of you who have never heard of it, the film documents “a day in the life” of Jackie Onassis’ delusional aunt and cousin. Also, another great documentary would be “Marjoe” (1972).
Christian Eriksson
I guess I would have to take back my previous comment. I didn’t see the 25 year mark. Sorry about that, but you should still watch those two documentaries – really, you should.
Christian Eriksson
I haven’t seen any of these only because they have not interested me. I am not into “real life” or “life-like” type shows, movies or books. However, I just might change my mind now reading this list. Sicko seems to be the most interesting to me.
On the other hand, I prefer Walking with Dinosaurs.
no errol morris? and where’s the hilarious ‘american movie’?
BOWLING FOR COLIMBINE BY MICHAEL MOORE IS REALLY GOOD. YALL SHOULD CHECK IT OUT (IM SORRY THIS IS IN CAPS I CANT GET MY BOTTON UNSTUCK)
Only seen one of them – Im not sure if it was on the hallmark or history channel.
#2 NoE is that a verse from Immortal Technique?
“Drunk in Public” released in 2006 director-David Sperling.
Sobering look at one man’s(Mark David Allen) struggle with substance abuse. Pretty disheartening.
“Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room” realeased 2005 director-Alex Gibney.
A look at how top executives and traders at Enron manipulated the California energy crisis, “earned” billions in stock options, then left their employees holding an empty bag of dreams. The first of many similar business failures in the U.S. economic “house of cards”.
BTW, liked the list. Agree with ‘teacherman’. If ya don’t like it, wait 24 hrs.
Interesting list. Except for Staircase and Capturing the Friedman’s I saw all the others
The 9-part ‘Baseball’ by Ken Burns was brilliantly researched and could be enjoyed even by the most rabid baseball hater. Worth a watch by any sports fan.
Interesting list!!! I like the look of 10, 6 and 1. I’m a stickler for a good World War II documentary, we had a good one here in England ( dunno if it was shown in all of Britain) called World At War. It was fab. Also, it might sound morbid but I like the documentaries about the murderers and massacres and how they are brought to justice!!!
cool… sounds like more to see on the holidays!
Average list. These must be the writers favorites because there are so many more recognized and influential docs he could have listed. Just to name a few: Hoop Dreams, Fahrenheit 911, Aileen Wuornos: The Selling of a Serial Killer, Eyes on the Prize. Even the sequel doc to Paradise Lost was better than the original. Good try though.
Not sure if this is a documentary but, the Zeitgeist
Good list! I saw a few of these. Ken Burns Civil War is a masterpiece, as is his doc on Jazz. But some of these are so heavy and depressing. I prefer a little lighter subjects. Check out American Movie (about a hopeful but hopeless midwest filmmaker) and Crumb (the bizarre life of cartoonist R. Crumb from director Terry Zwigoff who later did the great movie Ghost World).
Capturing the Friedmans is a good one. I heartily suggest you rent the extended version with an extra DVD of footage… to this day I have no idea what the truth might be…
Also interesting:
Who Killed The Electric Car?
I’m sorry, but “Sicko” is trash. Propaganda is right. Moore had me sold with both Roger & Me and Bowling for Columbine, but since he’s gone every bit as whacko and one-sided as the right wing airbags on Fox News.
-The Canadian folks he interviewed in depth about the Canadian healthcare system were his 2nd degree relations. This man is a internationally-renowned filmmaker, and he couldn’t find anyone in an entire country to interview that wasn’t his own family?
-Guantanamo Bay Naval Station is a restricted military installation, even for people without bullhorns and camera crews.
-The VAST majority of people interviewed for this movie were white, middle-to-upper class working people. We don’t really get to talk to immigrants, the indigent or the otherwise marginalized to see if they have any different experiences.
-He used the story of a little deaf girl being denied 2 cochlear implants as an example of gross malfeasance by the insurance industry. He didn’t bother to mention that having only 1 cochlear implant (which WAS covered by her insurance) is the standard of care, nor the fact that giving cochlear implants to children that young at all is ethically debated.
-Hotly criticizes the US government, and yet is gunning hard for universal health care. Who exactly does he think would be running a universalized health care system?
Again, sorry for the rant – I certainly agree that the US health care system is broken, but that movie is not helpful. He’s got a right to make whatever kind of movie he wants…but he doesn’t get to advertise it as the truth.
All in all a neat list! I’m especially interested in the Staircase – looks juicy. One I’d recommend is “A Family Undertaking” about the funeral industry and home funerals – fantastic. Thanks!
-Interesting NOT to see any Errol Morris or Frederick Wiseman docs in your 10pick.
A favorite of mine would be “The True Meaning of Pictures: Shelby Lee Adam’s Appalachia” directed by Jennifer Baichwal.
Another favorite, I always preferred “Brother’s Keeper” by Berlinger and Sinofsky, than “Paradise Lost”.
A relatively obscure one (which just falls into the 25year bracket) is the 1984 documentary by Martin Bell, “StreetWise”.
I agree with #26, American Movie. Also this list loses credibility by including a Michael Moore movie. That clown does NOT make documentaries, he makes entertaining(to some) movies. Not to mention most of information that he uses have all been proven as false or incomplete.
By the way, no Morris or Wiseman here makes little sense. Wise for one is highly regarded as one of the top documentary directors ever.
I would be interested as to why you didn’t include either of them.
correction: Wise=Wiseman
was expecting more of Michael Moore’s work and maybe even Super Size Me. interesting list tho
Nice list.
I loved Ken Burns’ Baseball (although being huge baseball fan I suppose I’m probably biased lol). I do have to agree with Jstar about Michael Moore, though. He’s not a documentary maker – he’s a sensationalist, through and through.
For everyone who can only say they hated the list – go submit one of your own.
Waco: The Rules of Engagement is a fascinating look inside the Branch Davidian compound at Mt. Carmel. It may turn a few heads.
“Hoop Dreams” and “Crumb” have been mentioned already and should be on the list; but the biggest omission by far is “The Thin Blue Line”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fog_of_War Academy Award winning doc. McNamara from WW2 to Vietnam with music by Philip Glass.
The Trials of Daryl Hunt looks very interesting.
With regards to Daryl Hunt, he killed a man prior to the rape accusation and got away with it. He was also involved in a lot of other crimes and served time prior.
His conviction was similar to sending OJ up the creek for entering a nhotel room, everyone knew he had murdered and got away with it previously. An angel he is not.
Band of Brothers was a really well made documentary of WWII, i was dissapointed to not see it on the list.
I need to see ALL of these… great… well thats what Netflix is for
supersize me!
What, no “The Corporation”?
Awesome list – you guys who want something less thoughtful can always go check out Ebaums.
I’ve seen some of these – I love public television – but there are some new ones that I must see. I’m looking for the Peterson one and the Friedman one as we speak.
I am disappointed that you missed the PBS Frontline documentary Bush’s War. Absolutely fascinating and thorough. Covers the legal justification, shows how top members of gov’t (Condie Rice and Colin Powell) were misled. Goes into depth about the shadow intelligence service Bush set up when the CIA didn’t provide him with the information he required to begin the war. Considering there are still citizens who believe the WMD lie and that Iraq was a hotbed of al qaeda – it should be required watching.
Why we fight is a great documentary…no Hoop dreams?
Good list. I’ve seen 8 of the 10 listed.
Anything by Ken Burns is wonderful. Loved his Jazz movie and the baseball one as well.
I’d also recommend “Best Boy” by Ira Wohl, documenting his mentally handicapped cousin, Philly. It’s sweet and heartwrenching
Cheers from Vermont USA, where apparently it’s monsoon season.
You mentioned Michael Moore and lost all credibility. Not only is he the maker of the most terrible propoganda since World War I, he also happens to be the single worst person to ever live. ever.